Trade hypotheticals

[Zach Package]

The most respected doctor in the league

The most respected doctor in the league also rightly told Ryder he had nothing to worry about regarding his son, and Paddy ignored that.

Him and Connors have basically decided that he's a port player already, he's been given a personal training program by Burgess, he's already looking at houses in adelaide and Paul 'I don't want to play it out in the media' Connors and himself are going to every media outlet that will listen with a sob story that bizarrely includes 'I'd stay if this was all finished by now'.

If he's intent on being a campaigner I hope we rain down all kinds of hellfire and brimstone on him, he well and truly deserves it. Ryder and his handlers have handled this in absolutely abhorrent fashion.

 

[Oddhawk]

I'm bit asking for Hartlett or wines or wingard I'm just asking for more then pick 17 cause that's about of an insult trade I expect some players like moore O'shea even butcher or be added to the deal

I think a bigger shovel is in order....

With Essendon at one end self capitulating and $ydney being c**k blocked by the AFL at the other and back 2 back flags... The signing if Frawley and the bag of peanuts we paid for O'Hawk it's never been a better time to be a hawk supporter!!

 

[Oddhawk]

To diverge from Essendon...

Is there any reason there couldn't be a three way deal done between Hawthorn, Collingwood and the Lions to get the Beams deal done?

Pies out- Beams
In 5 & Hallahan/Simpkin/Woodward

Hawks out - Boxer/ Simo / Woody
In pick 25

Lions out - 5 & 25
In Beams

Surely everyone gets what they want there.

 

[bloke_]

To diverge from Essendon...

Is there any reason there couldn't be a three way deal done between Hawthorn, Collingwood and the Lions to get the Beams deal done?

Pies out- Beams
In 5 & Hallahan/Simpkin/Woodward

Hawks out - Boxer/ Simo / Woody
In pick 25

Lions out - 5 & 25
In Beams

Surely everyone gets what they want there.

I don't think any of those Hawks players are worth 25

 

[Oddhawk]

2 Liston Medalist that can't break into what is arguably the best midfield in the comp

Or a hardened midfielder with age on his side.

Sure, slightly overs but everyone comes out smiling. Perhaps the Hawks throw 59 to the Lions for 63 to sweeten it a little

 

[bloke_]

2 Liston Medalist that can't break into what is arguably the best midfield in the comp

Or a hardened midfielder with age on his side.

Sure, slightly overs but everyone comes out smiling. Perhaps the Hawks throw 59 to the Lions for 63 to sweeten it a little

A 4 pick upgrade for a team like Brisbane who probably won't even use that pick isn't gonna make a difference.

If Hallahan/Woodward/Simpkin are worth 25 the Pies will just take 5 and 25. No need to get Hawthorn involved really. I'd prefer the picks in this draft

 

[Oddhawk]

A 4 pick upgrade for a team like Brisbane who probably won't even use that pick isn't gonna make a difference.

If Hallahan/Woodward/Simpkin are worth 25 the Pies will just take 5 and 25. No need to get Hawthorn involved really. I'd prefer the picks in this draft

But Collingwood don't.

 

[bloke_]

But Collingwood don't.

They would over those players

 

[Oddhawk]

They would over those players

Surely Aish and Lewis don't fit the bill either

 

[bloke_]

Surely Aish and Lewis don't fit the bill either

Brisbane won't trade them so it doesn't matter. FWIW they have way more value than the others

 

[Oddhawk]

Brisbane won't trade them so it doesn't matter. FWIW they have way more value than the others

Agree with that wholeheartedly Aish and Lewis worth more than the three I've listed for sure.

Whitecross maybe?

 

[bloke_]

Agree with that wholeheartedly Aish and Lewis worth more than the three I've listed for sure.

Whitecross maybe?

What's happened to him? How much VFL did he play this year or did he miss the while season? Still not sure he'd get it done

 

[Oddhawk]

What's happened to him? How much VFL did he play this year or did he miss the while season? Still not sure he'd get it done

Did his ACL in the PF against Geelong last year.
Was meticulous in his rehab.
Got it right and has been doing a pre season since August.

PRIMED is a word that springs to mind

 

[bloke_]

Did his ACL in the PF against Geelong last year.
Was meticulous in his rehab.
Got it right and has been doing a pre season since August.

PRIMED is a word that springs to mind

Feel for the bloke. 3 grand finals missed is just bad luck. Hope he has a good run next season

 

[Oddhawk]

Feel for the bloke. 3 grand finals missed is just bad luck. Hope he has a good run next season

Our depth is crazy at the minute!
People think I'm crazy when I suggest trading out one of our 15-25 (on field wise... IE. Suckling, Shiels, Simpkin, Litherland) in a pair to get into the first round. But our depth can cover and we can nab a young need player.

 

[bloke_]

Our depth is crazy at the minute!
People think I'm crazy when I suggest trading out one of our 15-25 (on field wise... IE. Suckling, Shiels, Simpkin, Litherland) in a pair to get into the first round. But our depth can cover and we can nab a young need player.

Yeah I think it's the envy of the competition

 

[Oddhawk]

Yeah I think it's the envy of the competition

I've resigned myself to the fact we may lose a favourite player.
If I had my way I'd offer Birchall to the highest bidder.... But I'm coo coo for cocoa puffs!!

 

[SnowRoo]

Ok who am i robbing here?

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood +55

Geelong trade: Pick 55+21
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark + Pick 36

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier Lumumba

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood + 36
North Melbourne receive: Pick 21 + 30

 

[bloke_]

Ok who am i robbing here?

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood +55

Geelong trade: Travis Varcoe + Pick 55+21
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark + Pick 30

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier Lumumba

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood
North Melbourne receive: Travis Varcoe + Pick 21

That's actually pretty good

 

[SnowRoo]

That's actually pretty good

Editted it a little, what do you think now

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood +55

Geelong trade: Pick 55+21
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark + Pick 36

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier Lumumba

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood + 36
North Melbourne receive: Pick 21 + 30

 

[bloke_]

Editted it a little, what do you think now

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood +55

Geelong trade: Pick 55+21
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark + Pick 36

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier Lumumba

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood + 36
North Melbourne receive: Pick 21 + 30

It's funny, because I look at it and think "Gee the cats and roos do pretty well there" but I can't see the other 2 being shortchanged at all. It's a genuine win/win/win/win

 

[Two Planks]

More like this

Geelong get Clark
Lose Varcoe and 55

Pies get Greenwood
Lose Lumumba and pick 50

Melbourne get Lumumba and 55
Lose Clark

Roos get Varcoe and 50
Lose Greenwood

 

[SnowRoo]

More like this

Geelong get Clark
Lose Varcoe and 55

Pies get Greenwood
Lose Lumumba and pick 50

Melbourne get Lumumba and 55
Lose Clark

Roos get Varcoe and 50
Lose Greenwood

OUCH, i struggle to rate Varcoe past a 3rd

 

[harro92]

Editted it a little, what do you think now

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood +55

Geelong trade: Pick 55+21
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark + Pick 36

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier Lumumba

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood + 36
North Melbourne receive: Pick 21 + 30[/QUOTppp

This is actually quite a fair and good trade

 

[Dom PC]

Do people think this could work?

Pick 5, pick 23 and Greenwood >> Collingwood
Merrett and Lumumba >> Melbourne
pick 25 and pick 30 >> North
Beams >> Brisbane