Trade Talk

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
hmmmm

I'm not a very big fan of Shaw but at least the price seems reasonable.

Whats your source?
Price is more than reasonable but do we really need him? Turns 27 next week and will get in the way of the younger midfielders coming through.
 
No problems with giving up pick #46, but I'm not sure why we would trade for a player not renowned for the quality of his disposal! He had a decent season for Collingwood, but he's still 27, so he's not getting any quicker. He would be little more than a depth player surely?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I'm not a very big fan of Shaw but at least the price seems reasonable.

Got speed, he has...but geez, he knows how to turn the ball over...

Price is more than reasonable but do we really need him? Turns 27 next week and will get in the way of the younger midfielders coming through.

No problems with giving up pick #46, but I'm not sure why we would trade for a player not renowned for the quality of his disposal! He had a decent season for Collingwood, but he's still 27, so he's not getting any quicker. He would be little more than a depth player surely?

I agree. :)

EDIT: Collingwood have just given pick 93 to Brisbane for Corrie.
24yo, probably quicker than Shaw, more versatile and a top kick.

Pies 1, Sydney 0.
 
Confirmed trades so far:

TRADE: Collingwood's Rhyce Shaw and pick 61 to Sydney for pick 46.

TRADE: Brisbane's Anthony Corrie to Collingwood for pick 93.

TRADE: Western Bulldogs' Farren Ray and pick 48 to St Kilda for pick 31.
 
hmmmm

I'm not a very big fan of Shaw but at least the price seems reasonable.

Whats your source?


I've payed very close attention to his career and he's developed into a decent player, this has been a good pick up for us. He's a handy midfielder, not great but he's ok. Good trade.:thumbsu:
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Of what value? Surely not the Pick 30 that you have? Herald Sun reports that 8 clubs have shown interest in Lovett.

LMAO, seems all 8 clubs thought he was not worth a fourth rounder.

So, you delist him, pretty much as i said you would, no?
 
Just a hunch, but I'm guessing if the Lions traded him for pick 93, he's not that special.

Steven King & Charlie Gardiner for pick 90 last year.

New coach up in Brisbane, he may not rate Corrie.

Malthouse obviously does. And presumably more than Rhyce Shaw, who he has just moved on.
 
Steven King & Charlie Gardiner for pick 90 last year.

New coach up in Brisbane, he may not rate Corrie.

Malthouse obviously does. And presumably more than Rhyce Shaw, who he has just moved on.

Rhyce wanted to leave the pies that is why malthouse moved him on. Pretty sure corrie isn't too good.

Rhyce is good at running with the ball, as long as roosey drums it in to him that he's not allowed to kick it and can only pass to a team mate 2 meters away, he'll be a tidy pick up for us.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top