Recommitted Tom Papley [wanted to return to Victoria, nominated Carlton - didn't get there]
- Thread starter Punts
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Oct 16, 2016
- 9,189
- 18,463
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Yeah no. Charlie Cameron had kicked 5 goals in a preliminary final and was quite obviously an absolute gun about to have a breakout season. Charlie Cameron was and is a better prospect than Papley. So yeah no!
If i had to chose a player between a 2017 Cameron or a 2019 Papley
I would take Papley but Cameron had an amazing year this year
The question would need to be does Papley have much more improvement and can he maintain this level
But pick #8 which will eventually become pick #10 looks about the value
I would take Papley but Cameron had an amazing year this year
The question would need to be does Papley have much more improvement and can he maintain this level
But pick #8 which will eventually become pick #10 looks about the value
Like in what kind of ****ed up stupid crazy ****ing universe is Papley on par with Weitering? It’s just STUPID. If you’ve actually been told this- then tell the teller to get some intense therapy. Or tell them “just tell Carlton it’s not happening.” But don’t be dickheads.
In a similar way to the Tigers theme song has put Adelaide players off bus trips....
We want an established player. Pick 8 just gets another homesick teenager.
We've loaded up on those youngsters these last few drafts so it will be an established player to fill a need or Paps just stays as the club has said. It has to be something we need.
Touchy lot over there, aren't they GUNlol still having nightmares are you about our norm smith medallist
Poor old Drewie's had a shocker of a day....
nice return lollol still having nightmares are you about our norm smith medallist
No, you want big Joe.
We've got Papley.
Carlton have Papley? Really?
My name geoff
Premiership Player
- Jul 2, 2015
- 4,523
- 6,097
- AFL Club
- Carlton
.......... Plowman ....
........... .......... .......
O’Brien Stocker Kennedy
Papley McGovern......
.......... DeKoning.......
Philips ........ ..........
Thanks Crows!
Yeah he kicked 3 goals in the prelim. And 24 goals total in the other 24 games that year.
Thats what happens when you bring a knife ............... To a GUN fightTouchy lot over there, aren't they GUN
Poor old Drewie's had a shocker of a day....
Hahaha
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
What if you could trade pick 8 for a player?
Wouldn't that be crazy
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
- May 1, 2002
- 12,129
- 20,683
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Papley is not Chris Judd - we won't be that 'desperate' this time and we now have SOS. End of discussion.
You'd have to add steak knives to make it work. Mills and Blakey as a starting point along with Papley. Weitering is a required player and contracted.
Edit: Personally, if you took Lang with you I'd give Weiters to you for free.
Blue and Silver
Brownlow Medallist
I guess Sydney might be weirdly fixated on one player, but unless Weitering wants to go, this seems stupid.
Your team will consider other options including trading any pick you may get for a player you want (who actually wants to come)
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
The Filth Wizard
Just here for the zipline
- Jul 26, 2007
- 95,431
- 171,832
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Coney Island Warriors
- Moderator
- #450
First time we've been properly linked, bar the "and North" references.
Roos join Blues in hunt for star Swans forward
Callum Twomey
Sep 13, 2019 1:50PM
NORTH Melbourne has joined Carlton in trying to lure goalkicker Tom Papley out of Sydney.
The Blues have been public in their ambitions to add to their small forward ranks this off-season, and are keen to pry Papley from the Swans.
But AFL.com.au understands the Blues are not alone in the hunt for Papley, with the Kangaroos also circling.
New North Melbourne coach Rhyce Shaw has a strong relationship with Papley from his time at the Swans as an assistant coach.
The Swans remain adamant that Papley will remain with the club next year and have a strong position after AFL.com.au revealed that the 23-year-old is contracted to the club until the end of 2023 after reaching a trigger clause
But clubs have felt Papley could be on the move having been unsettled in Sydney at different stages of the past 12 months.
He has not requested a trade from the Swans, who are steadfast that he will not be leaving to return home to Victoria. He was originally drafted as a rookie out of the Gippsland Power at the end of 2015.
It is unclear whether the changes within North Melbourne's recruiting and list management department will affect its interest in Papley.
The club confirmed this week it will be parting ways with list manager Michael McMahon in coming weeks after three years in the role.
North currently holds pick seven at the NAB AFL Draft, with Carlton's first pick coming at No.8 (which was tied to Adelaide's position).
Carlton list manager Michael Agresta, who was part of the recruiting team at Sydney that selected Papley in the draft, last week couldn't be drawn on the Blues' interest in him when he spoke to the Road to the Draft podcast.
"We're not going to discuss other players, especially contracted players. We're really respectful of the privacy and some conversations that go on between clubs," Agresta said.
Papley has played 82 games for the Swans in four seasons with the club, booting 120 goals.
He enjoyed his best season in 2019, kicking 37 goals from 22 games and being Sydney's leading goalkicker.
Roos join Blues in hunt for star Swans forward
Callum Twomey
Sep 13, 2019 1:50PM
NORTH Melbourne has joined Carlton in trying to lure goalkicker Tom Papley out of Sydney.
The Blues have been public in their ambitions to add to their small forward ranks this off-season, and are keen to pry Papley from the Swans.
But AFL.com.au understands the Blues are not alone in the hunt for Papley, with the Kangaroos also circling.
New North Melbourne coach Rhyce Shaw has a strong relationship with Papley from his time at the Swans as an assistant coach.
The Swans remain adamant that Papley will remain with the club next year and have a strong position after AFL.com.au revealed that the 23-year-old is contracted to the club until the end of 2023 after reaching a trigger clause
But clubs have felt Papley could be on the move having been unsettled in Sydney at different stages of the past 12 months.
He has not requested a trade from the Swans, who are steadfast that he will not be leaving to return home to Victoria. He was originally drafted as a rookie out of the Gippsland Power at the end of 2015.
It is unclear whether the changes within North Melbourne's recruiting and list management department will affect its interest in Papley.
The club confirmed this week it will be parting ways with list manager Michael McMahon in coming weeks after three years in the role.
North currently holds pick seven at the NAB AFL Draft, with Carlton's first pick coming at No.8 (which was tied to Adelaide's position).
Carlton list manager Michael Agresta, who was part of the recruiting team at Sydney that selected Papley in the draft, last week couldn't be drawn on the Blues' interest in him when he spoke to the Road to the Draft podcast.
"We're not going to discuss other players, especially contracted players. We're really respectful of the privacy and some conversations that go on between clubs," Agresta said.
Papley has played 82 games for the Swans in four seasons with the club, booting 120 goals.
He enjoyed his best season in 2019, kicking 37 goals from 22 games and being Sydney's leading goalkicker.
Similar threads
