Game Day Welcome to the "Only Lost 4 Games on the Trot Once Since 2007" Lounge

[frggr]

I am a Betty Man myself. Wilma has too many Karen vibes

"Move along to the "5 wins is a dynasty" lounge with Plugger35 please, M9. I don't want to cause you any further embarrassment"

 

[AvantGardener]

I'm beginning to think you're dense.

They would still rank far above Carlton on any finals measure in that period except for "not making finals"

What part was factually incorrect:

Since 2007 Geelong have lost more finals than Carlton.

Since 2007 Geelong have been eliminated from finals more times than Carlton.

Thats just the cherry picked years.

If you look at it as a whole Carlton has 16 flags to 10 Geelong flags.

Hard to see how Geelong are better in finals than Carlton are in finals.

 

[frggr]

What part was factually incorrect:

Since 2007 Geelong have lost more finals than Carlton.

Since 2007 Geelong have been eliminated from finals more times than Carlton.

Thats just the cherry picked years.

If you look at it as a whole Carlton has 16 flags to 10 Geelong flags.

Hard to see how Geelong are better in finals than Carlton are in finals.

The bit where I said:

"average finals finishing place for that period"

Geelong, on average, make Prelims.

Carlton, on average, don't make finals.

 

[AvantGardener]

The bit where I said:

"average finals finishing place for that period"

Geelong, on average, make Prelims.

Carlton, on average, don't make finals.

So you're comparing apples and oranges as you are comparing your finals performance with how we went in H&A. As you said H&A means nothing.

 

[Scully2GWS UMAD]

So you're comparing apples and oranges as you are comparing your finals performance with how we went in H&A. As you said H&A means nothing.

Overall Carlton have been eliminated from the finals more than Geelong.

 

[frggr]

So you're comparing apples and oranges as you are comparing your finals performance with how we went in H&A. As you said H&A means nothing.

No, you were crying about the illegitimacy of ladder position because it was ranked on H&A wins, so I offered to do a ranking on finals performance in the same period instead.

Carlton average "September holidays"

Geelong average "Prelim"