Opinion Top 50

Remove this Banner Ad

Is this who Throbbo thought was last year's Top 50 or his predictions on this year's Top 50?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Lingsface said:
Thought I would have a crack and it’s a lot harder than I thought. I’m sure I’ve missed some and open to changes so let loose on me (never doubted).

  1. Jeremy Cameron
  2. Marcus Bontempelli
  3. Lachie Neale
  4. Christian Petracca
  5. Tom Stewart
  6. Patrick Cripps
  7. Touk Miller
  8. Toby Greene
  9. Jack Steele
  10. Clayton Oliver
  11. Harry Mckay
  12. Zach Merrett
  13. Max Gawn
  14. Sam Walsh
  15. Andrew Brayshaw
  16. Callum Millls
  17. Tom Hawkins
  18. Connor Rozee
  19. Ollie Wines
  20. Jack McRae
  21. Tom Lynch
  22. Steven May
  23. Issac Heeney
  24. Charlie Curnow
  25. Shai Bolton
  26. Jack Crisp
  27. Patrick Dangerfield
  28. Travis Boak
  29. Darcy Moore
  30. Nat Fyfe
  31. Jeremy McGovern
  32. Nick Daicos
  33. Charlie Cameron
  34. Mitch Duncan
  35. Tom Barrass
  36. Luke Parker
  37. Hayden Young
  38. Tim English
  39. Dane Rampe
  40. Lachie Whitfield
  41. Noah Anderson
  42. Hugh Mcluggage
  43. Jordan Ridley
  44. Cam Guthrie
  45. Caleb Serong
  46. Zak Butters
  47. Aaron Naughton
  48. Darcy Parish
  49. Tom Mitchell
  50. Sean Darcy
Click to expand...
OIP.bLDAuMziUtREleUP3vLMwgHaE1
 
Lingsface said:
Thought I would have a crack and it’s a lot harder than I thought. I’m sure I’ve missed some and open to changes so let loose on me (never doubted).

  1. Jeremy Cameron
  2. Marcus Bontempelli
  3. Lachie Neale
  4. Christian Petracca
  5. Tom Stewart
  6. Patrick Cripps
  7. Touk Miller
  8. Toby Greene
  9. Jack Steele
  10. Clayton Oliver
  11. Harry Mckay
  12. Zach Merrett
  13. Max Gawn
  14. Sam Walsh
  15. Andrew Brayshaw
  16. Callum Millls
  17. Tom Hawkins
  18. Connor Rozee
  19. Ollie Wines
  20. Jack McRae
  21. Tom Lynch
  22. Steven May
  23. Issac Heeney
  24. Charlie Curnow
  25. Shai Bolton
  26. Jack Crisp
  27. Patrick Dangerfield
  28. Travis Boak
  29. Darcy Moore
  30. Nat Fyfe
  31. Jeremy McGovern
  32. Nick Daicos
  33. Charlie Cameron
  34. Mitch Duncan
  35. Tom Barrass
  36. Luke Parker
  37. Hayden Young
  38. Tim English
  39. Dane Rampe
  40. Lachie Whitfield
  41. Noah Anderson
  42. Hugh Mcluggage
  43. Jordan Ridley
  44. Cam Guthrie
  45. Caleb Serong
  46. Zak Butters
  47. Aaron Naughton
  48. Darcy Parish
  49. Tom Mitchell
  50. Sean Darcy
Click to expand...
mate do u even watch football ? even i know Clayton Oliver is the best footballer going round and has been for a coupla years n im more one eyed than
sinbad
troll of the season thus far🤣🤣🤣
 
Last edited:
lumpinee said:
mate do u even watch football ? even i know Clayton Oliver is the best footballer going round and has been for a coupla years n im more one eyed than
sinbad
troll of the season thus far🤣🤣🤣
Click to expand...
What’s your top 50… I disagree he isn’t even the best player on his team, I would take 2 ahead of him.
 
mate no disrespect but if you think Jack whatever his name is from St.Failure is a better footballer than Oliver im pretty sure you'll only be taken seriously in your own mind,thats just me tho.
i applaud anyone who posts a top 50 ,no easy task,but the top 4-5 are pretty well known and theres 3 in yours that are laughable and thats where i stopped
at and posted my first comment,@ #5
 
