So you're going to pick Heater Biggie?
I wouldn't be picking him, Gilbee and Mcleod all in the backline that's for sure.
-
LIVE: Sydney v Brisbane Lions - 2:30PM AEST Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 61% chance -- What's your tip? -- Ticketing Buy, Sell -- Teams on Thurs »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Supercoach 2009 - Discussions
- Thread starter #6 Mark Williams
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
So you're going to pick Heater Biggie?
I wouldn't be picking him, Gilbee and Mcleod all in the backline that's for sure.
Gilbee?
Look forward to your dummy spits in during the season after you miss out on his early high scores.
Shaw could be a sleeper, everyone is shit scared of him.
Still might get gilbee in my team mate, he is a proven SC gun. I'm just saying its a risk having all the ones i mentioned in the same backline. One of them might be ok.
I just put Gilbee in my team, took Heater out as I just don't trust him being able to shake off a tag anymore.
Loving the look of my team now, it looks awesome!
Loving the look of my team now, it looks awesome!
Current team:
Backs: H. Shaw, Gilbee, Mcleod, Malceski, Cornes, McPhee, Hill (Trengove, R. O'Keeffe)
Midfield: Judd, Kerr, Deledio, Murphy, Haselby, Rich (Dangerfield, Robinson)
Rucks: Ottens, McIntosh (Vickery, Currie)
Forwards: Pavlich, J. Brown, B. Johnson, Lucas, Didak, Higgins, Yarran (Sidebottom, Gumbleton)
$83,900 left in the kitty.
1) who should be my starting 18 rookie in defense? I currently have Hill, but am worried he wont get enough game time
2) Higgins or Veszpremi?
3) Shaw or Millburn?
Backs: H. Shaw, Gilbee, Mcleod, Malceski, Cornes, McPhee, Hill (Trengove, R. O'Keeffe)
Midfield: Judd, Kerr, Deledio, Murphy, Haselby, Rich (Dangerfield, Robinson)
Rucks: Ottens, McIntosh (Vickery, Currie)
Forwards: Pavlich, J. Brown, B. Johnson, Lucas, Didak, Higgins, Yarran (Sidebottom, Gumbleton)
$83,900 left in the kitty.
1) who should be my starting 18 rookie in defense? I currently have Hill, but am worried he wont get enough game time
2) Higgins or Veszpremi?
3) Shaw or Millburn?
There is about $4k difference in the price of these 2 different pairings that I am currently considering.
Bartel & Foley - Bartel started slowly last year & dropped a lot of value but came home with a rush later in the season. From memory he had a problem with his back for a while. Foley was probably a little disappointing after starring in the Origin game. If Cuz can stay fit I think foley may be third choice to mind after Cuz & Lids.
versus
Selwood & Cross - Selwood keeps getting better each year but has to share time with a star studded midfield. I still think he has the chance to grow a bit in value though. Cross is just super consistent & racks up the points each week not as damaging by foot which probably limits him getting the really huge scores.
Which pairing to go for at this early stage?
Bartel & Foley - Bartel started slowly last year & dropped a lot of value but came home with a rush later in the season. From memory he had a problem with his back for a while. Foley was probably a little disappointing after starring in the Origin game. If Cuz can stay fit I think foley may be third choice to mind after Cuz & Lids.
versus
Selwood & Cross - Selwood keeps getting better each year but has to share time with a star studded midfield. I still think he has the chance to grow a bit in value though. Cross is just super consistent & racks up the points each week not as damaging by foot which probably limits him getting the really huge scores.
Which pairing to go for at this early stage?
- Mar 30, 2007
- 597
- 4
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Definitely Selwood and Cross.
Answereing a question with a question: why do you need to have one?
hey guys just need a couple of opinions out of:
josh drummond and brendon goddard
daniel kerr and scott pendlebury and marc murphy and bryce gibbs
lance franklin and brent harvey and ryan okeefe
cheers guys
josh drummond and brendon goddard
daniel kerr and scott pendlebury and marc murphy and bryce gibbs
lance franklin and brent harvey and ryan okeefe
cheers guys
- Mar 30, 2007
- 597
- 4
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Itsblackandwhite
Senior List
Fellow coaches
In a bit of a dilemna, would be great if i could get some advise on a couple of players/scenarios
What do you think of players like Shane Tuck (mid) Brennan (Forward) - who finished of the year with some solid above 100 performances - consistency ? will they play in the same position. New arrivals changing their roles ?
