The Western Bulldogs Next Coach

Who do you want to be the next coach of the Western Bulldogs?

  • Total voters
    304

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Zgope1 said:
What year was that?
Click to expand...

2007.

Ozimandas said:
Meanehile back on planet earth. Our club cannot afford the luxury of quiet coach.

Next year may be a tough year on the field. If our coach cant sell then we will get destroyed in the media. Then our sponsors will get hit.

Do you think our sponsors have not been approached by other clubs or organizations in the last month?

We were out for the count last week. We hit back we ith Boyd.

Unfortunately this is just the first round. A bad season and we will have sponsors and players looking elseware.

Just in case we dont win the flag next year!
Click to expand...

Whether someone is media friendly is secondary as far as I am concerned. We are having a tough year next year irrespective of the coach. I want a coach who will deliver sustained success first and foremost.

There are plenty of other people in the organisation looking after sponsors, etc, its far from the coach's primary role and shouldn't be a driving consideration in our coach selection process.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Leigh Tudor Coaching Resume
Calder Cannons Asst. Coach 2001-2003
Western Jets Coach 2004
Geelong VFL Coach 2005-2008: P'Ship 2007
St Kilda Asst. Coach 2009-2010
Sydney Asst. Coach 2011-2013
North Melbourne 2014-

Brett Montgomery Coaching Resume
Carlton FC Ass. Coach 2007-2010
Western Bulldogs Snr Asst. Coach 2010- Current

Brett Ratten Coaching Resume
Melbourne FC Asst. Coach 2004
Norwood (EFL) Snr. Coach 2005-2006
Carlton FC Asst. Coach 2007
Carlton FC Snr. Coach 2008-2011
Hawthorn FC- 2012- Current

Scott West Coaching Resume
Melbourne Asst. Coach 2009-2011
Werribee FC (VFL) Snr Coach 2012-2013

Peter Sumich Coaching Resume
South Fremantle Snr Coach 2000-2001
West Coast Eagles FC Ass. Coach 2002-2011
Fremantle FC Asst. Coach 2011- Current

Brendan Bolton Coaching Resume
North Hobart (SFL) Snr Coach 2003-2005 P'Ship 2003
Tassie Devils (VFL) Snr Coach 2006
Clarence (TFL) Snr Coach 2008
Box Hill (VFL) Snr Coach 2009-2010
Hawthorn FC Asst. Coach 2011-

And for shits and gigs...

Mark Thompson Coaching Resume
Geelong FC Snr Coach 2000-2010 P'Ship 2007 & 2009
Essendon Asst. Coach and Snr Coach 2010-2014
 
But it is a box that needs to be ticked. IMO it is more relivent than being an assistant in a succesful club.

Just because a club is not succesful does not mean as an assistant should be viewed more or less favourably.

Monty may have learnt more in a tough 12 monthes at the bulldogs than tudor in 6 years of cruising in the fast lane.
 
black pup said:
I would be totally pissed off, if Tudor was appointed.
I'm told close race between Summich and Monty.
To close to call at the moment.
Click to expand...

Mate if the selection committee met for the first time yesterday, you would assume they haven't shortlisted or even interviewed all the candidates within 24hrs....find it hard to understand how its a two horse race just yet.
 
This is such a hard call. Do we go for someone who is a favourite son like Westy or Monty, or do we get new blood in from somewhere else?

All i can say is that yes the coach is important, but it all comes down to the cattle on the park in my view
 
If we hire a First Year Coach I expect to have a Director of Coaching with him.
It's to much of a risk now letting them go on their own
 
Ozimandas said:
But it is a box that needs to be ticked. IMO it is more relivent than being an assistant in a succesful club.

Just because a club is not succesful does not mean as an assistant should be viewed more or less favourably.

Monty may have learnt more in a tough 12 monthes at the bulldogs than tudor in 6 years of cruising in the fast lane.
Click to expand...

You may be right, or alternatively, that the last 12 months being tough could well have been contributed to by Monty - we don't know.

Personally, prefer our candidate to have experienced success in a coaching environment. But its by no means a guarantee.

Take Geelong assistants (Sanderson, sacked, Macca, sacked, Hinkley a god apparently. Take Collingwood's, Neeld sacked, Watters sacked, Scott going ok. Take Syd assistants, Longmire, awesome, Lyon pretty handy. But then the mentors of the aforementioned, Malthouse, Roos and Bomber go to different clubs and have done squat.

As someone said, its about the cattle, but its also identifying and training the cattle.

We are going to have to trust the club that their process will identify the right person. The club's handling of the Macca situation has not inspired confidence though.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

And the winner is 56 year old

MARK CHOCO WILLIAMS
Coaching career3
YearsClubGames (W–L–D)
1999–2010Port Adelaide274 (151–121–2)
MARK CHOCO WILLIAMS

2011-12 - Senior Assistant GWS
2012-current Assistant Richmond


Collingwood captain 1983-1986
Copeland winner 1981 & 1985
Premiership Coach 2004 &
Runner/up 2007
 
Maple WB Coach, that would be the West Gate Bridge for me, straight over the top.
Some goose wanted him for senior coach.
I think Yebiga could have coached that Footscray premiership with the list we had lol.
Just to explain my point, I said I would prefer Scott West coaching Footscray, than another Macca who has not played at senior level. We had two senior coaches at the club, who at not played at senior level, pretty hard task.
Have I changed my Mind. ABSOLUTELY NOT.
 
