List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2020

[Chrispiesssss]

I still want Harry Perryman!

 

[stormskye]

I still want Harry Perryman!

I’ll take a cardboard cutout from
The crowd as long as it’s above 196cm and not a ruck

 

[Virgin Dog]

Why would Hogan move into the backline when Pearce and Logue seem to have those positions locked up. They also have Cox, who seems part of their future plans

I agree, but Freo apparently doesn't. Article from last week said they were planning on sending Hogan to the backline for some reason... No idea why they would

 

[Matt_352]

Wasn't rocket science to say Riccardi was a great prospect, yet our recruiters didn't get the memo

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

Freos list is full of talls - why do they want Mioceck.
It makes no sense - I’m not buying it.

Longmuir knows the value he can bring

 

[Jen2310]

GEEZ.. The one we could have had.

 

[Matt_352]

GEEZ.. The one we could have had.

Recruiting team needs the sack

 

[stormskye]

GEEZ.. The one we could have had.

Our club really is stale.

 

[AndrewShawble]

GEEZ.. The one we could have had.

Not only that, but people were BEGGING for him. It’s not like he was plucked from nowhere and we never had a chance...

If we aren’t picking up these types at picks in the 50’s then god help us.

 

[Jen2310]

 

[TradeDraft]

GEEZ.. The one we could have had.

That looking to be a Massive F**k Up by Hine

 

[AndrewShawble]

Recruiting team needs the sack

Don’t be like that, rumour has it we’ve got our eyes on a 215cm Russian as a rookie. Going to be a project player but might replace Coxy over the next few years when Pendles and Steele have left.

Why waste a pick in the 50’s on a local forward?

 

[Jen2310]

Not only that, but people were BEGGING for him. It’s not like he was plucked from nowhere and we never had a chance...

If we aren’t picking up these types at picks in the 50’s then god help us.

We also exchanged our pick to GWS who then snapped him up.

 

[AndrewShawble]

Our club really is stale.

You say stale, I say ‘tenure’ and ‘commitment’.

Hine - 17 years
Eddie - 22 years

 

[TradeDraft]

You say stale, I say ‘tenure’ and ‘commitment’.

Hine - 17 years
Eddie - 22 years

Collingwood being too Collingwood

 

[stormskye]

You say stale, I say ‘tenure’ and ‘commitment’.

Hine - 17 years
Eddie - 22 years

Hine is living in the Sam Newman days when 6ft 2 was a ruckmen. He can’t see above that height

 

[gouki88]

I agree, but Freo apparently doesn't. Article from last week said they were planning on sending Hogan to the backline for some reason... No idea why they would

Weird... although Longmuir knows his defenders, so maybe it’s a good call? Honestly not a clue

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Collingwood Recruiting team when they trade their pick to GWS who then pick up Ricardi

 

[Go Woods]

Recruiting team needs the sack

Time for a fresh set of eyes...Steve Silvagni to replace Hine anyone? Carltons emerging list of midfielders & tall forwards is all his doing before they shafted him.

 

[Jen2310]

Collingwood Recruiting team when they trade their pick to GWS who then pick up Ricardi

GWS GIANTS gain Pick 51 and a future fourth-round pick. COLLINGWOOD gains a future third-round pick.

 

[kaistar]

Time for a fresh set of eyes...Steve Silvagni to replace Hine anyone? Carltons emerging list of midfielders & tall forwards is all his doing before they shafted him.

He is the worst recruiting manager the league had. This is a laughable suggestion. Tell me one other good Carlton midfielder besides Cripps and Walsh? Walsh was no1 pick and still no where near the player lukosius or Bailey smith will be. With the amount of draft picks the bluesers had, how could u not get some right?? Absolute spud, absolute balderdash of a suggestion.

 

[Go Woods]

We need a 2nd review & this time the end result should not be extending the coaches tenure.....their needs to be wholesale changes.

 

[AndrewShawble]

Time for a fresh set of eyes...Steve Silvagni to replace Hine anyone? Carltons emerging list of midfielders & tall forwards is all his doing before they shafted him.

Do a raffle for club members;
- $5 entry, enter and many times as you like
- winner gets Hines job
- condition is all picks have to be based on poll results from bigfooty

Not even kidding, half the posters here have called out names pre draft for the pies picks that have proven to be better selections.

 

[Matt_352]

We need a 2nd review & this time the end result should not be extending the coaches tenure.....their needs to be wholesale changes.

This

 

[Go Woods]

He is the worst recruiting manager the league had. This is a laughable suggestion. Tell me one other good Carlton midfielder besides Cripps and Walsh? Walsh was no1 pick and still no where near the player lukosius or Bailey smith will be. With the amount of draft picks the bluesers had, how could u not get some right?? Absolute spud, absolute balderdash of a suggestion.

Oh really, he has selected Weitering, Charlie Curnow (is a star but injured) McKay, Cripps etc. He has selected very good KP players, would be an upgrade on Hine!