List Mgmt. The 2024 Draft (Nov 20/21)

Remove this Banner Ad

  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #3

Quick links

Key Dates
• Oct 17 to Nov 8: Pick swap window
• Nov 1 to Nov 8: Delisted free agency period
• Nov 20-21: Telstra AFL Draft
• Nov 22: Telstra Pre-Season Draft and Rookie Draft

List Spots Available
• 6 Main list
• 1 Rookie list

Current Draft Picks
• Main Draft - 12,26,73,81,99
• Rookie Draft - 3

Recent News
• Luke Edwards delisted after deciding to step away from football due to ongoing concussion symptoms
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

If so that looks like a late pick for a KP defender is on the cards.

Not surprising just indicates we wont go early on a KP defender.
Agreed. Dennis is a far better prospect than Bell IMO but like I mentioned a few weeks ago, he’s very unlikely to get past the 50s. Getting 46 off Essendon in a pick swap and taking Dennis would be good business if he’s still available and we don’t plan on using an early pick on a KPD. A combo of Lindsay, Oliver, Moraes/Davis/Ough and Dennis would be a good result.
 
Agreed. Dennis is a far better prospect than Bell IMO but like I mentioned a few weeks ago, he’s very unlikely to get past the 50s. Getting 46 off Essendon in a pick swap and taking Dennis would be good business if he’s still available and we don’t plan on using an early pick on a KPD. A combo of Lindsay, Oliver, Moraes/Davis/Ough and Dennis would be a good result.

Yep. Dennis should be plan A.

Bell plan B maybe? Even a rookie spot for Bell plus Dennis late in the draft would firm up our list profile a tad.

Grab the next local Barrass in the 3rd round. Job done.
 
Yep. Dennis should be plan A.

Bell plan B maybe? Even a rookie spot for Bell plus Dennis late in the draft would firm up our list profile a tad.

Grab the next local Barrass in the 3rd round. Job done.
There’s a couple of good options late. Stumpf with his athletic profile would be a late pick I’d be happy with to develop as a KPD and would suit Harry Edwards if he can make it. Zaydyn Lockwood is another late pick that I like. eaglespremiers would have the best mail on him.

Don’t want to go early on a Whitlock (after 30 absolute minimum) and no thanks to Gerreyn.

I wouldn’t leave O’Farrell or Barrat on the board if available and we got Essendon picks 28 and 31.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Yep. Dennis should be plan A.

Bell plan B maybe? Even a rookie spot for Bell plus Dennis late in the draft would firm up our list profile a tad.

Grab the next local Barrass in the 3rd round. Job done.

Has Dennis done 2 naviculars already? The article suggests so. If it is the case, that is a pretty big red flag and could even mean he slides into the rookie draft surely.
 
Has Dennis done 2 naviculars already? The article suggests so. If it is the case, that is a pretty big red flag and could even mean he slides into the rookie draft surely.
Poorly reported. Not comparable to the Navicular injury Mraz sustained for example. Very confident he’s not getting past Collingwood’s three picks in the 50s.
 
Again, refer to Hawthorn’s method this year and see how improving bottom end, can improve a whole team performance.

Your argument last time I said this was “yea but I don’t think they can win a premiership” now you are saying, you can’t get out of the bottom 6 using this method??

You’re going around in circles Malakai Champion.
The assignment is to build a flag side (multiple flag side), rather than build a side that stays mid table. Focus on the top end, and the bottom end will come.
 
Sorry i'm back after being sucked into the US Presidential election wormhole for a couple of weeks.

What's the verdict on Knobel? He's been delisted by the Dockers right? Is he someone we can pick up? Is he worth it?

From what i've seen he seems to have more potential than any of our young rucks?
 
The assignment is to build a flag side (multiple flag side), rather than build a side that stays mid table. Focus on the top end, and the bottom end will come.
Completely agree. However you said 'In What world do you think improving the bottom 6 will improve our team'.

I've simply replied to that comment - asking you to look at Hawthorns model as they finished 16th, added 4 depth players and 12 months later were a kick away from a prelim. Once again, not saying this is my preference for West Coast to do the same, but you are contradicting yourself.

Hawthorn's plan, was build bottom end, become competitive and then attract top end, which is exactly what they have done and will go into 2025 as a potential top 4 side, when 18 months before they were bottom 4.

Along the way you need natural progression from younger players, need a nice draw from the AFL and need senior players to stay healthy.
 
Pretending there's only one to go about this is the issue
Yep. The definition of improvement is to raise the average skill level.

That can be done in a number of ways. Increase top end. Increase bottom end. Improvement of all players. Or probably all of those. (Others?)

And ‘improvement of all’ can be done in various ways. New coach. New game style. Better training. Better ‘standards’. Better surroundings (e.g. admin, facilities). Etc etc

Could also bring in external factors like less travel. More home games. Blah blah.

It gets a bit tiresome hearing people claim there is only one formula and that they know it - to the exclusion of all other views. Black and white thinking.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. The 2024 Draft (Nov 20/21)

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top