Trade hypotheticals

[harro92]

I seriously doubt that. There is definite talent there.

Then he stays at the club. We either get fairly compensated or he stays.

Well if you doubt it you are wrong, he's too far down the order, too many kids have passed him, any afl player hastalent it's how they got into the afl

 

[eth-dog]

You read it right..... hes gunna walk one way or the other.

Id take the 17 and some change.

I wouldn't. There is no way that this will hold up in the courts.

 

[eth-dog]

Well if you doubt it you are wrong, he's too far down the order, too many kids have passed him, any afl player hastalent it's how they got into the afl

I can think of 3 or 4 "kids" who've passed him.

 

[harro92]

I can think of 3 or 4 "kids" who've passed him.

Yeah I can think of more he's not worth much anymore your overacting him if you think he's worth much

 

[eth-dog]

Yeah I can think of more he's not worth much anymore your overacting him if you think he's worth much

Okay, which kids have passed him outside of Merrett, Gleeson, Daniher (who's a kpf so doesn't really count)?

 

[harro92]

Okay, which kids have passed him outside of Merrett, Gleeson, Daniher (who's a kpf so doesn't really count)?

Ashby, O'Brien, aylett I would even play Edwards before him, he doesn't even light it up in the VFL

 

[Sydswans0512]

I seriously doubt that. There is definite talent there.

Then he stays at the club. We either get fairly compensated or he stays.

If you make him stay the bombers are a terrible organization

 

[harro92]

Yay

If you make him stay the bombers are a terrible organization

Yeah but at the same time a decent offer as to be given to us

 

[eth-dog]

Ashby, O'Brien, aylett I would even play Edwards before him, he doesn't even light it up in the VFL

Ashby and Aylett are about the same. O'Brien maybe the same. Edwards is nowhere near him yet.

 

[Sydswans0512]

Yay


Yeah but at the same time a decent offer as to be given to us

Should be happy with their first rounder after what the guys been thru

 

[DapperDon]

If you make him stay the bombers are a terrible organization

We're not making him stay, he's up for trade.

It's up to other clubs to be serious about getting him.

 

[harro92]

Ashby and Aylett are about the same. O'Brien maybe the same. Edwards is nowhere near him yet.

I disagree but Yeah even if they are the same at least they wanna be at the club

 

[Sydswans0512]

We're not making him stay, he's up for trade.

It's up to other clubs to be serious about getting him.

Be happy with pick 17 or whatever it is stop dragging shit out all the time

 

[harro92]

Should be happy with their first rounder after what the guys been thru

He's a contracted player still so pick 17 is not enough

 

[Sydswans0512]

He's a contracted player still so pick 17 is not enough

You let the player down should be very happy with that

 

[harro92]

You let the player down should be very happy with that

He agreed to it and signed a waiver he still had a choice

 

[DapperDon]

Be happy with pick 17 or whatever it is stop dragging shit out all the time

Name another trade we have 'dragged out'?

We got unders for Crameri, we offered our first rounder and future AA defender for Caddy who said no.

All other trades have been done quickly, stop being fed shit by the media and do some research.

Why don't Port just offer a fair trade, then it will be done. Essendon aren't at fault here.

 

[DapperDon]

You let the player down should be very happy with that

lol.

You're 13 aren't you?

 

[Sydswans0512]

Name another trade we have 'dragged out'?

We got unders for Crameri, we offered our first rounder and future AA defender for Caddy who said no.

All other trades have been done quickly, stop being fed shit by the media and do some research.

Why don't Port just offer a fair trade, then it will be done. Essendon aren't at fault here.

I wasn't talking about dragging out trades

 

[Sydswans0512]

He agreed to it and signed a waiver he still had a choice

That makes it all better

 

[DapperDon]

I wasn't talking about dragging out trades

then what the actual **** are you on about then???

Jesus Christ, this site sometimes.......

 

[Sydswans0512]

then what the actual **** are you on about then???

Jesus Christ, this site sometimes.......

I wonder what you've been dragging out

 

[DapperDon]

I wonder what you've been dragging out

 

[Oddhawk]

Essendon fans this week

Ryder is worth top 5 pick >>>>> he's contacted >>>>> he won't walk >>>>>> it'll never hold up in court >>>>> sh1t..... Can we get pick 17???

Wake up... He's leaving this year. Take it and move on!! Take the bans and move on!! Sack the coach and move on!! Stop perpetuating the myth Essendon did nothing wrong!!

The most respected doctor in the league had his advice ignored and then Turd went behind his back and did it anyway.

My 2 year old takes it on the chin better!!

 

[harro92]

Essendon fans this week

Ryder is worth top 5 pick >>>>> he's contacted >>>>> he won't walk >>>>>> it'll never hold up in court >>>>> sh1t..... Can we get pick 17???

Wake up... He's leaving this year. Take it and move on!! Take the bans and move on!! Sack the coach and move on!! Stop perpetuating the myth Essendon did nothing wrong!!

The most respected doctor in the league had his advice ignored and then Turd went behind his back and did it anyway.

My 2 year old takes it on the chin better!!

I'm bit asking for Hartlett or wines or wingard I'm just asking for more then pick 17 cause that's about of an insult trade I expect some players like moore O'shea even butcher or be added to the deal