Stenglein to Eagles for Waters?

[Fred Phillis]

Micale

Highly respected coach over here - quite strong tactically and has a fair bit of clout at the club.

tks for that...never heard of him to be honest but i'll take yr word...

 

[MaccasNeighbour]

Here's another scenario:

Stenglein to Fremantle (from Adelaide)
2nd round draft pick to Nth Melbourne (from Adelaide)

Justin Longmuir to North Melb (from Fremantle)

1st round draft pick to Fremantle (from Nth Melb)

Jeremy Clayton to Adelaide (from Nth Melbourne)
John Baird to Adelaide (from Nth Melbourne)

Not a great deal for Adelaide, but they have little bargaining power.

Not as though I'm expecting a deal like this to be considered, let alone discussed. Just keen on getting J Longmuir to North.

A 24 and 23 year old who played 11 games b/w them for a team that finished outside the finals this year? I'm assuming this is meant to be a joke. How about a second crack at Wells?

 

[crazzzy_grrl]

tks for that...never heard of him to be honest but i'll take yr word...

I do know he is highly respected and in the WAFL took East Perth to 3 flags in a row and they were the total dominate team during those 3 years (Brisbane of the WAFL in those years)

 

[Streaker]

my point which you missed completely is that the head coach has the final say so if JW wants Stinger then he will get him regardless of what the ASSISTANT COACH WANTS. trust me adelaide learned from experience with the wayne

So this bloke Reid who is coming out and saying that Adelaide is going to play hardball is another glorified Adelaide pencil pusher blowing wind out of his rear end. Makes sense, after all he isn't the coach.

 

[Eagles4Ever]

So this bloke Reid who is coming out and saying that Adelaide is going to play hardball is another glorified Adelaide pencil pusher blowing wind out of his rear end. Makes sense, after all he isn't the coach.

touche'

 

[Mad Dog]

So this bloke Reid who is coming out and saying that Adelaide is going to play hardball is another glorified Adelaide pencil pusher blowing wind out of his rear end. Makes sense, after all he isn't the coach.

JR manages the Football Dept moron, and as such will negotiate the trade

 

[Total Package]

HAHAHA Adelaide people are unbelievable... I was banned from the Adelaide board because I told them they were fools 4 weeks ago when they said Wirrpunda+2rd round wasn't enough for Stenglein. bwahahaha honestly. We would NEVER give up Sam Butler or Beau Waters for Tyson Stenglein.. EVER. I don't care how much Adelaide supporters/coaches try to pump up Stengleins tyres the man is not a superstar of the AFL in fact he is not even close to it. In fact never mind Stenglein... there is not a single player in the Crows side who I would swap for Waters or Butler.

Its fair to say Adelaide people/supporters/coaches have no idea about trading because they gave up Daniel Wells for Wayne Carey and we all stood around and laughed at them while they were walking around like roosters telling everyone how jealous we were that Carey went to Adelaide. HAHAHAHA I still remember KG and Cornes on the footy show just after Carey was signed poking fun at the footy show saying all the Victorians were jealous because they got Carey hahaha

Think about this for a second Adelaide fans..... for the Crows to come out and say it would take Butler or Waters to let Stenglein go.... shows what they think of these 2 players. It's like us saying it would take Jonathon Brown and Akermanis to get Chris Judd. It would never ever happen buy the club has got to be seen to be playing hardball... and Adelaide know full and well that the Eagles will never let Butler and Waters go.... so for you Adelaide morons to actually believe it will happen is laughable.

 

[Jars458]

So this bloke Reid who is coming out and saying that Adelaide is going to play hardball is another glorified Adelaide pencil pusher blowing wind out of his rear end. Makes sense, after all he isn't the coach.

Exactly

Its all wind blowing at the moment. That's why statements such as Waters and Butler will not be traded being made as certainties are just ridiculous.

The trade may end up involing three or four clubs. I think we should all agree to leave it alone until after the finals. All this is pointless really

 

[Streaker]

JR manages the Football Dept moron, and as such will negotiate the trade

According to your mate the coach makes all the decisions, tosser.

 

[Mad Dog]

According to your mate the coach makes all the decisions, tosser.

yes but who NEGOTIATES the trade MORON

 

[Jabber]

yes but who NEGOTIATES the trade MORON

We all know how it works - tell your mate a couple of pages back before you put your foot further up your arse.