1. C. Oliver
2. T. Miller
3. J. Cameron
4. L. Neale
5. P. Cripps
6. M. Bontempelli
7. T. Stewart
8. C. Petracca
9. T. Lynch
10. A. Brayshaw
11. S. Walsh
12. C. Curnow
13. M. Blicavs
14. S. Bolton
15. R. Laird
16. C. Rozee
17. H. McKay
18. S. May
19. H. McCluggage
20. J. Sinclair
21. C. Guthrie
22. M. Gawn
23. C. Warner
24. T. Hawkins
25. C. Mills
26. J. Witts
27. C. Cameron
28. J. Steele
29. O. Wines
30. T. Greene
31. L. Parker
32. S. Taylor
33. L. Davies-Uniacke
34. J. Dawson
35. J. Sicily
36. J. Dunkley
37. J. Lever
38. J. Weitering
39. T. Papley
40. J. Kelly
41. J. Crisp
42. T. Boak
43. D. Prestia
44. B. Maynard
45. Z. Merrett
46. T. Barrass
47. N. Anderson
48. I. Heeney
49. A. Naughton
50. J. De Goey

Honourable Mentions: Duncan, Wilkie, Walker, Stengle, Saad, Taranto
 
Last edited:
tonygeeks said:
Question marks if Fyfey is in this sort of company these days
Click to expand...
Depending on how he goes in his new role he could easily end up being. Unfortunately he has to get through a season without a serious injury first which has been a challenge for him since 2015/16
 
lumpinee said:
mate no disrespect but if you think Jack whatever his name is from St.Failure is a better footballer than Oliver im pretty sure you'll only be taken seriously in your own mind,thats just me tho.
i applaud anyone who posts a top 50 ,no easy task,but the top 4-5 are pretty well known and theres 3 in yours that are laughable and thats where i stopped
at and posted my first comment,@ #5
Click to expand...
No I would take Gawn and petracca.
 
Bunk Moreland said:
Seriously though… Charlie Curnow 😂😂

I can show you a player who, at an identical age, playing as a key forward in one of the absolute shittest teams in the comp:

Unlike Curnow, copped the #1 key defender every week
Kicked a whole 10 goals less for the season
Took more marks
Was a far more accurate shot at goal
Had a far better disposal efficiency around the ground
Had more goal assists
Gave away less frees
Had less clangers
Had less turnovers
Had double the one-percenters
Is 11cm taller
Is 6kg heavier

And does all that while also going into the ruck when called upon each quarter and doing a stellar job in there.

Arise the true #1:

Two Metre Peter



Better than Curnow. Facts don’t lie.
Click to expand...
Thank you for agreeing with me that TMP is the Big W version of Charlie Curnow.

Next!
 
Eddie Murphy said:
1. C. Oliver
2. T. Miller
3. J. Cameron
4. L. Neale
5. P. Cripps
6. M. Bontempelli
7. T. Stewart
8. C. Petracca
9. T. Lynch
10. A. Brayshaw
11. S. Walsh
12. C. Curnow
13. M. Blicavs
14. S. Bolton
15. R. Laird
16. C. Rozee
17. H. McKay
18. S. May
19. H. McCluggage
20. J. Sinclair
21. C. Guthrie
22. M. Gawn
23. C. Warner
24. T. Hawkins
25. C. Mills
26. J. Witts
27. C. Cameron
28. J. Steele
29. O. Wines
30. T. Greene
31. L. Parker
32. S. Taylor
33. L. Davies-Uniacke
34. J. Dawson
35. J. Sicily
36. J. Dunkley
37. J. Lever
38. J. Weitering
39. T. Papley
40. J. Kelly
41. J. Crisp
42. T. Boak
43. D. Prestia
44. B. Maynard
45. Z. Merrett
46. T. Barrass
47. N. Anderson
48. I. Heeney
49. A. Naughton
50. J. De Goey

Honourable Mentions: Duncan, Wilkie, Walker, Stengle, Saad, Taranto
Click to expand...

