Injury Walsh's Injury Updates

[Darkyprotector]

Yeah not sure what the tape was about if it were bruising. Can you kick like that with a medial ligament injury?

The tape was administered to restrict movement somewhat and give more support

When I did my acl , couldn't jump, no peer
ALSodone the others same same
The amazing thing no freekick

 

[Quicky]

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/pies-finally-get-good-injury-news-20180709-p4zqf2.html

Maybe he really hasn't sustained any structural damage.

The article Hagla posted above seems to confirm that it is just bone bruising for WHE. That is some epic good news.

Also good to see that Aish, Elliott and Fasolo are set for returns. They will hopefully start replacing some depth players.

It will give the AFL and VFL teams a real boost.

 

[TradeDraft]

Didn’t see it but presume AFL get their info from Collingwood.
Even with that they got Moore as test but he played VFL. Maybe they mean test for seniors?
Who knows?

Didn't a Report from Club say Aish be playing Intra Club with VFL Team on Thursday?

 

[northpie]

I am with you Apex.........not sure why people are ganging up on BC.

I like the fact he goes against the status quo here.

CFC you are better than that. No one is hanging up on BC, rather he is being called out for some outrageous pontification, based on zero interaction with the patients he is opining on. He does this on the basis that he claims they professionals providing the treatment are incompetent, and that he is better qualified to treat them. Pretty unusual for someone who doesn’t actually have a practice himself
Don’t let apex suck you into the argument

 

[northpie]

Apologies! You accused him of only having an acupuncture degree as his highest qualification. How terrible of me. I’m not sure how I’ll sleep at night now...

Pretty poor effort to cover a serious fault in your argument.maybe you should have checked my quote before responding. Cute I think was the term you used for my apparent lack of google proficiency.
BTW exactly how many more patients does Fooksey attend to than our resident BFF physio BC.

 

[jmac70]

I am with you Apex.........not sure why people are ganging up on BC.

I like the fact he goes against the status quo here.

I asked him for his opinion on Treloar’s chances of recovering this season and he wouldn’t give one. I should be grateful he didn’t insult me.

 

[spartan-magpie]

Treloar will be back before finals can just feel it.

Wanna hope so, norm smith beckons.

 

[CFC2010]

CFC you are better than that. No one is hanging up on BC, rather he is being called out for some outrageous pontification, based on zero interaction with the patients he is opining on. He does this on the basis that he claims they professionals providing the treatment are incompetent, and that he is better qualified to treat them. Pretty unusual for someone who doesn’t actually have a practice himself
Don’t let apex suck you into the argument

Look northpie this is a forum and we all give opinions as such...….B C isn't any different in my eyes.
Yes his posting style is "unique" but me personally I don't mind the left field posters.
It would be pretty boring around here if we all agreed.

I am not getting sucked into the argument or agreeing with what B C is saying but he has a right to say it all the same.
I do agree the insults don't add anything to the discussion.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Look northpie this is a forum and we all give opinions as such...….B C isn't any different in my eyes.
Yes his posting style is "unique" but me personally I don't mind the left field posters.
It would be pretty boring around here if we all agreed.

I am not getting sucked into the argument or agreeing with what B C is saying but he has a right to say it all the same.
I do agree the insults don't add anything to the discussion.

And there is a really simple solution, people have the choice of either reading what the bullshit artist writes or put him on ignore
There are bullshit threads and bullshit posters all over Big footy, its nothing new

 

[Saintly Viewed]

 

[sideswipe]

Pretty poor effort to cover a serious fault in your argument.maybe you should have checked my quote before responding. Cute I think was the term you used for my apparent lack of google proficiency.
BTW exactly how many more patients does Fooksey attend to than our resident BFF physio BC.

Love that he is now "Fooksey".

#Fookesyknows

 

[BigCharlie]

I could say you were an egomaniac but you would probably diagnose my opinion as uninformed despite my humble qualifications which, after 40 years in a profession, I am quite proud of obviously pale as compared to yours

What is the "profession?"

based on zero interaction with the patients he is opining on. He does this on the basis that he claims they professionals providing the treatment are incompetent, and that he is better qualified to treat them. Pretty unusual for someone who doesn’t actually have a practice himself

It might help if you actually read what I wrote.

1) I have a practice. I am a part time (0.5) lecturer. Nowhere have I stated that I am a full time academic - I couldn't stand associating with that many sanctimonious lefties on a full time basis.
2)It is widely acknowledged that the Hawthorn football club's medical, allied health and conditioning team are the best in the business.
3)It is widely acknowledged that the Collingwood football club's medical, allied health and conditioning team are not. Further,not only are they not in the ballpark of being the best, they weren't even given the directions to the stadium. Given that both clubs have a similar football department spend, you need to question why.

Pretty poor effort to cover a serious fault in your argument.

Pretty poor effort of you to fail to answer this question:

Is he more or less qualified than every other Physio in Melbourne who has a Masters in Sports Physiotherapy? Is his opinion more or less valued than Gary Nicholls, former Physio at the CFC, an APA titled Sports Physiotherapist who works at the same practice?

I'll even do your homework for you. Fooks is an APA titled Sports Physio through the acquiring of a Masters degree. Nicholls is an APA titled Sports Physio through the acquiring of vast experience (as well as examination).

I'll try to frame the question in as simple language as I can for you: Who is the better Physio and why?

BTW exactly how many more patients does Fooksey attend to than our resident BFF physio BC.

Are you talking on a time spent in clinic equation, or raw numbers? I see 20-25. (25 is my limit)

I asked him for his opinion on Treloar’s chances of recovering this season and he wouldn’t give one. I should be grateful he didn’t insult me.