 

[Cap]

HAHAHA Adelaide people are unbelievable... I was banned from the Adelaide board because I told them they were fools 4 weeks ago when they said Wirrpunda+2rd round wasn't enough for Stenglein. bwahahaha honestly. We would NEVER give up Sam Butler or Beau Waters for Tyson Stenglein.. EVER. I don't care how much Adelaide supporters/coaches try to pump up Stengleins tyres the man is not a superstar of the AFL in fact he is not even close to it. In fact never mind Stenglein... there is not a single player in the Crows side who I would swap for Waters or Butler.

Its fair to say Adelaide people/supporters/coaches have no idea about trading because they gave up Daniel Wells for Wayne Carey and we all stood around and laughed at them while they were walking around like roosters telling everyone how jealous we were that Carey went to Adelaide. HAHAHAHA I still remember KG and Cornes on the footy show just after Carey was signed poking fun at the footy show saying all the Victorians were jealous because they got Carey hahaha

Think about this for a second Adelaide fans..... for the Crows to come out and say it would take Butler or Waters to let Stenglein go.... shows what they think of these 2 players. It's like us saying it would take Jonathon Brown and Akermanis to get Chris Judd. It would never ever happen buy the club has got to be seen to be playing hardball... and Adelaide know full and well that the Eagles will never let Butler and Waters go.... so for you Adelaide morons to actually believe it will happen is laughable.

mate you got banned cause you are a t***** nothing else

 

[afc9798]

HAHAHA Adelaide people are unbelievable... I was banned from the Adelaide board because I told them they were fools 4 weeks ago when they said Wirrpunda+2rd round wasn't enough for Stenglein. bwahahaha honestly. We would NEVER give up Sam Butler or Beau Waters for Tyson Stenglein.. EVER. I don't care how much Adelaide supporters/coaches try to pump up Stengleins tyres the man is not a superstar of the AFL in fact he is not even close to it. In fact never mind Stenglein... there is not a single player in the Crows side who I would swap for Waters or Butler.

Its fair to say Adelaide people/supporters/coaches have no idea about trading because they gave up Daniel Wells for Wayne Carey and we all stood around and laughed at them while they were walking around like roosters telling everyone how jealous we were that Carey went to Adelaide. HAHAHAHA I still remember KG and Cornes on the footy show just after Carey was signed poking fun at the footy show saying all the Victorians were jealous because they got Carey hahaha

Think about this for a second Adelaide fans..... for the Crows to come out and say it would take Butler or Waters to let Stenglein go.... shows what they think of these 2 players. It's like us saying it would take Jonathon Brown and Akermanis to get Chris Judd. It would never ever happen buy the club has got to be seen to be playing hardball... and Adelaide know full and well that the Eagles will never let Butler and Waters go.... so for you Adelaide morons to actually believe it will happen is laughable.

It's ironic that you value the Eagles players so highly, given that they have been far less successful than our team in recent years. You're telling me that after one ordinary year, we are dead, yet your ordinary bunch of hacks that gets beaten by us regularly are so much better?

Waters has yet to prove anything and did not get a Rising Star nomination. Sure he has potential, but even you have potential Frank. We don't want Butler and Waters, just Waters will do. You keep harping on about what the Eagles will do, I would venture that you in fact have no idea what they will do. You can't even get off your arse to go to a game, let alone be bothered enough to have any inside knowledge.

To say that there is not one player you would take from Adelaide is probably fairly indicative of the type of mindset you get when you're 8 hours from civilisation and probably indicative of why your club is so mediocre.

 

[Total Package]

Let me explain how trades work....

Stenglein: I want to go back to Perth to play with the Eagles.
Adelaide: Ok... we want Butler and Waters
West Coast: ******** off.
Adelaide: Ok... we want Butler and a 1st round pick
West Coast: ******** off.
Adelaide: Ok.. how about first and 2nd round draft pick
West Coast: *yawn* ******** off
Adelaide: Please we beg you... give us a 1st round pick and Callum Chambers.
West Coast: ok deal.

 

[Cap]

We all know how it works - tell your mate a couple of pages back before you put your foot further up your arse.

mate you have no f***** idea my point is that in that article your assistant coach said the two players were in his view keepers
my point is if John Worsfold doesnt think so then they will go

of course you football department is going to make the actaual trade but would be up to the coach which player he does or doesnt want

 

[Total Package]

It's ironic that you value the Eagles players so highly, given that they have been far less successful than our team in recent years. You're telling me that after one ordinary year, we are dead, yet your ordinary bunch of hacks that gets beaten by us regularly are so much better?

You look at the squads and tell me who is going to be a better side in the next 5 years.

