- Jul 14, 2005
- 18,723
- 29,565
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Chelsea FC
- Banned
- #101
It is my view that we spent far longer down than we needed to and we have been far to slow to build, entirely because of certain players on our list not doing the absolute best to help us get up there. The tail has wagged the dog at Carlton for a decade IMO.
Not picking on Waite. He and Walker have been my two favourites. I have absolutely no doubt that if Waite had been more mature, had taken care of himself and had given 100% on the field every game, Carlton would have been a much better side over that journey. All players at Carlton wanted success, only some have been prepared to put in the work to get it. Waite wants to capitalise on the hard work of North players to this point, rather than give everything he has to get Carlton up to that point.
Robbie Flower deserved a flag. Robert Harvey deserved a flag. One club players who gave their all because they loved the club, and could easily have gone somewhere else for glory. Flower only played finals in his final year. Not all players deserve a flag I'm afraid.
I agree entirely. Through 2004-2010 we brought a lot of young, talented players to the club but failed to develop them and create an environment where they pushed themselves to succeed. It's no wonder players like Gibbs and Yarran are having breakout seasons years after they should have - things have finally clicked.
Waite's an odd cat though. He might have become the player we all envisioned him being, or he may well have continued to underachieve. It's all speculation and hyperbole. I don't think he deserves a flag either - but he's got every right to chase one with his chosen club.
But rather than see his departure as inherently dark, I'd rather see it as indicative of the direction of the club over the next decade. For every player that leaves, new players get opportunities. If we can nab Jaksch, have a fit Henderson, along with Casboult playing closer to goal we may have stumbled on a formula that might just work.