Strategy Trade and List Management Thread Part 7 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[The City Boyz]

If the club has an issue with them ask them to leave the rooms. They have a duty of care to all staff.

Is it time to worry about how close JUH seems to be with the younger players in that case? Arty, Clarke etc

 

[Munnez]

6 year offer to SDK from the Dogs

Dogs selling the idea of him, Buss and JOD as the next pillars of our defence

Well that might planr the seed

 

[Scott Tracy]

"O'Halloran comes from a strong football pedigree with his late grandfather Ron McCarthy playing 42 games for Footscray, including the Bulldogs’ 1954 premiership."

 

[Dog 36]

Macrae is going, CD may ask for a trade. JJ retires ? that may leave Bont and Libba as the only premiership Dogs from 2016.

 

[Dogs Rule]

What did Bailey dress up as for the Cats’ whacky Wednesday?

Put a shirt on.

 

[adogsfan5]

Macrae is going, CD may ask for a trade. JJ retires ? that may leave Bont and Libba as the only premiership Dogs from 2016.

JJ one year deal I heard.

 

[Struggle]

Is it time to worry about how close JUH seems to be with the younger players in that case? Arty, Clarke etc

No

 

[Snarls Barkley]

I don't see it with O'Halloran. As a cheap option maybe not much to lose but it's been a pretty underwhelming first 70 odd games.

Think his best chance to make it is as a wing. Decent size, long kick are probably his best traits, maybe he could line up opposite to Bailey Williams

 

[c0de_crow]

Is it time to worry about how close JUH seems to be with the younger players in that case? Arty, Clarke etc

outrageous take, if anything it is good they are all close. JUH is only 1 or 2 years older than them anyways.

 

[Dogsfan1]

I don't see it with O'Halloran. As a cheap option maybe not much to lose but it's been a pretty underwhelming first 70 odd games.

Think his best chance to make it is as a wing. Decent size, long kick are probably his best traits, maybe he could line up opposite to Bailey Williams

This was this year

 

[Iamspock]

According to Jay Clark “The Bulldogs and Geelong are yet to start talks on a deal for gun midfielder Bailey Smith”.

I find that hard to believe.

Well, Geelong started talks, just not with the Bulldogs...mainly with Bailey, Cotton On, and real estate agents in Bellbrae.

 

[LukasTheGreat]

Does anyone know if SDK can play forward?

 

[Snarls Barkley]

This was this year

Ok. And?

 

[DannyB4]

Does anyone know if SDK can play forward?

How many KPF's do you want?

 

[SweatOnMySkin]

XOH sounds like a vdm upgrade which will delight 50% of the fanbase and cause the other 50% to rush to his defence against this comment. For the right price seems a reasonable if unexciting pickup

 

[lachy]

Our midfield is going to be piss poor moving forward. What are we doing to fill it?

Given trade period hasn't started and the draft is a couple of months away, nothing at the moment other than planning strategies

On SM-S926B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Dogs 13]

So Mid - Week has Reported that the club have welcomed Smith to Attend the dogs B&F. But it’s unlikely he will attend good riddance I say Gutless w***er

However I’m sure he’ll find time for some inane look at me post on Insta at the same time as our B&F.
No show without Punch.

 

[SweatOnMySkin]

However I’m sure he’ll find time for some inane look at me post on Insta at the same time as our B&F.
No show without Punch.

he'll probably launch his onlyfans during Bont's speech

 

[Iamspock]

However I’m sure he’ll find time for some inane look at me post on Insta at the same time as our B&F.
No show without Punch.

So glad I unfollowed him on Insta. I didn't see his last post.... Thank God, hearing about it was enough.

 

[ArNcHiSe]

It wouldn’t be a Bulldogs off-season if they didn’t pick up some other teams below-average mid.

 

[glenashley]

Smith to Geelong
SDK to Blues
Blues pick 11 and Geelong 2nd round to us?

Maybe a 3rd round back to Geelong? (Depends how you rate SDK?)

Feels about right.

Unless SDK really wants to go to the blues, I'd cut them out of the deal and just take him and Geelong's 2nd.

I suspect I'd even be ok without the 2nd. So would Geelong.

 

[Freshwater]

If Smith has bought property and has moved down to Belbrae or Newtown? And is working closely with Cotton-On in their HQ in North Geelong?
It’s going to be a real pain in the arse driving to Punt Road in Richmond or slightly better driving to Arden St in North Melbourne every day. Does his free agency time reset once changing clubs? Because he’ll have years to wait if this is the case
He wants to go to Geelong badly. He is not a free agent, not even a restricted free agent! We actually hold all the cards. We didn’t even have him this season, so we know what life is like. Why give him to those flogs in Geelong for peanuts? Number 7 draft pick, who we’ve nurtured, some would say babied and is in his prime now.

 

[Chalky White]

I don't see it with O'Halloran. As a cheap option maybe not much to lose but it's been a pretty underwhelming first 70 odd games.

Think his best chance to make it is as a wing. Decent size, long kick are probably his best traits, maybe he could line up opposite to Bailey Williams

Perfect player to do a run with role which we haven't got. Local boy from Altona and wouldn't cost much at all. For him to be playing 70 games in a good team with GWS shows that he is no dud.
Give me him any day over O'Neil, VDM, Poulter or Baker.

 

[Chalky White]

According to Jay Clark “The Bulldogs and Geelong are yet to start talks on a deal for gun midfielder Bailey Smith”.

I find that hard to believe.

Agree. However thats not to say Smith's manager hasn't spoken to the Cats and the Dogs to try to ink out a deal.
It's the easy way a club doesn't lie, discussion with the other club hasn't happened however discussion with an intermediary who also has had discussion with another club has.

 

[Chalky White]

One day older then West, went 4 spots before him in the draft aswell.
I feel like if he came across they'd be fighting for the same spot at half forward.

Completely different players. XOH more mid based and can do run with roles as well as play wing or inside mid. West is a half forward who can pinch hit in the midfield at best.