Laird is always underrated in these type of lists. Should have 1-2 more AA’s and it wouldn’t surprise me if he adds another this year.

15 is about right, should be higher than Walsh as it stands though.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Sentinel said:
If you think Robbo's list is bad, check out ESPN's effort (with special appearance from George Hewitt at 50)

www.espn.com.au

The AFL's 50 best players

Not valuable. Not skilled. Not must-watch. But who are the 50 best AFL players heading into season 2023?
www.espn.com.au
Click to expand...
This is far more accurate than slobbos rambling mess of a list.
 
Eddie Murphy said:
1. C. Oliver
2. T. Miller
3. J. Cameron
4. L. Neale
5. P. Cripps
6. M. Bontempelli
7. T. Stewart
8. C. Petracca
9. T. Lynch
10. A. Brayshaw
11. S. Walsh
12. C. Curnow
13. M. Blicavs
14. S. Bolton
15. R. Laird
16. C. Rozee
17. H. McKay
18. S. May
19. H. McCluggage
20. J. Sinclair
21. C. Guthrie
22. M. Gawn
23. C. Warner
24. T. Hawkins
25. C. Mills
26. J. Witts
27. C. Cameron
28. J. Steele
29. O. Wines
30. T. Greene
31. L. Parker
32. S. Taylor
33. L. Davies-Uniacke
34. J. Dawson
35. J. Sicily
36. J. Dunkley
37. J. Lever
38. J. Weitering
39. T. Papley
40. J. Kelly
41. J. Crisp
42. T. Boak
43. D. Prestia
44. B. Maynard
45. Z. Merrett
46. T. Barrass
47. N. Anderson
48. I. Heeney
49. A. Naughton
50. J. De Goey

Honourable Mentions: Duncan, Wilkie, Walker, Stengle, Saad, Taranto
Click to expand...
:rolleyes::rolleyes: Carlton the gift that keeps on gifting...loaded with top 25 players it appears,millionaires who own cadillacs but ironically cant afford the gasoline to run em😂😂
 
Lingsface said:
No I would take Gawn and petracca.
Click to expand...
Splitting hairs but Oliver has won the last 2 b&f's and last two ALFCA awards.

Gawn and Petracca can have the bigger games though but they are behind Oliver
 
00Stinger said:
Splitting hairs but Oliver has won the last 2 b&f's and last two ALFCA awards.

Gawn and Petracca can have the bigger games though but they are behind Oliver
Click to expand...
Oliver just doesn’t have the damage factor for me, I’ve said before he gets the ball going your way but he can’t kick goals and his possesions don’t really seem to have the hurt factor of other stars.
 
Kysiah is pronounced Kize-ear, or Kuh-zeer. So why is Pickett known as "Kozzy"? Even just "Kuzzy" would be better.

It's gotta be one of the more stupid nicknames in the AFL and irritatingly used to excess by everyone in the media. I don't lose any sleep over it. It just shits me. It's probably more irritating the way commentators act like they are best mates with the star forwards instead of just calling their surnames like they do every other player...

Pickett....... "Kozzy"
Cameron.... "Charlie"
Riewoldt..... "Jack"
Betts.........."Eddiebetts"
Rioli........... "Cyril"
Johnson..... "Steveejay"

Picardpalm.gif
 
Robbo had a stroke right ?

Vlaustin…. good player but the 38th best player in the game ?????

Good lord
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

ItsAllAboutMe
Slobbos top 50
4 5 6 7 8
Replies
188
Views
8K
adammania9
adammania9
Lingsface
Top 50- Season 24
Replies
15
Views
1K
Lingsface
Lingsface
Lunchtime
Top 10 Players Since 2000
4 5 6 7 8
Replies
180
Views
4K
Roobs321
Roobs321
Robroy22
Who are your teams Top Eight players
2 3
Replies
67
Views
2K
Robroy22
Robroy22
Lingsface
Top 5 Indigenous families
Replies
8
Views
461
Lingsface
Lingsface
Lingsface
Name top 5
2 3 4 5
Replies
114
Views
3K
bradydaw91
B
sthmelb_dimmies
Rd 6 and the Top 4 is locked in
Replies
24
Views
890
beerbandit
beerbandit

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top