Roast The $$Dump$$ Thread

[Westcoast88]

Sadly, even another bottom 4 finish next year will not likely be enough to rid us of Nisbett or Simpson.

Simpson won us a flag in 2018 and as much as I don't like the Hunt trade, Simpson deserves a chance.

 

[PremiershipNo4]

Robertson too young for retirement home eagles. We need 27+ age bracket according to our great posters, never mind that we finished second last have one of the oldest lists in the afl and the worst under 23's in the comp. We need experience, well more experience you can never have too much you see. I think Priddis should come back too we need that age bracket, we love a golden oldie at the Eagles. I know why don't we trade for Lobb wouldn't he make us a better team, too old you say ? Codswallop we will just let him go easy on the training put on a bit of a gut, he will fit in real well. Our supporters here don't really care about flags anyway we just wanna see a 12th place finish that would be a huge success here in the forums to hell with the top 4 too much long term planning and it hurts my brain to think that far out at the best of times.

What a load of rubbish

 

[ChasingFlags25]

What a load of rubbish

100% agree!!

 

[Biggie]

I don't like the Hunt trade,

Is trade the right word for this?

Free Agent signing, and I’m not a fan either

 

[Keys]

I dont think we have ever had a great half fwd?
I would love to have a Robbie Gray type rather than cobble together a fwd line.
Our last 2 flag teams had
2006 : Stenglein, Chick & Armstrong
2018 : Cripps, Rioli & Venables.
No match winners there

Heady?
Lewis?
Lecras?

 

[TerryFilk]

I dont think we have ever had a great half fwd?
I would love to have a Robbie Gray type rather than cobble together a fwd line.
Our last 2 flag teams had
2006 : Stenglein, Chick & Armstrong
2018 : Cripps, Rioli & Venables.
No match winners there

AA Liam Ryan put together an incredibly dominant season at HF, LeCras was amazing for us as well

I just think you can find them types of players later in drafts, you do not need to spend pick 2 on them, I really like Sheezel, just not for us.

 

[dinnaz]

Heady?
Lewis?
Lecras?

All good players (Lewis was one of my faves) yet are below the level of literally the entire best ever WCE team which can boast GOATS in nearly every line.

 

[amazingjoshy]

All good players (Lewis was one of my faves) yet are below the level of literally the entire best ever WCE team which can boast GOATS in nearly every line.

If it's not ANY of those 3, who's on our fwd flanks and pockets in your best ever 22?

Lecras is a walk up and the other 2 def have a claim. All 3 absolutely match winners in their own right

 

[JDWCE]

If it's not ANY of those 3, who's on our fwd flanks and pockets in your best ever 22?

Lecras is a walk up and the other 2 def have a claim. All 3 absolutely match winners in their own right

Has to be tnem surely, I’ve got all three the way I see it…


FB Wirrpanda Glass Mcgovern

HB McKenna Jakovich Hurn

C Matera Kemp Cousins

HF Heady Kennedy Lewis

FF Lecras Sumich Darling

R Cox Judd Kerr

I Nicnat Shuey Pyke Worsfold

 

[twadds]

Has to be tnem surely, I’ve got all three the way I see it…


FB Wirrpanda Glass Mcgovern

HB McKenna Jakovich Hurn

C Matera Kemp Cousins

HF Heady Kennedy Lewis

FF Lecras Sumich Darling

R Cox Judd Kerr

I Nicnat Shuey Pyke Worsfold

McIntosh over Glass. IMO

 

[JDWCE]

McIntosh over Glass. IMO

Always miss someone

 

[Obeanie1]

I dont think we have ever had a great half fwd?
I would love to have a Robbie Gray type rather than cobble together a fwd line.
Our last 2 flag teams had
2006 : Stenglein, Chick & Armstrong
2018 : Cripps, Rioli & Venables.
No match winners there

Your showing you age here.

Chris Lewis and Brett Heady were pretty decent.

 

[Mop]

McIntosh over Glass. IMO

And both over McGovern.

