List Mgmt. Trade targets 2022

[benblinkau]

If only we had got pick 9 .

View attachment 1513570

Its an idiot statement to choose a particular draft number in a given time frame and say its a likely hit or miss. Particularly when half of those players are 25 or under.

It will be pick 9 after ashcroft goes at number 1.

 

[240volt]

Not talking about pick 8 but we really need a good KPD.
You can all talk about Butters Rozee and Pickett all you want but what I see on the team sheet each week screams disaster.
Jonas,McKenzie,Clurey.

 

[ClintEastwood]

Dunno if this has been posted yet.

Josh Dunkley turns his back on monster offer to request trade to rival club

With his partner playing professional netball in Adelaide, the Dogs star has made a shock call.

7news.com.au

F*ck.

 

[240volt]

One diabolical draft in thirteen years hardly amounts to it being a raffle. the one thing our club has actually been ok at, is drafting. Way more hits than misses.

All I said was after a couple of real stand out players it’s a raffle.
Even last years pick 12 is looking dodgy.

 

[benblinkau]

All I said was after a couple of real stand out players it’s a raffle.
Even last years pick 12 is looking dodgy.

After 1 season? Gee, give the bloke a chance lol

 

[Bevoman]

Not talking about pick 8 but we really need a good KPD.
You can all talk about Butters Rozee and Pickett all you want but what I see on the team sheet each week screams disaster.
Jonas,McKenzie,Clurey.

I reckon we should be looking at gems like Joshua Schache.
He is 201cms and comes from Seymour in country Victoria.

He has some baggage, being Pick 2 in the 2015 draft and has since been moved on by the Lions, to the Doggies.
A crack junior full-forward the Dogs have played him in the backline.

The Dogs will need currency if they wish to prise Lobb from Freo (who, at this stage have said no).
Therefore, they may be examining who they can move on to facilitate the Rory Lobb trade.
Could be a win, win, win situation.

 

[PatientMental]

I reckon we should be looking at gems like Joshua Schache.
He is 201cms and comes from Seymour in country Victoria.

He has some baggage, being Pick 2 in the 2015 draft and has since been moved on by the Lions, to the Doggies.
A crack junior full-forward the Dogs have played him in the backline.

The Dogs will need currency if they wish to prise Lobb from Freo (who, at this stage have said no).
Therefore, they may be examining who they can move on to facilitate the Rory Lobb trade.
Could be a win, win, win situation.

Schache is a legit plod, if you can't make the dogs defence you might as well give up.

 

[King_Tredrea]

I reckon we should be looking at gems like Joshua Schache.
He is 201cms and comes from Seymour in country Victoria.

He has some baggage, being Pick 2 in the 2015 draft and has since been moved on by the Lions, to the Doggies.
A crack junior full-forward the Dogs have played him in the backline.

The Dogs will need currency if they wish to prise Lobb from Freo (who, at this stage have said no).
Therefore, they may be examining who they can move on to facilitate the Rory Lobb trade.
Could be a win, win, win situation.

What’s your end game here? You must live a sad life if you think this is fun

 

[Lightning_Rod]

I reckon we should be looking at gems like Joshua Schache.
He is 201cms and comes from Seymour in country Victoria.

He has some baggage, being Pick 2 in the 2015 draft and has since been moved on by the Lions, to the Doggies.
A crack junior full-forward the Dogs have played him in the backline.

The Dogs will need currency if they wish to prise Lobb from Freo (who, at this stage have said no).
Therefore, they may be examining who they can move on to facilitate the Rory Lobb trade.
Could be a win, win, win situation.

Why on gods green earth would we need schache, these trade ideas are getting so bad.

Just because they are over 200cm doesn't mean they are good.

 

[Powerade 08]

The new pied piper coach of North will regenerate a new attitude from Horne-Francis.
We can but hope that North are still not that successful next year.

lol now South Australians wont come here either. Only player that will apparently is Josh Schache. You've lost it.

 

[Schulzenfest]

I have said for a while that Fiorini would be great for us. I rate him highly and if gold coast are gonna give him up for a 2nd round draft pick as a salary dump then it is a no brainer. we should also be looking at others we can get from gold coast as salary dumps to bring in good picks. Imagine if we could get a pick from gold coast in the 30s and then fwd it on for Rioli

There's absolutely no reason that Fiorini would come here.

There are three reasons why a contracted player might move: More money, the chance to go to their preferred state or club, the chance to get more opportunities at AFL level. Fiorini is apparently being paid $600k a year already so we definitely shouldn't offer him option 1, we obviously can't offer him option 2, and I wouldn't play him in the middle ahead of any of Wines, Rozee, Butters, Boak, Drew or SPP so we can't offer him option 3 either.

