List Mgmt. Trade and F/A 2020 Cont’d

[unplugged]

We’re hearing that it makes no sense for us to do it.

It's basically even points. I'm all for it personally.

 

[gopies123]

Would prefer to not have him based on the sh*t bloke factor, and also because he’s not actually that good.

He’s a bit of a beast. Good ball winner. But yeah the shit bloke factor needs to be straightened out first!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Reef just needs to keep clocking sh1t times, in fact he should turn up drunk, with Collingwood's unofficial blessing of course

I could turn up & pretend to be a scaly mate of his.

I could put on such a show be my normal self, that we'd be sure to get him in the rookie draft.

 

[gopies123]

Geez I hope the pies don’t just sit and twiddle their thumbs until the final day. What are our thoughts. Are we going hard early??


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Anyone else concerned that we don’t seem to be a destination club?
We don’t have the appeal like we used to.

Being a destination club is closely correlated with having cash to splash.

 

[Pistol Night]

I could turn up & pretend to be a scaly mate of his.

I could put on such a show be my normal self, that we'd be sure to get him in the rookie draft.

Love it

 

[Bussie]

What happens when we upgrade all our picks to get North's pick 2 for us to get Logan McDonald only for Adelaide to pick him up with pick 1?

 

[jackcass]

Political? You mean the 'bored' and Ed thread?

Forget about politics, the Pie faithful are pretty p155ed off at the minute, walk down the street or visit the local and chat to any loyal Pie they're not happy. Hell look at this thread. The speculation alone on our cap space disaster is enough to envision pitch forks and jerry cans at the Holden centre, don't even need to mention the supposed 'toxic ex Adz' theories as well.

These Pie boards, hell anything social media about Collingwood is ready to implode. If I wasn't a Pie fan I'd have the popcorn at the ready.

You seriously need to get out more and socialize more broadly, I’m yet to encounter these pissed off Pies supporters you suggest are so prevalent.

 

[johncitizen]

Last political bickering I’m gonna say.

But if Trump gets done, any chance we can topple Eddie with the big man?

Replace one fat man with another. Could imagine him up in the bleachers at the G waving his Pies flag. What a sight to behold that would be

The funny thing is, he would likely bring us success..

 

[manicpie]

What happens when we upgrade all our picks to get North's pick 2 for us to get Logan McDonald only for Adelaide to pick him up with pick 1?

Which is exactly what will happen, Adelaide have already said so

 

[HFF]

Was just an idea for discussion..
Also don't you have a FS this year? where is he projected to go?

We have an academy player who is expected to go somewhere early to mid in the second round.
We have that one well and truly covered as we have a full compliment of picks

 

[jackcass]

6-8 is nether here or there
As I said it makes no sense—-when we could turn our first pick next year into another this year thus hitting the draft with 2 first round selections this year as opposed to just the one in your proposal.....

Getting 2x 1st round picks isn’t as important as ensuring we get a pick before a bid comes for McInnes.

 

[Tazleski]

Gotta get Esava Ratougolea to Collingwood = There is ya Tall Forward!!

 

[manicpie]

Interesting the talk of McDonald if we can move Cox.

Realistically, who is taking Cox? Can’t see it.

A lot of people I would imagine

 

[HFF]

Getting 2x 1st round picks isn’t as important as ensuring we get a pick before a bid comes for McInnes.

Reef is projecting a bid to come in second round and not in top 15-20...so I’m pretty sure we will be ok there
Hence why getting in another first rounder before that is what is going to work best for us.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

The funny thing is, he would likely bring us success..

He’s bankrupted enough businesses already thanks.

Anyway, back to the football... what are the chances of hearing anything meaningful regarding Collingwood on day 1 tomorrow? I’d have it around 1%. Will they even rock up Marvel stadium or wherever? Might well all be done on Webex, this being 2020 and all...

 

[Carringbush2010]

You seriously need to get out more and socialize more broadly, I’m yet to encounter these pissed off Pies supporters you suggest are so prevalent.

Well Jack if you would've got out yourself you'd see it, these threads are just an example of many, including speaking to other Pie loyals at the local and at work. Can't find a happy one.

So yeah get out more and open your eyes and ears.

 

[manicpie]

Gotta get Esava Ratougolea to Collingwood = There is ya Tall Forward!!

Nah, sorry mate, old Cement hands Sav, no thanks, he is another Dawes, the ball just keeps bouncing off his hands, I think he would make a good Full Back if anything, because he could just spoil and not have to mark all the time

 

[Apex36]

It's basically even points. I'm all for it personally.

Couldn’t care less about points in this scenario. It’s a pick upgrade vs 2 first round picks this year. You take the two picks, no contest. There are plenty of ways for us to trade in points next year without giving up first rounders to do it.

 

[Apex36]

Getting 2x 1st round picks isn’t as important as ensuring we get a pick before a bid comes for McInnes.

Prediction from both draft central and Twomey is that a bid is unlikely to come before the second round now. I’d much rather take the chance than get what could really be a superficial pick upgrade given the circumstances of this years draft.

 

[Apex36]

He’s bankrupted enough businesses already thanks.

Anyway, back to the football... what are the chances of hearing anything meaningful regarding Collingwood on day 1 tomorrow? I’d have it around 1%. Will they even rock up Marvel stadium or wherever? Might well all be done on Webex, this being 2020 and all...

Given that Ned Guy will be on trade radio at 12.30, you’d hope something meaningful will be said.

 

[Crazy Tails]

He’s bankrupted enough businesses already thanks.

Anyway, back to the football... what are the chances of hearing anything meaningful regarding Collingwood on day 1 tomorrow? I’d have it around 1%. Will they even rock up Marvel stadium or wherever? Might well all be done on Webex, this being 2020 and all...

Surprisingly enough Ned Guy is slated to be on trade radio at 12:30 tomorrow. So hopefully we will get some info from the inner sanctum to explain the current s**t show.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[unplugged]

Couldn’t care less about points in this scenario. It’s a pick upgrade vs 2 first round picks this year. You take the two picks, no contest. There are plenty of ways for us to trade in points next year without giving up first rounders to do it.

Either way I think we need to upgrade Pick 16 as it stands, whether it's this trade or something else.

We've seen lots of Power Rankings have Reef drift from low tens early this year to as high as 20+, but all it takes is Dom Milesi and the Bulldogs to have seen enough in 2019 and bid at Pick 14 and we're ****ed.

 

[Quicky]

Would anyone look at Phillips for Blakeley? As long as he promises to leave everyone’s wives alone!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

No way. Phillips is a better player without the character issues. You don't invite that into the club if you can avoid it.

 

[Apex36]

Either way I think we need to upgrade Pick 16 as it stands, whether it's this trade or something else.

We've seen lots of Power Rankings have Reef drift from low tens early this year to as high as 20+, but all it takes is Dom Milesi and the Bulldogs to have seen enough in 2019 and bid at Pick 14 and we're f’ed.

Except the Dogs won’t have pick 14....?