Trade Week Over - Who won, Who Lost??

[badboybenny]

Who got the most out of trade week

Was it St Kilda, Richmond, Geelong, Bulldogs???

Your thoughts?

 

[AFKAJR]

1st West Coast
2nd St Kilda
3rd Carlton

 

[RUNVS]

Sydney lost.

 

[badboybenny]

IMO I like what the Doggies did, I like the trades, but the proof will be in the pudding.

I like what the Saints have done. Pick 90 for King and Gardiner will go down as a famous trade.

And Judd to Carlton - I like that trade - and it looks pretty even for both WCE and the Blues

 

[MF]

1. Carlton
2. St. Kilda
3. Brisbane - Although the Hadley deal makes me reconsider this

 

[ShinSplints]

Richmond if they get brennan in PSD are the winners not to mention mcmahon.

 

[hawka187]

St.Kilda

1 player + 3 premierships players for 26 + 90, Awesome trading

 

[claf-43]

West Coast, Carlton, St Kilda

easily

 

[royals1922]

The Eagles got robbed on Judd but did pretty well to convert their draft picks to 4 picks in the top 22 and clear some cap space. Pick 54 probably won't be used.

Further besides Judd they only lost Morton. The Eagles have very rarely traded for players but got Kennedy so Kennedy and 4 in the top 22 is pretty good.

 

[dobbo_18]

1. Saints
2. Blues
3. Tigers
4. Dogs
5. Lions

 

[dylan101]

1. Saints
2. Blues
3. Dogs

 

[Smoky]

Melbourne lost... Pick 14 for a Clubs Favourite son. Melbourne supporters must be absolutely riled.

St Kilda won.

Swans just confuse me, and Geelong giving away their Premiership ruckman for nothing (very cocky)

 

[BluesRules]

Seriously, I think we have traded very well. The judd trade speaks for itself, but Richard Hadley is a fantastic get.

Hadley could do a Rodan

 

[BluesRules]

1. Saints
2. Blues
3. Tigers
4. Dogs
5. Lions

How have the saints won?

They picked up hacks.

 

[Smoky]

Seriously, I think we have traded very well. The judd trade speaks for itself, but Richard Hadley is a fantastic get.

Hadley could do a Rodan

And Judd could do a Wowoden!

 

[fishbowl]

Sydney lost, St Kilda won. Carlton lost, West Coast won.

 

[Snakeman66]

How have the saints won?

They picked up hacks.

We don't have hAckland.

 

[badboybenny]

And Judd could do a Wowoden!

Love that Smoky - great line!!

 

[Scotland]

Carlton got Judd, so it's safe to say everyone else is fighting it out for the minor placings.

We did well to end up with 4 picks in the first 22 for the loss of just a fringe player, a late second round pick and a guy who was leaving anyway.

The Dogs and Collingwood both did well to get a ruckman, which is something each club needed. Collingwood paid more, but got a player who should be around for a long time.

The Saints did well to get Schneider for pick 26, but will Dempster really add that much? King and Gardiner for 90 is an interesting one. Very short term for mine, who knows how much longer King can play for?

Freo did well to stay out of proceedings. No magic beans this year.

 

[Mcleod_Nine]

Sydney and Adelaide lost i think
But Carlton and St. Kildla won
good trade week all up

 

[Munga]

I might say St Kilda won, but Carlton getting Hadley for pick 52 might put them ahead. Althought the Saints have only given up pick 26.

 

[RoyalBlue]

Carlton and St Kilda dead heat.

North smashed.

 

[Higgs Boson]

Melbourne lost... Pick 14 for a Clubs Favourite son. Melbourne supporters must be absolutely riled.

I've always been a Travis fan, so I'm disappointed. On the other hand, though, two first round picks is pretty cool.

 

[blues4flag]

Saints did very well, but Carlton nabbing the biggest name plus Hadley for practically nothing has us probably ahead. Very happy with trade week and was an exciting final two days - needless to say, my stress levels dropped dramatically after those first few days.

 

[pete_21]

Michael Gardiner and Steven King together will be a dynamic Ruck Duo.