Top 10 worst Top 10 picks since '97 - '03

[Tas]

2003
#7 Kane Tenace
#9 David Trotter

Trotter turns 21 this year, he has been set back with injuries in 04 & 05, he has been pretty disappointing given the huge rap he had in 03 by people outside the club, ie Wallace & Williams.

He needs to extract the digit this year though or else it will be flipping burgers for a living.

 

[cradle of filth]

Mark Bolton
Kris Massie
Laurence Angwin
Tim Walsh
Sam Power
Kepler Bradley
Xavier Clarke
Raphael Clarke
David Trotter
Daniel Motlop

Bit harsh on the Clarke's and Tim Walsh. They've just been injured a lot, hav'nt had a chance to deliver.

 

[ManWithNoName]

Pick 4: Mark Bolton-Essendon
Pick 5: Luke Power-Brisbane

Oh what could've been.

 

[Atomboy]

Bit harsh on the Clarke's and Tim Walsh. They've just been injured a lot, hav'nt had a chance to deliver.

Yep, love watching Xavier Clarke play when he occasionally gets out on the paddock.

Quick, skillful and for such a slightly built bloke he goes in bloody hard. I remember back to 02-03 as well, he was taking screamers every second week.

We haven't seen the best of X-man yet methinks..........and hopes

 

[BZAROO]

*Andrew Halpin
*Trent Varney
*Troy Prijt
*Damien Neive
*Adam Lenehan
*Caleb Martin
*Dagogo Altraide
*Shannon Smith
*Peter Bolt
*Rodney Lance

These are for sure the ten in my opinion

never heard of any of em!
well done~!

 

[FieryNayta]

Andrew Walker

ur a knob

 

[Wizard]

The Laurence Angwin argument is an interesting one. Talentwise he was an excellent pick up as he could do anything on the footy field IMO. Mentally the guy is an idiot which cancels out the talent i guess.
So in conclusion the Crows drafted a talented idiot, that could have been anything.

 

[cameron 29]

brad ottens

 

[cradle of filth]

What about Andrew Mcdougall??

 

[Quinz]

*Andrew Halpin
*Trent Varney
*Troy Prijt
*Damien Neive
*Adam Lenehan
*Caleb Martin
*Dagogo Altraide
*Shannon Smith
*Peter Bolt
*Rodney Lance

These are for sure the ten in my opinion

AHAHAHAHA!!

 

[Paddywhackers]

Andrew Walker of course

 

[#1 Dogs Fan]

What about Andrew Mcdougall??

What about Andrew Mcdougall ?

 

[#1 Dogs Fan]

Andrew Walker of course

To be fair Andrew Walker will be a very good player but the only thing he lacks is foot skills.
He will be a gun player by the time he plays 100 games

 

[West_Is_Best]

I'm gonna throw one in for 5 years down the track. Richard Tambling will be a massive disappointment for the tiges

 

[MC_Gusto]

Bit harsh on the Clarke's and Tim Walsh. They've just been injured a lot, hav'nt had a chance to deliver.

not only that but raph was 12

x will prove everyone wrong this year he is a jet mark my word

 

[#1 Dogs Fan]

I'm gonna throw one in for 5 years down the track. Richard Tambling will be a massive disappointment for the tiges

Thats a big call West_Is_Best ?
and now have fun with the Richmond supporters

 

[West_Is_Best]

Thats a big call West_Is_Best ?
and now have fun with the Richmond supporters

lol i no im waiting for them. but im not just stirring them i honestly beleive he will be the next cupido. show plenty of glimpses of talent but will not cut it

 

[windyhill]

Pick 4: Mark Bolton-Essendon
Pick 5: Luke Power-Brisbane

Oh what could've been.

I`ve just spewed all over my key board.

 

[#1 Dogs Fan]

lol i no im waiting for them. but im not just stirring them i honestly beleive he will be the next cupido. show plenty of glimpses of talent but will not cut it

Only time will tell

 

[#1 Dogs Fan]

I`ve just spewed all over my key board.

HAHA lol gold i would have to

 

[jonesy86]

a bit harsh to put danny roach in there, his career was cut down by injury and had to retire after 1 game

at least all the others had every chance to prove themselves

 

[windyhill]

HAHA lol gold i would have to

And I had a lovely dinner as well.

 

[RememberMe]

From 1997 -> 2003
Here are the real shockers

1997
#7 Danny Roach
#9 Caydn Beetham

1998
#6 Murray Vance
#10 Brandon Hill

2000
#6 Dylan Smith
#7 Lawrence Angwin

2001
#9 Luke Molan

2002
#4 Tim Walsh
#8 Luke Brennan

2003
#7 Kane Tenace
#9 David Trotter

He will prove you wrong.

 

[Daytripper]

He will prove you wrong.

I hope he does.

Signs aren't good at the moment though.

 

[Richo83]

Ones not mentionned yet (to my knowledge)

1997

6 James Walker (looks okay, but considering Chad Cornes went after him has been a waste)

1998

2 Justin Longmuir (been up and down, not worth no. 2 pick)
4 Ryan Fitzgerald eek
9 Mark McVeigh (has been, and always was s***. Amazed at how long he's been playing)
10 Brandon Hill

1999

3 Aaron f***ing Fiona
9 Cayden Beetham (who? Exactly)

2000

5 Andrew McDougal (to be fair to bulldog fans, he isn't a failure, but hasn't been great to be honest)
6 Dylan Smith

2001

9 Luke Molan
10 Sam Power

2002

3 Jarred Brennan
7 Andrew Mackie (not a KPP, not a midfielder, not anything)
10 Jayson Laycock

2003

9 David Trotter (although I will admit it's a tad too early he hasn't shown much)