Waters has yet to prove anything and did not get a Rising Star nomination.

Actually he did... along with Butler, Staker and Seaby.

Sure he has potential, but even you have potential Frank.

There is a difference between having potential and actually displaying it. They have both displayed they are going to be top quality class players.

To say that there is not one player you would take from Adelaide is probably fairly indicative of the type of mindset you get when you're 8 hours from civilisation and probably indicative of why your club is so mediocre.

Re-read what I said... there is not 1 Adelaide player I would take in exchange for Butler and Waters. You explain to me who we would take? Your best players are all retiring.

 

[Jabber]

It's ironic that you value the Eagles players so highly, given that they have been far less successful than our team in recent years. You're telling me that after one ordinary year, we are dead, yet your ordinary bunch of hacks that gets beaten by us regularly are so much better?

Unless you can manage to score a Waters or Butler for Stenglein, you are dead and you know it. Out of curiosity, what is this success you speak of?

I know we have played finals every year but 2 since 1989, I can't seem to find a corresponding success rate for you guys.

 

[Streaker]

yes but who NEGOTIATES the trade MORON

It isn't the Coach is it! TOSSER

Why would all you fans be so upset with Reid about the Carey trade then if he doesn't make the decisions. It would be Ayres fault because he is the coach and he made the decision. You see dikcwit, I know who does the negotiations and who makes the decisions, unlike your mate who thinks it is the all up to the coach.

 

[Cap]

Unless you can manage to score a Waters or Butler for Stenglein, you are dead and you know it. Out of curiosity, what is this success you speak of?

I know we have played finals every year but 2 since 1989, I can't seem to find a corresponding success rate for you guys.

i suppose if you going to talk like that our success is more recent than yours
but both are old news

remeber that the WCE had a crap year a couple of yrs ago and have scrapped into the eight last year and this year - its hardly something you'd right home about though

and granted you come back is going to be that well worn "your not in the finals" which i am quite aware of. but if we are to be successful in the future we needed this year (unfortunatly), hopefully we arent scraping into the 8 and getting knocked out week one though

 

[Jars458]

HAHAHA Adelaide people are unbelievable... I was banned from the Adelaide board because I told them they were fools 4 weeks ago when they said Wirrpunda+2rd round wasn't enough for Stenglein. bwahahaha honestly. We would NEVER give up Sam Butler or Beau Waters for Tyson Stenglein.. EVER. I don't care how much Adelaide supporters/coaches try to pump up Stengleins tyres the man is not a superstar of the AFL in fact he is not even close to it. Its fair to say Adelaide people/supporters/coaches have no idea about trading because they gave up Daniel Wells for Wayne Carey and we all stood around and laughed at them while they were walking around like roosters telling everyone how jealous we were that Carey went to Adelaide. HAHAHAHA I still remember KG and Cornes on the footy show just after Carey was signed poking fun at the footy show saying all the Victorians were jealous because they got Carey hahaha

You know NOTHING about what West Coast will or will not do.

You are such a child.

 

[funkyfreo]

Let me explain how trades work....

Stenglein: I want to go back to Perth to play with the Eagles.
Adelaide: Ok... we want Butler and Waters
West Coast: ******** off.
Adelaide: Ok... we want Butler and a 1st round pick
West Coast: ******** off.
Adelaide: Ok.. how about first and 2nd round draft pick
West Coast: *yawn* ******** off
Adelaide: Please we beg you... give us a 1st round pick and Callum Chambers.
West Coast: ok deal.

Adelaide: Ha ha suckers - I can't believe we got a 1st rnd pick for a slow tagger. Chambers is a great boot studder.

West Coast (mid-2005): @#$$&(@$!^!!!!!

 

[Jabber]

mate you have no f***** idea my point is that in that article your assistant coach said the two players were in his view keepers
my point is if John Worsfold doesnt think so then they will go

of course you football department is going to make the actaual trade but would be up to the coach which player he does or doesnt want

Of course Tony Micale just spews his opinions to the media without first consulting the football department. If he said it, then Woosha agrees.

 

[Cap]

Of course Tony Micale just spews his opinions to the media without first consulting the football department. If he said it, then Woosha agrees.

ok great one
so i suppose he asks worsfold when he can fart

 

[Total Package]

You know NOTHING about what West Coast will or will not do.

You are such a child.

pssst... just between you and me.... I kinda do.

 

[crazzzy_grrl]

ok great one
so i suppose he asks worsfold when he can fart

If it has anything to do with the team, probably