Top 15 players 07 - 09 Drafts

[blaisee]

Hurley shouldn't be in the top 20 of his own draft , let alone be in the top 14 of the 07-09 drafts. It's a joke


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[blaisee]

What about rance . Glaring omission


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[timtamWB]

Hurley shouldn't be in the top 20 of his own draft , let alone be in the top 14 of the 07-09 drafts. It's a joke


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It's based on what they could potentially combined with what they've done to date, so it's not that outrageous. But Rance should be there too.

 

[Andronicus]

Would be very interested if anyone else can be bothered doing a top 40.

Your list is great.

It's very easy to pick holes in someone else's good work, but to put yourself on the line like you did is hard to do.

Hats off.

 

[Bailey01]

My attempt in 2011:
1. S. Hill
2. M Kreuzer
3. M. Hurley
4. D. Martin
5. S. Sidebottom
6. C. Rioli
7. T. Cotchin
8. N. Natanui
9. T. Pears
10. P. Dangerfield
11. D. Rich
12. J. Ziebell
13. H. Taylor
14. T. Scully
15. J. Trengove (Dees)


New attempt : MY PREDICTIONS OF BEST PLAYERS BY END OF CAREERS, not just what they have done to date:

1 .P. Dangerfield
2. T. Cotchin
3. N. Natanui
4. N. Fyfe
5. H. Taylor
6. T. Walker
7. J. Carlisle
8. T. Rockliff
9. D. Beams
10. D. Hannebery
11. D. Martin
12. H. Hartlett
13. R. Sloane
14. M. Hurley
15. C. Rioli
16. J. Gunston
17. M. Barlow
18. S. Sidebottom
19. D. Rich
20. L. Shuey
21. D. Zaharakis
22. S. Hill
23. A. Black
24. J. Butcher
25. H. Ballantyne
26. M. Walters
27. S. Reid
28. M. Pike
29. A. Christenson
30. C. Ward
31. S. Mumford
32. J. Ziebell
33. C.Yarran
34. S. Selwood
35. R. Bastinac
36. L.Henderson
37. M. Kreuzer
38. J. Garlett
39. J. Redden (BL)
40. J. Melksham
41. T. Scully
42. B. Cunnington
43. J. Trengove.(Dees)

Daniel Talia a bit stiff, held down CHB and beating the big forwards week after week.

 

[MAAAATTDAAAAMON]

Your list is great.

It's very easy to pick holes in someone else's good work, but to put yourself on the line like you did is hard to do.

Hats off.

Thanks mate. Was tough.

Yeah missed a few, as pointed out - Rance, Motlop, Roughead.

 

[Sherrinator]

Could someone do me a top 100 and don't forget to add some bias towards your own team please.

Oh and please, more Sidebottom!

 

[MAAAATTDAAAAMON]

Since being corrected a few times, I had a more thorough look to try not to miss anyone.

New attempt : MY PREDICTIONS OF BEST PLAYERS BY END OF CAREERS, not just what they have done to date:

1 .P. Dangerfield
2. T. Cotchin
3. N. Natanui
4. N. Fyfe
5. H. Taylor
6. T. Walker
7. J. Carlisle
8. T. Rockliff
9. D. Beams
10. D. Hannebery
11. D. Martin
12. H. Hartlett
13. R. Sloane
14. M. Hurley
15. S. Motlop
16. C. Rioli
17. J. Steven
18. J. Gunston
19. P. Hanley
20. M. Barlow
21. S. Sidebottom
22. D. Rich
23. M. Duncan
24. L. Shuey
25. D. Zaharakis
26. S. Hill
27. A. Black
28. J. Butcher
29. H. Ballantyne
30. M. Walters
31. S. Reid
32. T. Bellchambers
33. A. Christenson
34. M. Pike
35. S. Mumford
36. J. Ziebell
37. A. Rance
38. C. Yarran
39. C. Mayne
40. P. Davis
41. C. Ward
42. S. Selwood
43. R. Bastinac
44. L.Henderson
45. D. Talia
46. Z. Clarke
47. M. Kreuzer
48. J. Garlett
49. L. Breust
50. J. Redden (BL)
51. B. Ebert
52. S. Crameri
53. J. Melksham
53. T. Scully
54. B. Cunnington
55. J. Trengove.(Dees)
56. J. Trengove (Port)
57. S. Jacobs
58. Lewis. Jetta
59. D. Menzel
60. C. Masten
61. J. Watts
62. C. Hooker
63. M. Suckling
64. N. Suban
65. J. Pittard
66. G. Rohan
67. J. Grimes
68. T. Vickery
69. B. McEvoy
70. M. Robinson

 

[Bailey01]

Since being corrected a few times, I had a more thorough look to try not to miss anyone.

