Teams SC 2015 - My team (During NAB)

[thetradesman]

I just think they will job share. Did you see the Sydney Brisbane match? Martin looked great, carrying on from 2014. Luey spent a fair bit of time forward where he rucked well setting up f50 chances but didn't have much of an impact as pure forward.

Didn't see that game, Did berger get a decent supercoach score though?

 

[anfa18]

Didn't see that game, Did berger get a decent supercoach score though?

Berger scored 44

 

[thetradesman]

Berger scored 44

Ouch, doesn't fill me with confidence.

I'll wait and see what happens.

 

[gcsunsfc]

Shepphard and Wallis, could be nice POD's (I have my doubts though). With our lack of midfield depth he may not have his tagging role so much, he's still a big risk at that price, would be surprised if he averages more than 95 for mine. Bontempelli is more of a calculated risk (even if he is 2nd year which scares a few off), especially in the forwards I don't mind that selection. Sheppard, haven't a clue about him. 3 rookie forwards in interesting. On balance I probably prefer team B, not by much though.

Thanks for the advice. Yeah that's the thought with Wallis. He averaged 90 a few years back as a clearance specialist. If he could get back to that, make 200K would be worth it. Guess will have to see how he lines up in NAB 3. Bontempelli will almost certainly improve I feel. I didn't watch many dogs games last year but from what I have seen this summer is in the Fyfe mould. If I felt confident in Berger getting a decent run at the ruck role I'd pick Bontempelli for sure. Think I'v got to spend that extra money on suring up the rucks unfortunately..

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Anyone got any idea what Haynes would have to average for him to make around 70-100k?

Haynes is priced at an average of 71 ($383k). To rise in price by 70k, he would need to average 84. To rise in price by 100k, he would need to average 90. An average of 90 would put him in the top 10 defenders based on starting prices.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Haynes copped a score of 9 in R8 last year, getting the red vest in this match. If this score is taken out of his results, he would have averaged 80 last year.

 

[thetradesman]

Haynes won't rise 100K in my book, At the max I think he will average about 83.

 

[rocker_oz33]

If he av 83 thats a keeper imho at worst D6 at season end.
But needs to play most games.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

If he av 83 thats a keeper imho at worst D6 at season end.
But needs to play most games.

If your D6 after all your upgrades is only averaging 83, that is nowhere near the top 10. You should also upgrade D6 in this case.

 

[rocker_oz33]

If your D6 after all your upgrades is only averaging 83, that is nowhere near the top 10. You should also upgrade D6 in this case.

IMHO def will be the last place people will upgrading,just my thoughts tho.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

IMHO def will be the last place people will upgrading,just my thoughts tho.

Sure can be a late upgrade, but you said keeper i.e. wouldn't need one, which is just not true.

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Haynes won't rise 100K in my book, At the max I think he will average about 83.

He average 80 last year taking out his injury score. Can see him averaging 85-90 due to his and GWS improvement and he should be maturing. More value than KK and Newnes IMO. What was his injury last year does anyone know? is he injury prone?

 

[Krujan]

He average 80 last year taking out his injury score. Can see him averaging 85-90 due to his and GWS improvement and he should be maturing. More value than KK and Newnes IMO. What was his injury last year does anyone know? is he injury prone?

If you take out Haynes' injury score, he averaged 80 from only 7 games, which is not nearly enough games to confidently say he can average 80 over 22 games, let alone average 85-90 based on such a small size sample.

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

If you take out Haynes' injury score, he averaged 80 from only 7 games, which is not nearly enough games to confidently say he can average 80 over 22 games, let alone average 85-90 based on such a small size sample.

I said I can see him averaging 85-90, not he will average 85-90, thats implying that he stays on the track and plays the same role which he did last year as a rebounding defender, and as I said with maturity and an improving team this could easily happen

 

[thetradesman]

He average 80 last year taking out his injury score. Can see him averaging 85-90 due to his and GWS improvement and he should be maturing. More value than KK and Newnes IMO. What was his injury last year does anyone know? is he injury prone?

Taking a decent size risk picking him as well, is around that awkward price range.

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Taking a decent size risk picking him as well, is around that awkward price range.

Yeah if he does **** all in the remaining Nab games and KK/Savage light it up then might easily switch. Clancee is another intriguing one if he keeps up the good scores

 

[MotlopMagic]

Any thoughts on the following?

 

[thetradesman]

Yeah if he does **** all in the remaining Nab games and KK/Savage light it up then might easily switch. Clancee is another intriguing one if he keeps up the good scores

Agree on KK, I was going to put him in but he just doesn't fit with my team structure.

Savage is a spud, wouldn't go near him.

Had Pearce in about 2 days ago but reverted back to the 3 premiums and 2 mid pricers back line.

 

[toxic]

If your D6 after all your upgrades is only averaging 83, that is nowhere near the top 10. You should also upgrade D6 in this case.

Have you ever ended up with the top averaging players in any position? Let alone all positions on the field ?

The concept is flawed as it is 100% unattainable based on historical data of say an average of 260,000 teams for 10 years

 

[toxic]

Taking a decent size risk picking him as well, is around that awkward price range.

Whats the risk?
Whats the viable alternative?

 

[thetradesman]

Any thoughts on the following?

Very risky team with Wells, Nic Nat, Van Berlo.

Like the wines selection, also like a few PODS you have in there such as Mckenzie and Bartel.

Nice team but would steer clear of Wells and Van Berlo.

 

[toxic]

So everyone is aware and excuse the tone

But blatant dismissal of peoples ideas without offering an alternative or basis on why an idea is "no good"

Is shitting me to tears

FFS everyone is here asking for opinions and advice...

Provide it plz

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Have you ever ended up with the top averaging player in any position? Let alone all positions?

The concept is flawed as it is 100% unattainable based on historical data of say an average of 260,000 teams for 10 years

What a load of rot. So you want to know how I have gone getting top averaging players? I started and finished with the top DEF, MID and FWD last year and I upgraded into guys on each line who were in the top 10-15 for their position by about R16. Overall finish was top 200.

You can think the concept is flawed if you want to, suit yourself. If my D6 is averaging 83 this year, they will certainly be in line for an upgrade.

 

[thetradesman]

Whats the risk?
Whats the viable alternative?

Risk is he is worth 380k (not cheap) and played 7 games last year for an average of 80.

He was injured for most of the year, and it is irrefutable he is in an awkward price range.

 

[toxic]

Risk is he is worth 380k (not cheap) and played 7 games last year for an average of 80.

He was injured for most of the year, and it is irrefutable he is in an awkward price range.

Dayne beams says hi