-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Speculation Trades
- Thread starter GhostofJimJess
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I'm not approving the trade, just identifying Zantuck. Personally I don't think Crawf will go anywhere, Hawks will want too much in return for a player with only 2 years left, too much of a risk for an injured player, not enough of a window to win a flag in for the team that gets him.
Cogs is a gun
Senior List
Nightwolf_69 said:
Cause then he can ******** williams up every day
#1 - Darren Gaspar to WCE for Paul Johnson and 4th round pick.
#2 - Mark Chaffey/Andy Kellaway to anyone for a draft pick.
#2 - Mark Chaffey/Andy Kellaway to anyone for a draft pick.
I agree that it would be the worst trade ever!Nightwolf_69 said:
Why would we want to trade a bloke who has potentially 10 good years of footy in him for a bloke ,who , 18 months ago when seen in his tell all , on the inside doco , was having injections reguarly just to get out on the field . And this year , he limped through a dozen or so games due to a chronic back injury . It was actually quite humane when he busted his arm because at the time it was very apparent that he was "really" struggling and was barely a shadow of his former self .
Ty Zantuck will never be in the same league as Crawford but the man is finished . It would be a foolish club to trade away valuble players or picks for Crawf , he is in worse shape than Carey was when he went to the crows .
- Thread starter
- #33
Nightwolf_69 said:
You interpret me wrong, Nightwolf ... I do rate Crawf. Always have. Very highly in fact.
But I'm also very aware that he's soon to turn 30, his body has been bashed from goalpost to goalpost for over a decade, and his 'alternative' life and media options appear to have drained his intrinsic motivation quite significantly of late.
As for "not even knowing who he (Zantuck) is", that's just plainly an ignorant comment ... you better hope you're own clubs recruiting personnel (have they gone too??) are a little more familiar with opposition players than yourself.
For arguments sake, then, lets sub in a different name that you might know ... like Tivendale, or Fiora, or Hall, then. Pick 20's hardly insulting too ... it's the first choice of the 2nd Rounders this year.
Blair7 said:
Often the best time to do a trade with a habitual underperformer such as Joel.
After all, with the benefit of hindsight, would you have traded Daffy after his B&F year of 1999 ?
I damn well would have.
Krak is another story. He would have great trade currency, particularly with the Roos where there must be that sentimental extra value.
Come to think of it, maybe just Harris is undervaluing Andy ??
But seriously, if we're tradin crawf, we're gettin rid of our number 1 player. You cant expect us to be overthe moon about gettin Zantuck in return. Yeh crawf has had his injuries, but really only this year in his whole career. You guys are acting like he is washed up, and i guarantee that if he is in a hawks jersey next year, he will perform the best and most consistant out of every1 in our team. Might even push the Brownlow again! Hes just that good. If we get rid of him we want someone quality in return. But lets face it, he wont leave
- Thread starter
- #35
Nightwolf_69 said:
Fair enough, too. I hope he finishes as a one-team player, and I honestly hope he gets his premiership (though not at our expense!!)
Tiger_Of_Old
THE_GUN:"Why don't you use your reg acc"7/9/24
what would you give for Richo?Nightwolf_69 said:
cheers!
tiger of old said:
Believe it or not, i rate richo. If he gets his kicking right, hes a star. Wouldnt consider crawf for him tho. I cant think of anything that comes to my head tho, and what would make you guys happy. Depends on how much you like him?
pick 2 would be alright
Tigerbob said:
Awesome trades and sensible aswell, something rare from any BF poster
quick someone email this to Miller let's make it happen !!!
I like it alot!
Gaspar plus Pick 1----> Humphrey B Bear.
We may not even be able to get the ABC to agree to this, we may have to tip in our 1st round pick as well to offload him.
We may not even be able to get the ABC to agree to this, we may have to tip in our 1st round pick as well to offload him.
rfctigerarmy
🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
because Ghost of Punt Road was being serious...
[/QUOTE]If north agreed to trade Harris for Krakouer it would be a huge win. Harris is one of the hardest at the pill in the AFL . Very much in the Coughlan mould . Two of them would be fantastic .nelroo said:
Admitted Andy K has had a good year and shown a lot of improvement , to me , he would be expendable to get a bloke like Harris
- Thread starter
- #47
jezza said:
Just having a look back through some oldies and goldies.
Seems that two years was enough of a window if he'd gone.
localyokel said:
Now we know...
sante
Emu
LOL @ me wanting McGough
- Thread starter
- #50
sante said:
Some of these old posts can be very cruel, can't they sante. Maybe we should have some sort of statute of limitations on digging them up.
Anything for a laugh this week, though.
