-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Welcome Welcome to Hawthorn : Jack Ginnivan!
- Thread starter Strapping Young Lad
- Start date
- Tagged users None
This ducking action was brought into the game by the Selwood twins who taught their younger brothers. Joel Selwood did the exact same thing as Ginni for the first ten years of his career. The only difference was Selwood did it 3-4 times a game whilst gathering 25-30 possessions. The AFL made a huge mistake by rewarding this ducking. What happened was younger players like Mathieson, Weightman and Ginni decided to emulate Selwood but did it every time they got the ball. There was some backlash against these young players. So for last 5 years of his career Joel Selwood changed to shrugging both of his shoulders while going low to draw a high free kick. Ginni needs to stop doing this action for 3-4 weeks and then bring back a more subtle shoulder shrug so it is not so obvious for the umpires.
Last edited:
I'm sure all she's admitting to is that they made errors and free kicks should have been paid. She is not admitting to a conspiracy against Ginny, just saying that umpires didn't make the correct call and missed free kicks. We really need umpires to be full time so these guys can go through a video review and be questioned by their coaches, "why did you miss that free?" "you were in correct spot and had clear vision, what were you looking at to not see the high contact?"
My suggestion to Ginny, is to go with short sleeves and get a very boring short back and sides haircut so in the heat of the contest the umpires can't quickly identify it's the guy in long sleeves and headband and not pay a free.
Hodgey 15
Premiership Player
- Aug 2, 2013
- 4,725
- 12,433
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Tasmania
This sounds more like the AFL trying to nip things in the bud early and trying to take heat out of the conversation and off umpires.
Meaningless unless there is a massive culture change at the umpiring dept.
That is all it is. Usual BS and politics. Play on.
At the end of the day, the umpires are umpiring with different standards, which when directed at two players specifically is unsportsmanlike behaviour and we should have fair grounds to refuse certain umpires if it keeps happening, our lack of vocalness here compared to other clubs is the bit that drives me up the wall.
But in a weird way it will make a stronger side, so let it keep happening but and the big but, the club needs to swing for the hills for the players
But in a weird way it will make a stronger side, so let it keep happening but and the big but, the club needs to swing for the hills for the players
The way it was explained to me was she freely admitted to the error, apologised for it and particularly as Geelong got similar free kicks, she wanted the AFL to be “on the front foot”. I don’t believe she got into the conspiracy theory.
Restricted Free Agent
President of the Conor Nash fan club
AFL reaches out to Hawks, admits Ginnivan frees were missed
The AFL admits the umpires missed some of the free kicks that should have been paid to Jack Ginnivan
www.afl.com.au
Jeez the stats in this article are interesting 21 high contact frees in his first year, down to four last year after the AFL's stance on ducking the shoulder changed, and just a single free kick as a Hawk
HedgeFund
Norm Smith Medallist
Sounds to me like the AFL contacting a club (which is entitled to query some umpiring calls) and acknowledging the calls were wrong.
Nothing more.
- Apr 10, 2017
- 2,375
- 4,573
Well done to the AFL - the right thing to do on her part... It's quite rare the AFL does it.
Not going to lie though, it doesn't make me less angry at the AFL though, especially when i see Ginni go off with a blood nose.
I don’t know what game you were watching. I did not see Ginnivan drop his knees or his shoulder. Ginnivan has learnt this action has to be removed from his game. I very much agree with this attitude. He was clearly taken high.
Fabulous news, we’re so grateful AFL for shedding your newfound wisdom.
Now we can all rest assured.
Undoubtedly Ginnivan (and Watson too when he’s back playing) will get the 3 or 4 frees each week that are warranted.
Or else it’s just f*cking lip service and the blinkered umpires will give us a fair week and then revert to their entrenched biased umpiring. Just as they did with Buddy for a decade and a half with us and Sydney, and as they’re doing with Sicily now.
And as they did with Selwood in the reverse manner throughout his career.
Now we can all rest assured.
Undoubtedly Ginnivan (and Watson too when he’s back playing) will get the 3 or 4 frees each week that are warranted.
Or else it’s just f*cking lip service and the blinkered umpires will give us a fair week and then revert to their entrenched biased umpiring. Just as they did with Buddy for a decade and a half with us and Sydney, and as they’re doing with Sicily now.
And as they did with Selwood in the reverse manner throughout his career.
Ginnivan "read the room" and left. Schultz deal was done only thing left was a good old public humiliation from the coach to get things moving.
I love this guy so much. Electric personality. He’s what we need
Love him. But he polarises the public.
One thing i know, is that when we're good (he's only 21), he's gonna whip the faithful into absolute frenzy in big finals.
One thing i know, is that when we're good (he's only 21), he's gonna whip the faithful into absolute frenzy in big finals.
stevehawkington
Senior List
Ginnivan received 21 free kicks for high contact in 2022 when he kicked 40 goals as a rookie at Collingwood. That number dropped to just four last year after a directive from the AFL to not reward players who attempt to draw free kicks.
Spot on , he is what the competition needs. Plays with heart and passion and is a bit different. Love it.
Slaatybaadfaast
Debutant
- Aug 25, 2023
- 136
- 453
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Added to the 2 dodgy deliberate out of bounds that resulted in goals
- Mar 17, 2011
- 2,611
- 4,456
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Everton, Denver Broncos
All the clear frees yesterday (three of them) had no dropping or whatever, just blatant arm across the shoulder/neck from a player behind him. He didn't drop, he didn't shrug or whatever - he played the ball, got fouled and got nothing.
- Jun 17, 2019
- 8,018
- 19,865
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Love the lawyer talk" The AFL doesn't umpire certain players differently" sure they don't. The know legal troubles this could bring.
It’s amazing how quickly kids gravitate to him. Fan favourite with kids after his first game.
Roger Rogerson
Brownlow Medallist
That is clear evidence he is being umpired differently.
Terrific article in The Age expressing Peter Schwab’s views on Ginnivan’s non-free kicks.
I’ve got a lot of time for Schwabby.
He’s a former director of the umpires, as well as having done everything else in footy.
He refers to the umpires “subconscious bias” when not awarding Ginnivan the frees he clearly should have got.
I’ve absolutely no doubt that his views, expressed privately, would be a lot stronger than that.
I’ve got a lot of time for Schwabby.
He’s a former director of the umpires, as well as having done everything else in footy.
He refers to the umpires “subconscious bias” when not awarding Ginnivan the frees he clearly should have got.
I’ve absolutely no doubt that his views, expressed privately, would be a lot stronger than that.
Last edited:
Similar threads