I gave you an answer. I said "possibly". He's had surgery on an intramuscular tendon strain. It's impossible to give an exact time frame for any number of reasons. Time-based criteria for return to function isn't as common as criteria-based return to function these days, but there is still basic physiology to contend with.

 

[Apex36]

Pretty poor effort to cover a serious fault in your argument.maybe you should have checked my quote before responding. Cute I think was the term you used for my apparent lack of google proficiency.
BTW exactly how many more patients does Fooksey attend to than our resident BFF physio BC.

You would have to ask BC that question. I’m not sure how relevant quantity over quality is in this instance though.
Are you trying to say that a better physio will see a higher number of patients. Because that’s incredibly naive.

 

[Anzacday]

Come on guys we're fortunate enough to have some medicos with differing opinions who are prepared to discuss.
Challenge/question by all means or agree to disagree and move on.
Can all parties please do it without the insults as it detracts from and derails the discussion which could be quite fruitful if allowed to be.

 

[MyManLynch]

I asked him for his opinion on Treloar’s chances of recovering this season and he wouldn’t give one. I should be grateful he didn’t insult me.

That’s ok...I can...you Dodo!

 

[unplugged]

If we announce at end of season that we've appointed Charles Silkundies to our medical team, I'll be rapt.

 

[jimmy35]

I think we’d all sleep a lot better. Hope he stays off the internet a bit more and spends that time in the medico rooms though.

 

[jmac70]

Yes, I did. What are your issues with that term? Are you denying that it exists?



What is the "profession?"



It might help if you actually read what I wrote.

1) I have a practice. I am a part time (0.5) lecturer. Nowhere have I stated that I am a full time academic - I couldn't stand associating with that many sanctimonious lefties on a full time basis.
2)It is widely acknowledged that the Hawthorn football club's medical, allied health and conditioning team are the best in the business.
3)It is widely acknowledged that the Collingwood football club's medical, allied health and conditioning team are not. Further,not only are they not in the ballpark of being the best, they weren't even given the directions to the stadium. Given that both clubs have a similar football department spend, you need to question why.



Pretty poor effort of you to fail to answer this question:


I'll even do your homework for you. Fooks is an APA titled Sports Physio through the acquiring of a Masters degree. Nicholls is an APA titled Sports Physio through the acquiring of vast experience (as well as examination).

I'll try to frame the question in as simple language as I can for you: Who is the better Physio and why?



Are you talking on a time spent in clinic equation, or raw numbers? I see 20-25. (25 is my limit)



I gave you an answer. I said "possibly". He's had surgery on an intramuscular tendon strain. It's impossible to give an exact time frame for any number of reasons. Time-based criteria for return to function isn't as common as criteria-based return to function these days, but there is still basic physiology to contend with.

Treloar mentioned that Fockers (or whatever his name is) had mapped out a six week plan for him. In your expert opinion, what might that involve?

Lay man’s terms please because I’m only a school teacher.

 

[jackcass]

2)It is widely acknowledged that the Hawthorn football club's medical, allied health and conditioning team are the best in the business.
3)It is widely acknowledged that the Collingwood football club's medical, allied health and conditioning team are not. Further,not only are they not in the ballpark of being the best, they weren't even given the directions to the stadium. Given that both clubs have a similar football department spend, you need to question why.

Widely acknowledged by whom? Where has this been stated?

 

[surfer1]

Yes, I did. What are your issues with that term? Are you denying that it exists?



What is the "profession?"



It might help if you actually read what I wrote.

1) I have a practice. I am a part time (0.5) lecturer. Nowhere have I stated that I am a full time academic - I couldn't stand associating with that many sanctimonious lefties on a full time basis.
2)It is widely acknowledged that the Hawthorn football club's medical, allied health and conditioning team are the best in the business.
3)It is widely acknowledged that the Collingwood football club's medical, allied health and conditioning team are not. Further,not only are they not in the ballpark of being the best, they weren't even given the directions to the stadium. Given that both clubs have a similar football department spend, you need to question why.



Pretty poor effort of you to fail to answer this question:


I'll even do your homework for you. Fooks is an APA titled Sports Physio through the acquiring of a Masters degree. Nicholls is an APA titled Sports Physio through the acquiring of vast experience (as well as examination).

I'll try to frame the question in as simple language as I can for you: Who is the better Physio and why?



Are you talking on a time spent in clinic equation, or raw numbers? I see 20-25. (25 is my limit)



I gave you an answer. I said "possibly". He's had surgery on an intramuscular tendon strain. It's impossible to give an exact time frame for any number of reasons. Time-based criteria for return to function isn't as common as criteria-based return to function these days, but there is still basic physiology to contend with.

The proffession is my business, look I like your opinions and consider them informed. I just dont like the way you express yourself maybe tone it down a bit

 

[PIEWITHSAUCE]

Treloar mentioned that Fockers (or whatever his name is) had mapped out a six week plan for him. In your expert opinion, what might that involve?

I think members should have a chance to ask questions of this guy in a similar fashion to the member forum.

Call it Meet (The) Fockers.

 

[MagpieBat]

 

[Bored_Pie]

WHE Test
Fasolo/Elliott/Blair/Aish - Match Simulation
Wills - Hamstring - 2 weeks
Appleby Hamstring - 4-6 weeks
Reid - 3 weeks.

 

[10571z]

Did Goldsack have Lars? How could he possibly be a chance otherwise?

 

[MagpieBat]

Did Goldsack have Lars? How could he possibly be a chance otherwise?

Had the regular job. But in-year comebacks can sometimes happen. Macaffer & Krakouer in 2012, for instance.