Obviously it would be nice to get a free second rounder, but players are human beings, and there's no good reason for Fiorini to pick us over clubs that may be able to offer him one or two of the above incentives that we can't offer.

 

[longdonkey]

Just as aside to this discussion because I don't think Schache is who we want or need. I think there is a misconception on here about what is realistic and what trading that we can do that could be to our long-term detriment.

I think getting Rioli could be to our long-term detriment and the more we pay for him the greater the risk but I'm happy to be proved wrong.

But I don't see a scenario where we get a young key defensive tall via trade that doesn't compromise our trade hand in the draft looming at a possible run at a flag in 2024-28. Which means we need to draft the long-term key back and in the meantime make do with a DFA or someone we can get on the cheap.

You can't throw everything at one player and we make this mistake consistently bringing in one player and expecting its the missing piece meanwhile everyone else gets one year older. We are just starting to see it with Ryder then Gray but soon it will be Boak, Dixon, Lycett that need to be replaced.

 

[BigBadBergman]

They're going to have to delist a bunch of players and all clubs would know who they are.

If they're serious about trading they will have to salary dump some decent players.

Any thoughts on who they might salary dump?

 

[240volt]

Starting to sound like a verge pick up.

 

[longdonkey]

Any thoughts on who they might salary dump?

Fiorini
Sexton
Bowes
Atkins if they can
McPherson

they will likely be front of the queue but there will probably more behind them like Corbett, Burgess, Thompson, Holman, Day which won't be salary dump but preparing for a smaller list while clearing some salary

 

[Boak10]

Jack Payne from the Lions is the one we should be targeting
Lions need picks, he’s behind Andrew’s, Adam’s and Gardiner

QLD boy admittedly, but you throw a 4 year deal on good coin and see if you can prize him out.
22 year old monster lock down defender, exactly our needs.

Draft capital wise, I wouldn’t think it would be too far from a late first, early second.

 

[Powertron]

We need to cool the jets on trading pick 8 or the Amon compo pick.

Unless it’s a walk up start first 22 player within the <26 age bracket we’re better off adding another layer of youth to come up with the core youngsters we have.

 

[Port 2004]

Come back in 2023 or 2024?

Not stipulated. I can make further enquiries with our family friend. There is no BS involved from my source. If possible I will post further info.

 

[Launchpad McQuack]

Jack Payne from the Lions is the one we should be targeting
Lions need picks, he’s behind Andrew’s, Adam’s and Gardiner

QLD boy admittedly, but you throw a 4 year deal on good coin and see if you can prize him out.
22 year old monster lock down defender, exactly our needs.

Draft capital wise, I wouldn’t think it would be too far from a late first, early second.

If he's behind three players he isn't worth a second let alone a first.

 

[Port 2004]

I won’t be upset if he stays at North. Apart from being hyped as a number 1 pick, he’s been miles off showing it on the field.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

No worries. I don’t hold out a lot of hope that he will come to Port. Just reporting a bit of info.

 

[Turksta84]

There's absolutely no reason that Fiorini would come here.

There are three reasons why a contracted player might move: More money, the chance to go to their preferred state or club, the chance to get more opportunities at AFL level. Fiorini is apparently being paid $600k a year already so we definitely shouldn't offer him option 1, we obviously can't offer him option 2, and I wouldn't play him in the middle ahead of any of Wines, Rozee, Butters, Boak, Drew or SPP so we can't offer him option 3 either.

Obviously it would be nice to get a free second rounder, but players are human beings, and there's no good reason for Fiorini to pick us over clubs that may be able to offer him one or two of the above incentives that we can't offer.

Never once said he would. I said i like him and he would fit in nicely and targetting gold coast players in salary dumps to get draft picks in return would be great.

 

[EskimoPAFC]

If Kosi is smart he sticks around the Dees who are still in a window and avoids the Port succession that might not be a succession shitshow in 2023.

He can make his decision end of next year.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Any thoughts on who they might salary dump?

Not really, just can't see clubs showing much interest in players that are delisting material. They would have to be offering some reasonable quality.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Lloyd Meek has asked to be traded to Hawthorn.

 

[EskimoPAFC]

Not talking about pick 8 but we really need a good KPD.
You can all talk about Butters Rozee and Pickett all you want but what I see on the team sheet each week screams disaster.
Jonas,McKenzie,Clurey.

I have said Busslinger a lot lately but allow me to continue....

Busslinger, Busslinger, Busslinger