New attempt : MY PREDICTIONS OF BEST PLAYERS BY END OF CAREERS, not just what they have done to date:

1 .P. Dangerfield
2. T. Cotchin
3. N. Natanui
4. N. Fyfe
5. H. Taylor
6. T. Walker
7. J. Carlisle
8. T. Rockliff
9. D. Beams
10. D. Hannebery
11. D. Martin
12. H. Hartlett
13. R. Sloane
14. M. Hurley
15. S. Motlop
16. C. Rioli
17. J. Steven
18. J. Gunston
19. P. Hanley
20. M. Barlow
21. S. Sidebottom
22. D. Rich
23. M. Duncan
24. L. Shuey
25. D. Zaharakis
26. S. Hill
27. A. Black
28. J. Butcher
29. H. Ballantyne
30. M. Walters
31. S. Reid
32. T. Bellchambers
33. A. Christenson
34. M. Pike
35. S. Mumford
36. J. Ziebell
37. A. Rance
38. C. Yarran
39. C. Mayne
40. P. Davis
41. C. Ward
42. S. Selwood
43. R. Bastinac
44. L.Henderson
45. D. Talia
46. Z. Clarke
47. M. Kreuzer
48. J. Garlett
49. L. Breust
50. J. Redden (BL)
51. B. Ebert
52. S. Crameri
53. J. Melksham
53. T. Scully
54. B. Cunnington
55. J. Trengove.(Dees)
56. J. Trengove (Port)
57. S. Jacobs
58. Lewis. Jetta
59. D. Menzel
60. C. Masten
61. J. Watts
62. C. Hooker
63. M. Suckling
64. N. Suban
65. J. Pittard
66. G. Rohan
67. J. Grimes
68. T. Vickery
69. B. McEvoy
70. M. Robinson

Talia should be in the top 30, apart from that great effort

 

[The Swert]

Since being corrected a few times, I had a more thorough look to try not to miss anyone.

New attempt : MY PREDICTIONS OF BEST PLAYERS BY END OF CAREERS, not just what they have done to date:

Not a bad effort. Although I'm sure a few of those players probably will either 1: have breakout years or 2: suffer poor form/injuries. Can't predict those obviously so that list is a pretty conservative prediction.

I think Ward could be a bit higher though. He's doing good things in a poor side and should lead them up the ladder.

 

[Rainfall]

midfield wise i'd..
Dangerfield
Fyfe
Cotchin
Hannebery
Beams
Steven
Barlow
Sloane

 

[timtamWB]

Dammit MAAAATTDAAAAMON where is Roughead????

Reckon Kreuzer might surprise a few and surge up the rankings. And if Menzel gets fit then he will also surge up the rankings, that guy is soooooooo good. But another good effort

 

[KissKiss]

Since being corrected a few times, I had a more thorough look to try not to miss anyone.

New attempt : MY PREDICTIONS OF BEST PLAYERS BY END OF CAREERS, not just what they have done to date:

Not a bad effort. I would have a few higher and a few lower but pretty good. More effort than I could be bothered putting in

 

[Wild Bill]

Since being corrected a few times, I had a more thorough look to try not to miss anyone.

