![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/sydney.png)
- Nov 11, 2012
- 36,282
- 42,559
- AFL Club
- Sydney
I willI'm not really following.
But hey, if you dump on most of our players at some point, you can come along and tell us you knew all along I guess, when some of them don't turn out.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
I willI'm not really following.
But hey, if you dump on most of our players at some point, you can come along and tell us you knew all along I guess, when some of them don't turn out.
I just think Horse has to trust these players like Cleary, Warner Jr. etc.Selection has been quite peculiar to be fair.
Average because he was playing injured for most of the match.Fox hurt too sucks , though he was average last week
Average because he was playing injured for most of the match.
Sent from my Pixel 8 Pro using Tapatalk
Do we all think Warner really has a sore calf?
Did you see his last game? Didn't look like a guy who was short of a run or lacking match fitness. Would've been the perfect time to give him a go.Perhaps it's because he has played only 4 games since May and you know is working his way back to AFL fitness rather than Horse just hates the bloke.
You can go back to 1998 and pretty much the only time we have selected well in the first round has been selecting twice in it or matching on Swans academy players. If its a singular selection of a non Swans academy player. Zak Jones and Jarrad McVeigh are the only exceptions to this rule in over a quarter of a century.I'm disappointed that Gus isn't in this week, but in no way surprised.
What does really disappoint me - Stephens, Gus, Konstanty. We do love to torch a first rounder. And I don't think the club's management of any of them has helped.
That’s a very fair point.Sheldrick can't get a game because he can only play 1 position.
Cleary, Campbell, Roberts, Warner are all in the team playing in positions they weren't originally drafted for
We brought Sheldrick in as a forward before and everyone lost their mind.
He'll have to wait until his spot in the middle opens up.
Sheldrick can't get a game because he can only play 1 position.
Cleary, Campbell, Roberts, Warner are all in the team playing in positions they weren't originally drafted for
We brought Sheldrick in as a forward before and everyone lost their mind.
He'll have to wait until his spot in the middle opens up.
Adams forward?That’s a very fair point.
My counter is that Parker and Adams are both capable half-forwards. Our forward line without Papley is fairly impotent.
Should we be considering moving both of them forward, thus opening the spot up?
They're drafted on talent. Being flexible comes into the equation.You can sort of never guess it judging from the VFL i dont know if its a clear direction but most of the players we draft never actually play in their positions :S
Adams isn't a forward. Parker is probably still a better mid than SheldrickThat’s a very fair point.
My counter is that Parker and Adams are both capable half-forwards. Our forward line without Papley is fairly impotent.
Should we be considering moving both of them forward, thus opening the spot up?
You can go back to 1998 and pretty much the only time we have selected well in the first round has been selecting twice in it or matching on Swans academy players. If its a singular selection of a non Swans academy player. Zak Jones and Jarrad McVeigh are the only exceptions to this rule in over a quarter of a century.
Heres to the 2025 draft with 2 first round selections hey