Edited for completeness, Choc may be good, but shit he has some big flaws that are of concern.

yebiga said:
And the winner is 56 year old

MARK CHOCO WILLIAMS
Coaching career3
YearsClubGames (W–L–D)
1999–2010Port Adelaide274 (151–121–2)
MARK CHOCO WILLIAMS

2011-12 - Senior Assistant GWS
2012-current Assistant Richmond


Collingwood captain 1983-1986
Copeland winner 1981 & 1985
Premiership Coach 2004 - after which his grand final speech lacked grace, slammed a major sponsor and contributed to dividing his club
Runner/up 2007 Loser by greatest ever losing margin in a grand final. After which the club imploded and Port's viability was questioned and only sustained with massive AFL assistance. [/QUOTE]
Click to expand...
 
black pup said:
Maple WB Coach, that would be the West Gate Bridge for me, straight over the top.
Some goose wanted him for senior coach.
I think Yebiga could have coached that Footscray premiership with the list we had lol.
Just to explain my point, I said I would prefer Scott West coaching Footscray, than another Macca who has not played at senior level. We had two senior coaches at the club, who at not played at senior level, pretty hard task.
Have I changed my Mind. ABSOLUTELY NOT.
Click to expand...
It would be interesting to know how significant a role Joel Corey played in our VFL team - he was certainly in the box with maple.
 
Ozimandas said:
Meanehile back on planet earth. Our club cannot afford the luxury of quiet coach.

Next year may be a tough year on the field. If our coach cant sell then we will get destroyed in the media. Then our sponsors will get hit.

Do you think our sponsors have not been approached by other clubs or organizations in the last month?

We were out for the count last week. We hit back we ith Boyd.

Unfortunately this is just the first round. A bad season and we will have sponsors and players looking elseware.

Just in case we dont win the flag next year!
Click to expand...
Agree, the coach and the captain need to be good communicators, unfortunately both Brendan and Ryan had the personalities of a doormat, hence contributed to our irrelevance tag.
 
Any chance the selection committee comprised of Darcy/Grant/Garlick and Woosha. Has been formed to make an offer to Woosha he couldn't refuse. Allowing him some solid think time to assess whether he firmly believes the outcome we want is achievable, without media following him everywhere he goes. We need a premiership coach, any of Woosha/Bomber/choco fit the bill in my eyes. Anyone else is a bigger risk.
 
yebiga said:
Well lets air them, what are they, in your view?
Click to expand...

Read your post that I quoted. He can be divisive. He's a very loose unit. GWS passed him over. He left his club in disarray.

Having said that he has his good points too.
 
BRG93 said:
Leigh Tudor Coaching Resume
Calder Cannons Asst. Coach 2001-2003
Western Jets Coach 2004
Geelong VFL Coach 2005-2008: P'Ship 2007
St Kilda Asst. Coach 2009-2010
Sydney Asst. Coach 2011-2013
North Melbourne 2014-

Brett Montgomery Coaching Resume
Carlton FC Ass. Coach 2007-2010
Western Bulldogs Snr Asst. Coach 2010- Current

Brett Ratten Coaching Resume
Melbourne FC Asst. Coach 2004
Norwood (EFL) Snr. Coach 2005-2006
Carlton FC Asst. Coach 2007
Carlton FC Snr. Coach 2008-2011
Hawthorn FC- 2012- Current

Scott West Coaching Resume
Melbourne Asst. Coach 2009-2011
Werribee FC (VFL) Snr Coach 2012-2013

Peter Sumich Coaching Resume
South Fremantle Snr Coach 2000-2001
West Coast Eagles FC Ass. Coach 2002-2011
Fremantle FC Asst. Coach 2011- Current

Brendan Bolton Coaching Resume
North Hobart (SFL) Snr Coach 2003-2005 P'Ship 2003
Tassie Devils (VFL) Snr Coach 2006
Clarence (TFL) Snr Coach 2008
Box Hill (VFL) Snr Coach 2009-2010
Hawthorn FC Asst. Coach 2011-

And for shits and gigs...

Mark Thompson Coaching Resume
Geelong FC Snr Coach 2000-2010 P'Ship 2007 & 2009
Essendon Asst. Coach and Snr Coach 2010-2014
Click to expand...

Leigh Tudor most certainly followed the good teams around didn't he. No brainer in my opinion. In some capacity we need someone like him to rectify our defensive issues. If he has put his hand up I would be putting him in charge.
 
Ok, one more time, then everybody please shut up about it. I'll make it big and bold so you all get it:

Worsfold is not going to be our coach. He is not going to be coaching any club.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Eastdog
Western Bulldogs and the MCG factor
2 3
Replies
72
Views
3K
Dogs_r_barking
Dogs_r_barking
Fossie 32
2025 Western Bulldogs Men's Sponsorship
Replies
4
Views
220
dogwatch
dogwatch
Dav1d
Analysis Western Bulldogs 2024 Mock Draft
7 8 9 10 11
Replies
265
Views
11K
Munnez
M
_Mike_
  • Sticky
Official Club Stuff Western Bulldogs 2024 NAB Draft, Trades, & PSD tracker (no discussion)
Replies
0
Views
1K
_Mike_
_Mike_
Optimistic Dog
Opinion Who Do We Want As Our Next Coach
2 3
Replies
69
Views
3K
redmania
R
Testekill
Welcome to the Bulldogs Matthew Kennedy
2 3 4
Replies
91
Views
7K
Hoges64
Hoges64
stefoid
western bulldogs fringe festival
Replies
18
Views
2K
Freshwater
Freshwater
Back
Top