SNFL Div 3 discussion 2023

[don_draper]

if div 3 and 4 merge you'd need to move a couple up to div 3 and have an uneven fixture. top of div 3 and bottom of div 4 are poles apart.

 

[SaintsMagee]

if div 3 and 4 merge you'd need to move a couple up to div 3 and have an uneven fixture. top of div 3 and bottom of div 4 are poles apart.

If you had 14 in a div 3, could you go top 6? Each team plays each other once and then the last 5-6 rounds the top 8-10 teams compete for finals while the bottom 4 odd teams just round robin to finish the season? In theory I think it's a good idea but very hard to actually make happen.

I think more teams in finals for a bigger division would be great but the difference between the top and bottom sides would be big

 

[MortlockWatcher]

11, 12 or 13 = final five
14 or 15 = final six

 

[Sloppyskillz]

If you had 14 in a div 3, could you go top 6? Each team plays each other once and then the last 5-6 rounds the top 8-10 teams compete for finals while the bottom 4 odd teams just round robin to finish the season? In theory I think it's a good idea but very hard to actually make happen.

I think more teams in finals for a bigger division would be great but the difference between the top and bottom sides would

If you had 14 in a div 3, could you go top 6? Each team plays each other once and then the last 5-6 rounds the top 8-10 teams compete for finals while the bottom 4 odd teams just round robin to finish the season? In theory I think it's a good idea but very hard to actually make happen.

I think more teams in finals for a bigger division would be great but the difference between the top and bottom sides would be big

If you had 14 in a div 3, could you go top 6? Each team plays each other once and then the last 5-6 rounds the top 8-10 teams compete for finals while the bottom 4 odd teams just round robin to finish the season? In theory I think it's a good idea but very hard to actually make happen.

I think more teams in finals for a bigger division would be great but the difference between the top and bottom sides would be big

Why do we need mini finals series before the finals? Not every year has to be fair for every team. If you arent good enough to make finals you come back next year and try again. If you are well off finals and getting belted every week then change something, stop trying to hide bottom teams from versing top sides just so nobody gets their feelings hurt and stop playing.

 

[Making Up the Numbers]

Black rock coming back down a division.

I am a city follower and supporter.

But rumours are a few old heads heading down to black rock to be with the hoy boys

Black Rock just don’t learn 2022 - old boys win flag go up a Div and they leave club
2023 - thrashed each week in Div 2
2024 - back down to Div 3 and call up old boys to play again.

Bloody stupid

 

[Wild Thing]

Black Rock just don’t learn 2022 - old boys win flag go up a Div and they leave club
2023 - thrashed each week in Div 2
2024 - back down to Div 3 and call up old boys to play again.

Bloody stupid

Says something about the club to be honest!
Have won 3 x D3 flags in the last 20 years and lasted no more than 2 seasons each time they have gone up.
Same rotating cycle will occur if they go down this road again.

 

[kangakangakanga]

Says something about the club to be honest!
Have won 3 x D3 flags in the last 20 years and lasted no more than 2 seasons each time they have gone up.
Same rotating cycle will occur if they go down this road again.

Rather be winning flags going up. Then being mid table year after year in div 3 not improving.

 

[Banger1]

absolutely incorrect

Absolutely correct. Let’s see the figures. And who stays and goes.

 

[Dukes_08]

Absolutely correct. Let’s see the figures. And who stays and goes.

Would also like to see this.

 

[FootballGuy95]

Absolutely correct. Let’s see the figures. And who stays and goes.

Already signing players so the money must be there


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Dukes_08]

Already signing players so the money must be there


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Resigning. And the blokes they’ve resigned wouldn’t be on a cent.

 

[Clanger95]

Resigning. And the blokes they’ve resigned wouldn’t be on a cent.

They only recruited half the karingal twos side over the last two years so there’s still half a team to sign

 

[Apolo creed]

Already signing players so the money must be there


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Spent the money to get into 2nd Div as MPNFL told them that to have any chance of moving league's they need to be in higher division so they splashed the cash

 

[Wild Thing]

Spent the money to get into 2nd Div as MPNFL told them that to have any chance of moving league's they need to be in higher division so they splashed the cash

Wouldn’t be listening to anything the MPNFL says…..full of s#it!

 

[Dukes_08]

Spent the money to get into 2nd Div as MPNFL told them that to have any chance of moving league's they need to be in higher division so they splashed the cash

Just waiting for don_draper to pipe up

 

[FootballGuy95]

Spent the money to get into 2nd Div as MPNFL told them that to have any chance of moving league's they need to be in higher division so they splashed the cash

So why can’t they go again in Div 3


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Clanger95]

So why can’t they go again in Div 3


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Why would they do that? They already lost a grand final in that division now they will be expecting to have a crack at losing one in Div 2

 

[don_draper]

Spent the money to get into 2nd Div as MPNFL told them that to have any chance of moving league's they need to be in higher division so they splashed the cash

stop making shit up. just stop.

 

[Dukes_08]

stop making s**t up. just stop.

And there it is

 

[tiga2017]

Anyone has idea why the Lyndhurst coach got the kick? Not related or got anything to do with them.

 

[Football_Fanatic]

Says something about the club to be honest!
Have won 3 x D3 flags in the last 20 years and lasted no more than 2 seasons each time they have gone up.
Same rotating cycle will occur if they go down this road again.

Div 2 a different beast. Most teams with Juniors, U/19s 3rds makes it tough for any team with only Seniors/reserves. Black Rock have started Juniors which Rome wasn’t built in a day. Hopefully keep being strong in Div 3 until the foundations are in place to go up and stay up.

 

[Deezpleez]

Well said fanatic..plenty of interest in BR as a destination club, but any suggestion that they are automatically old blokes is absolute crap..

 

[Apolo creed]

stop making s**t up. just stop.

Just stating the facts

 

[sup3rfish]

Anyone has idea why the Lyndhurst coach got the kick? Not related or got anything to do with them.

not going to get much out of it here. my guess is club needed a change in direction

 

[tiga2017]

not going to get much out of it here. my guess is club needed a change in direction

Interesting. I thought winning a flag should be enough and they were very close to finish top 4 this year. Good luck to the new coach.