Scott Watters and Scott Cummings wtf?

[Carringbush2010]

I'll quote from these two clowns from footy WA

Scott Watters:

"Luke Schuey has been under rated"

Pffft really? Anyone who under rates that bloke is a fool, there is no one that disputes Luke's ability. Not disputable.

Scott Cummings:

"Nic Nat has had his critics"

Show me one critic of Nic Nat Scott.

This is not up for debate Scott's, you're both wrong and those players should rightly be pi55ed at you two w******.

Seriously poor form and not helping the west teams.

 

[Benny78]

I'm am extraordinary critic of Nic Nat. Doesn't he cost his club like 200k a game?

If you add up every players salary and divide it by the number of games played he cost the most

 

[Carringbush2010]

I'm am extraordinary critic of Nic Nat. Doesn't he cost his club like 200k a game?

Like if you add up every players salary and divide it by the no of games they've plated he cost the most

Why are you a critic of Nic Nat? Would you be a critic of Jeremy Howe because he's not playing games? How about Harley Bennell? How much is he costing Freo? What about Alex Rance? How much is he costing his club?

Your argument is feeble.

 

[Topkent]

I'll quote from these two clowns from footy WA

Scott Watters:

"Luke Schuey has been under rated"

Pffft really? Anyone who under rates that bloke is a fool, there is no one that disputes Luke's ability. Not disputable.

Scott Cummings:

"Nic Nat has had his critics"

Show me one critic of Nic Nat Scott.

This is not up for debate Scott's, you're both wrong and those players should rightly be pi55ed at you two w******.

Seriously poor form and not helping the west teams.

There has been **** loads of critics of nic nat what the **** are you on about

 

[Carringbush2010]

There has been **** loads of critics of nic nat what the **** are you on about

Name those critics, I can't find one.

 

[Benny78]

Name those critics, I can't find one.

Me

 

[Topkent]

Name those critics, I can't find one.

Garry Lyon + Jason Dunstall were heavy critics of his. You must have had your head inside your ass if you can't remember the years of critisicm he got

 

[JADED]

Garry Lyon + Jason Dunstall were heavy critics of his. You must have had your head inside your ass if you can't remember the years of critisicm he got

Yep, Gary Lyon said he'd take Zac Clarke (Freo/Ess) over Naitanui.

 

[Nostradumbass]

This is going well.

 

[RAPPA]

I’m a critic of this thread

 

[Del165198]

Yep, Gary Lyon said he'd take Zac Clarke (Freo/Ess) over Naitanui.

Just shows how little clue hairy Garry has

 

[Brunswick Trap King]

Old man Leigh Matthews criticised Nic Nat on Saturday

 

[BigFrizz36]

It appears that scott Cummings has bigger issues at the moment.

 

[Farang83150]

I'll quote from these two clowns from footy WA

Scott Watters:

"Luke Schuey has been under rated"

Pffft really? Anyone who under rates that bloke is a fool, there is no one that disputes Luke's ability. Not disputable.

Scott Cummings:

"Nic Nat has had his critics"

Show me one critic of Nic Nat Scott.

This is not up for debate Scott's, you're both wrong and those players should rightly be pi55ed at you two w******.

Seriously poor form and not helping the west teams.

Watch the Hawks WC game from the weekend, commentators mentioned the same as Watters re LS.
And if you never heard Dunstall or G Lyon go on about Nata a while back then i guess you haven't been following footy for to long.

 

[Jaeger]

To be fair there have been some critics ovee Nic Nats impact on games and his numbers and whether he does enough




As for Shuey, I think before he won the Norm Smith he was a little underrated.

 

[Turnover]

I blame the vicco media bias.

 

[DirtySandman]

I think the AFL underrates match fixing,

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

Name those critics, I can't find one.

Use the search function, there's threads on here that are highly critical of him.

Not me though, I think when he's playing he's the best tap ruckman in the league. He doesn't get the ball around the ground like the others, but he affects the play in other ways with his bulk and bullocking work.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

What a dumb thread

 

[Dazzler9]

I'll quote from these two clowns from footy WA

Scott Watters:

"Luke Schuey has been under rated"

Pffft really? Anyone who under rates that bloke is a fool, there is no one that disputes Luke's ability. Not disputable.

Scott Cummings:

"Nic Nat has had his critics"

Show me one critic of Nic Nat Scott.

This is not up for debate Scott's, you're both wrong and those players should rightly be pi55ed at you two w******.

Seriously poor form and not helping the west teams.

Mate, I like your posting a lot, but you're off the mark here. NicNat has been criticised from pillar to post over the years, by those who focus on what traditional rucks do and can't see what he brings to the team.

Shuey has been under-rated for years. But I'd say he's beginning to finally get his dues.

 

[Dazzler9]

Mate, I like your posting a lot, but you're off the mark here. NicNat has been criticised from pillar to post over the years, by those who focus on what traditional rucks do and can't see what he brings to the team.

Shuey has been under-rated for years. But I'd say he's beginning to finally get his dues.

Also, do you not remember the NicNat vs Jack Watts #1 debate that raged for years? As recently as last year there were people claiming that Jack Watts was definitely the right choice with the #1 draft pick and was proving to be a better player than Naitanui. Jack f***ing Watts!!!!!!!

 

[Coaster2012]

Name those critics, I can't find one.

literally half of BF

 

[flyinghi64]

Ummm, mmmmm, well.
Yep NicNat often has his critics. Even now. Leigh Matthews say hi.
Shuey, even after winning Normy, very much underrated. Never in the conversation when media talks elite mids, rarely if ever.

But you want to talk underrated, Brad Sheppard say hi.

 

[Truckosaurus]

It's an outrage all right, you should write to the WA government.

 

[PieLebo87]

Ummm, mmmmm, well.
Yep NicNat often has his critics. Even now. Leigh Matthews say hi.
Shuey, even after winning Normy, very much underrated. Never in the conversation when media talks elite mids, rarely if ever.

Absolutely underrated in my books.

Even after winning a Norm Smith, rarely gets a mention when they talk about the best mids in the game - I can’t understand why either.