New attempt : MY PREDICTIONS OF BEST PLAYERS BY END OF CAREERS, not just what they have done to date:

1 .P. Dangerfield
2. T. Cotchin
3. N. Natanui
4. N. Fyfe
5. H. Taylor
6. T. Walker
7. J. Carlisle
8. T. Rockliff
9. D. Beams
10. D. Hannebery
11. D. Martin
12. H. Hartlett
13. R. Sloane
14. M. Hurley
15. S. Motlop
16. C. Rioli
17. J. Steven
18. J. Gunston
19. P. Hanley
20. M. Barlow
21. S. Sidebottom
22. D. Rich
23. M. Duncan
24. L. Shuey
25. D. Zaharakis
26. S. Hill
27. A. Black
28. J. Butcher
29. H. Ballantyne
30. M. Walters
31. S. Reid
32. T. Bellchambers
33. A. Christenson
34. M. Pike
35. S. Mumford
36. J. Ziebell
37. A. Rance
38. C. Yarran
39. C. Mayne
40. P. Davis
41. C. Ward
42. S. Selwood
43. R. Bastinac
44. L.Henderson
45. D. Talia
46. Z. Clarke
47. M. Kreuzer
48. J. Garlett
49. L. Breust
50. J. Redden (BL)
51. B. Ebert
52. S. Crameri
53. J. Melksham
53. T. Scully
54. B. Cunnington
55. J. Trengove.(Dees)
56. J. Trengove (Port)
57. S. Jacobs
58. Lewis. Jetta
59. D. Menzel
60. C. Masten
61. J. Watts
62. C. Hooker
63. M. Suckling
64. N. Suban
65. J. Pittard
66. G. Rohan
67. J. Grimes
68. T. Vickery
69. B. McEvoy
70. M. Robinson

There is only 1 better backmen on this list than Scott Thompson and that is Taylor.

You have Carlisle at 7 yet no Thompson in the top 70? The essendon bias in the list lets it down. Unless you really think you have drafted the 2nd best back, 2nd best ruckman and the 2nd best forward?

 

[whattagun07]

If this becomes an accurate list, Fremantle, Adelaide and Essendon will have been the best teams over the next 6ish years.
Melksham is not going to be as good as a number of players below him though.

 

[Bailey01]

If this becomes an accurate list, Fremantle, Adelaide and Essendon will have been the best teams over the next 6ish years.
Melksham is not going to be as good as a number of players below him though.

We drafted incredibly well in those years though

 

[MAAAATTDAAAAMON]

When pointed out, I can see the bias. Hurley, Bellchambers could be a bit high but I am hopeful they will reach those levels. Hurley won't get there as a forward but as a back could well do. IMO. Carlisle I am confident with. Scott Thompson!! How'd I miss him!! Dam. Certainly deserving of a spot.

 

[MAAAATTDAAAAMON]

If this becomes an accurate list, Fremantle, Adelaide and Essendon will have been the best teams over the next 6ish years.
Melksham is not going to be as good as a number of players below him though.

Geelong are pretty well represented also.

 

[whattagun07]

We drafted incredibly well in those years though

yeah i'm confident we can achieve something in the next 5 years with the core group of danger, rory, walker, talia and jacobs. We have to strike while the iron is hot though, and have some luck with (no) long term injuries. It's when these guys turn 26-8 that we should be challenging. I think they're all about 23 at the moment.

 

[MAAAATTDAAAAMON]

midfield wise i'd..
Dangerfield
Fyfe
Cotchin
Hannebery
Beams
Steven
Barlow
Sloane

Don't rate Rockliff as much as these guys? What do others think? Does Rockliff belong in this company?

 

[whattagun07]

Geelong are pretty well represented also.

yeah unfortunately this includes Menzel though, with who I would be surprised if he came back to make a considerable contribution.

 

[Bailey01]

Don't rate Rockliff as much as these guys? What do others think? Does Rockliff belong in this company?

Rockliff's around the mark but those guys clearly are ahead

 

[the distributer]

Don't rate Rockliff as much as these guys? What do others think? Does Rockliff belong in this company?

Rockliff and Cotchin aren't as good as Beams-Danger.

 

[Wild Bill]

Rockliff and Cotchin aren't as good as Beams-Danger.

Cotchin is with beams and danger. I would not have Rockcliffe with this group.

 

[the distributer]

Cotchin is with beams and danger. I would not have Rockcliffe with this group.

He would be if he hit the scoreboard more, until he does I have him a notch below.