SFL 2010 Division 1 Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
superfreak said:
Tips...

Chelt by 15 goals ;) ha!
Tooronga by 3 goals
St Pauls by 8 goals
Chelsea Heights by 7 goals
Springvale by 5 points.

b2b, it didn't take long to get Nathan Carroll in the lineup, i see he is picked to play this week!
Click to expand...

whats the point? he trained last night is in melbourne for the next fortnight and is available to play the next 2 or 3 weeks!

Sholud he not play?
 
No real point mate, just some clubs would make a bloke play a game in the reserves, no matter who they are. Sends the message to the players that are already there that no one gets special consideration.

Its good to have players such as him in the league. The more ex-AFL the better.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

superfreak said:
No real point mate, just some clubs would make a bloke play a game in the reserves, no matter who they are. Sends the message to the players that are already there that no one gets special consideration.

Its good to have players such as him in the league. The more ex-AFL the better.
Click to expand...

I agree some clubs would make certain players play a game in the scoobies but I think the majority wouldn't bother, especially if it was a big recruit.. would your coach? don't think mine would!!
 
superfreak said:
No real point mate, just some clubs would make a bloke play a game in the reserves, no matter who they are. Sends the message to the players that are already there that no one gets special consideration.

Its good to have players such as him in the league. The more ex-AFL the better.
Click to expand...
carlton should have rolled judd out at kramer street then
 
Bit different RRM. Judd did the entire pre season with Carlton as he was recruited in October of the previous year. Thats not what occurs in local footy. If such a player did the hard yards pre season with the group then yeah, they play Round 1 in the seniors, but if they don't and all of a sudden turn up a few weeks in, then IMO they have to come through the reserves. It sends the right message to the rest of the playing group. If the player refuses, then they aren't someone that I'd want at my club, no matter their ability.

JMHO.
 
superfreak said:
Bit different RRM. Judd did the entire pre season with Carlton as he was recruited in October of the previous year. Thats not what occurs in local footy. If such a player did the hard yards pre season with the group then yeah, they play Round 1 in the seniors, but if they don't and all of a sudden turn up a few weeks in, then IMO they have to come through the reserves. It sends the right message to the rest of the playing group. If the player refuses, then they aren't someone that I'd want at my club, no matter their ability.

JMHO.
Click to expand...
bit hard to do the pre season when you're in perth..... if that's the way cheltnham go about it good luck hope it works for you.... if anyone thought at this level a guy with carrolls football resume needs to have a game in the 2's just to prove point to the rest of the club was a good move i'd be surprised
 
superfreak said:
Saw Chelsea Heights on the weekend. Would be surprised if they lost a game. Very good side. Having said that St Pauls were extremely impressive on Sunday.
Click to expand...

Might have to take this back....

Nothing to do with Chelsea Heights, who won easily again today over a finals aspirant but what I saw at JBO was nothing short of class. Fair to say there aren't too many local/country teams that would have beaten City today, and that includes Vermont, Balwyn, Albury.
Super side St Kilda City, and they had 4-5 out too!
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

superfreak said:
Might have to take this back....

Nothing to do with Chelsea Heights, who won easily again today over a finals aspirant but what I saw at JBO was nothing short of class. Fair to say there aren't too many local/country teams that would have beaten City today, and that includes Vermont, Balwyn, Albury.
Super side St Kilda City, and they had 4-5 out too!
Click to expand...

Our younger players are performing very well, probably added a bit run and enthusiasm
 
Must be stoked b2b if the kids are playing well, if you have them playing most of the year and win another flag alot of people might back off the bagging of you guys... but maybe not!!
 
I know exactly where our league stands in the pecking order snowman, but it is nowhere as bad as you are suggesting.

Now I'm not saying City would beat Vermont etc every week, but they would have given them a fair run for their money on Saturday. Anyone at the game would tell you that they were just on another level, especially in the first half.

BTW, did I read correctly that Dingley lost to Tooronga Malvern for the third time in two years??? Hmmm ;) I'd suggest you keep your mouth shut until you have something to back it up with!
 
superfreak said:
I know exactly where our league stands in the pecking order snowman, but it is nowhere as bad as you are suggesting.

Now I'm not saying City would beat Vermont etc every week, but they would have given them a fair run for their money on Saturday. Anyone at the game would tell you that they were just on another level, especially in the first half.

BTW, did I read correctly that Dingley lost to Tooronga Malvern for the third time in two years??? Hmmm ;) I'd suggest you keep your mouth shut until you have something to back it up with!
Click to expand...


I doubt the snowman is from Dingley, no way would anyone be running their mouths off after a very disappointing display of footy that we played on saturday.
 
um42 said:
Must be stoked b2b if the kids are playing well, if you have them playing most of the year and win another flag alot of people might back off the bagging of you guys... but maybe not!!
Click to expand...

Doubt it, its fashionable to hate stkilda city, most people that do make there judgements from afar and we cant please everyone.

As far as our young players go we had a 16, 17 , 3 x 18, 19 and a 20 yo in the seniors on Saturday and all of them were handy, we are going to need 3 or 4 of them to stand up and become a part of the team all year.
 
Unknown Identity said:
B2B..

Any truth in the rumour that the great Matthew Richardson could make a 4 game cameo appearance down at the farm..?
Click to expand...

Absolutely no chance of playing with St.Kilda City, it is a rumor that has been on going since November last year, to my knowledge not one person of any official capacity has even spoken to Richo, he knows a few of the players on a social basis thats about it.

Id suggest with his media commitments he would not risk playing any level of football anywhere , even a recent as Monday I received a phone call from another club official telling me he was playing at St.Kilda City, whoever is fuelling the rumors is doing a good job!
 
Can Opener said:
I doubt the snowman is from Dingley, no way would anyone be running their mouths off after a very disappointing display of footy that we played on saturday.
Click to expand...

Very strong rumor going around that the snowman has let his identity slip whilst drunk and the word around the traps he is actually a dingley player!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

B
  • Sticky
SFNL Division 1 2024 discussion
19 20 21 22 23
Replies
573
Views
79K
Greg Tivendale
Greg Tivendale
Greg Tivendale
SFNL Division 1 2023 discussion
24 25 26 27 28
Replies
682
Views
129K
bedford
B

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top