Chris Masten - regular spot in west coast midfield ?
Heath Scotland - has he done well over the years ? better to go for more established supercoach players ?
Dale Thomas or Alwyn Davey - Hearing Dale gets more midfield time this year
I know its a lot of points - if anyone has any input or views - thanks in advance. Good Luck
In a bit of a dilemna, would be great if i could get some advise on a couple of players/scenarios
What do you think of players like Shane Tuck (mid) Brennan (Forward) - who finished of the year with some solid above 100 performances - consistency ? will they play in the same position. New arrivals changing their roles ?
Chris Masten - regular spot in west coast midfield ?
Heath Scotland - has he done well over the years ? better to go for more established supercoach players ?
Dale Thomas or Alwyn Davey - Hearing Dale gets more midfield time this year
I know its a lot of points - if anyone has any input or views - thanks in advance. Good Luck
Biggie
Eat better and exercise
- Moderator
- #291
I like Tuck.
Although I have GAblett atm, I did have Tuck for quite a while. May still go back and free up cash but wil decide after NAB obv.
Brennan, nah.
Masten, looks to be pumped up by his team mates, and may be a good buy.
Scotland, nah.
Dale Thomas IMO, a different approach.
Although I have GAblett atm, I did have Tuck for quite a while. May still go back and free up cash but wil decide after NAB obv.
Brennan, nah.
Masten, looks to be pumped up by his team mates, and may be a good buy.
Scotland, nah.
Dale Thomas IMO, a different approach.
Shane Tuck is one I'd expect to lose midfield time with Couglan, Cousins, Cotchin, Tambling & Deledio increasing there midfield time. I know he finished strongly but competition has increased. Pass
Brennan - Most difficult player in SC to understand. pass
Masten - could be good but is a handballer - good prospect
Scotland - Has a lot of competition but worth considering
Dale Thomas - Have to see were he plays
Davey- On my short list
This pleases me, since I may try an Essendon forward line and put Lucas, Davey AND Skipworth in there.
Just kidding, I dont have room, but I have Lucas and Davey in there, and if Skippy is going to get games, I might ditch one for him.
Whom should I kick out?
What's your starting midfield look like?
Still dosn't give me the confidence he will be starting though SJ05.
Is there players ahead of him?
Drummond, if you could gaurantee 22 games out of him he would be my first selected. But you cant, and he will most likely play 12 matches, though 12 decent scoring matches. Far too injury prone im afraid which is a shame.hey guys just need a couple of opinions out of:
josh drummond and brendon goddard
daniel kerr and scott pendlebury and marc murphy and bryce gibbs
lance franklin and brent harvey and ryan okeefe
cheers guys
Kerr. Top 3 player in the league.
And Harvey, purely because Franklin has had an interupted pre season. And i think its fair to say that teams have been working hard over the summer to triple team him so that will no doubt effect his scoring ability.
Masten will be a regular midfielder.
Scotland is a gun when injury free. Always seems to be carrying niggles and has had an interupted pre season.
Thomas V Davey is an interesting one. Davey comming off the big knee though so id say Thomas to be safe.
Not A grade, but im reasonably happy with it.
Judd, Kornes, Kerr, Cotchin, Coughlan, Rich
With Dangerfield and Mitch Robinson as my reserves at this stage.
I had Griffen, but upgraded to Kornes when i found some spare cash.
Itsblackandwhite
Senior List
Is it too risky starting yarran and gumbleton in the forwards ?
Though it gives me 5 elite backs 3 elite mids and 3 elite forwards
Or is it safer to go yarran and dale thomas with 4 elite and a david myers/raines sorta defender ? 2 elite and kerr'ish/bateman'ish/boak'ish kinda mid ?
Though it gives me 5 elite backs 3 elite mids and 3 elite forwards
Or is it safer to go yarran and dale thomas with 4 elite and a david myers/raines sorta defender ? 2 elite and kerr'ish/bateman'ish/boak'ish kinda mid ?
- Status