Which, to bring this back to draftees, I would love us to get Big Busslinger. Not at 2 though

 

[Mop]

Has to be tnem surely, I’ve got all three the way I see it…


FB Wirrpanda Glass Mcgovern

HB McKenna Jakovich Hurn

C Matera Kemp Cousins

HF Heady Kennedy Lewis

FF Lecras Sumich Darling

R Cox Judd Kerr

I Nicnat Shuey Pyke Worsfold

Braun over Pyke?
Would love to fit Brad Sheppard in there somewhere but struggling unless you move Woosh into the coaches box, but realistically Malthouse gets that gig with two flags.

 

[MrWoollie]

I dont think we have ever had a great half fwd?
I would love to have a Robbie Gray type rather than cobble together a fwd line.
Our last 2 flag teams had
2006 : Stenglein, Chick & Armstrong
2018 : Cripps, Rioli & Venables.
No match winners there

Heady?
Lewis?
Lecras?

Phil Matera was no scrubber.

Heady - 156 games for 237 goals at 1.52 per game
Lewis - 215 games for 259 goals at 1.2
LeCras - 219 games for 441 goals at 2.01 per game
Matera - 179 games for 389 goals at 2.17 per game

compare to
Eddie Betts - 350 games for 640 @ 1.83
Robbie Gray - 271 games for 367 @ 1.35
Ballantyne - 171 games for 254 @ 1.49 (the comedy entry in this company - just for comparison as the best the muppetts have had)

My 2 would be LeCras and either Phil Matera or Chris Lewis, who was possibly the most talented player we have ever had.

Edit - I don't think there have been that many half forwards in the AFL era who averaged 2 goals a game for a full career. And we've had two.

 

[Truckosaurus]

Speaking a bit about the draft in general.

Yes it seems Nisbett has sent the word out and i am blacklisted from anything WCE related.

Lucky you didn't wake up to Jackson Nelson's severed head on your pillow.

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

Speaking a bit about the draft in general.

Yes it seems Nisbett has sent the word out and i am blacklisted from anything WCE related.

You silly kent

 

[WCE_phil]

Lucky you didn't wake up Jackson Nelson's severed head on your pillow.

The next time one of Bob Peters racehorses dies Nisbett might end up with a special delivery via courier.

 

[kranky al]

i'll rephrase, those were the numbers of OOTF from set shots. I didn't count in play rushed shots outside of the official goal and behind figures that everyone has.

The word is North are seriously considering Cadman with their first.

West Coast staff refuse to to talk to me after my outburst at Nisbett at his little private asslicking parade.

Expect a surprise top 10 draft pick.

Also expect someone who may have only been mentioned on here maybe a max of once to be taken in the top 30 picks. I'm sure more will come to light on these two in the coming few weeks leading into the draft.

I may be called in for a couple of player interviews in regards to trades this week however it's a quiet week until I'm absolutely flat out during the interview stage of the combine and discussions with families.

After the combine I finally get to come back to WA and away from this shithole.

Pray tell what outburst was this?

 

[kane249]

Pray tell what outburst was this?

Just walked out of the box with John Castrilli and told Nisbett to go * himself. Won't be in that box again.

 

[ArdentEagle]

boom or bust shot, however the boom far outweighs the bust

Don't want to know about his sex life! ...Actually, tell me more!

 

[WCEswift]

Don't want to know about his sex life! ...Actually, tell me more!

Something something tent

 

[random260]

If Harley Reid was available this year I’d think West Coast would be taking him at pick 2 and he’s only going to stand out more next year you would think.

Yeah WCE will not get pick 1 next year. There is zero chance. Think we should all forget about him.

1) Simmo will get the boot
2) I don't think in our history we finished 2 seasons worse

 

[CountryLad]

Yeah WCE will not get pick 1 next year. There is zero chance. Think we should all forget about him.

1) Simmo will get the boot
2) I don't think in our history we finished 2 seasons worse

Everyone is entitled to there opinion and if your correct it will be a good thing.
However I wouldn’t be trading our future 1st and I really doubt the clubs even considering it.

 

[Priddis Is Done]

Si

Yeah WCE will not get pick 1 next year. There is zero chance. Think we should all forget about him.

1) Simmo will get the boot
2) I don't think in our history we finished 2 seasons worse

Simmo getting the boot end of next year with 2 more years to run is never going to happen.