Western Bulldogs BigFooty Consensus Best 22 - Now Voting on Interchange (vote for 4)

[inyourfacedunk]

Oh nice. Just saw the edit. My bad.

 

[Yojimbo]

By the way, by popular demand I'll allow all six members of the forward line to be selected together.

Dannnnnnnnnn Easton Wood is down twice so i voted for him twice.

PS- Only Joking, but seriously it will happen.

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

Dannnnnnnnnn Easton Wood is down twice so i voted for him twice.

PS- Only Joking, but seriously it will happen.

Haha, the talls are in there twice as they're not always limited to FB/CHB - people might want a very tall defensive setup with all of Fletch, Hamling and Roughead back. Hopefully those that vote for the same player twice are in the minority.

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

Interesting, Roughead is getting more votes at CHB than I expected him to so far.

 

[Yojimbo]

Interesting, Roughead is getting more votes at CHB than I expected him to so far.

Maybe it's because we are spoiled for choice, so many options.

 

[DogDays]

Wood, Roughy, Murphy


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[BEaston]

Good work Dan of many Ns.

 

[Super Hans]

Wood and Murph.
Hamling.

Great thread Dannnnnnnnnn.

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

This one's a tad one-sided at the minute, haha.

My major points of interest for this are the ruck situation (one ruck? Two? Who are they?) and our forward setup (Boyd? Redpath? Both?). Also curious to see which of Biggs, McLean and Stevens miss out as, as far as my selection goes, at least one of them misses.

 

[TheHoneyBadger]

This one's a tad one-sided at the minute, haha.

My major points of interest for this are the ruck situation (one ruck? Two? Who are they?) and our forward setup (Boyd? Redpath? Both?). Also curious to see which of Biggs, McLean and Stevens miss out as, as far as my selection goes, at least one of them misses.

Minson & Roughead.

Just Boyd.

Biggs misses of that trio.

 

[bontshow]

My major points of interest for this are the ruck situation (one ruck? Two? Who are they?) and our forward setup (Boyd? Redpath? Both?). Also curious to see which of Biggs, McLean and Stevens miss out as, as far as my selection goes, at least one of them misses.

The first point of interest for me is JJ who finished 6th in the B&F isn't selected in his preferred position. 3 time premiership HBF Matthew Suckling only has 2 votes. They are every chance to slot in somewhere else but it goes to show we are hugely stacked for HBF's

 

[Super Hans]

Maybe most think the wing is JJ's best position next year? I do.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Maybe most think the wing is JJ's best position next year? I do.

Or that a backline doesn't necessarily consist of 6. I think his best position is half back along with Murphy and Boyd. Boyd would play a higher role, more kick behind the play.

 

[razrblayd]

Or that a backline doesn't necessarily consist of 6. I think his best position is half back along with Murphy and Boyd. Boyd would play a higher role, more kick behind the play.

Agreed. If you look at the tendency's this year, You'd have to say that the backline would be roberts, hamling, morris, wood, murphy, m boyd and johannisen. (or similar) this makes 7. with such a heavy reliance on murph, moyd and moz, surely one of these players will play less time back in order for the next crew to come through otherwise we may look a little silly when they all go. put murph on the wing and let him slide back into defence when necessary

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Agreed. If you look at the tendency's this year, You'd have to say that the backline would be roberts, hamling, morris, wood, murphy, m boyd and johannisen. (or similar) this makes 7. with such a heavy reliance on murph, moyd and moz, surely one of these players will play less time back in order for the next crew to come through otherwise we may look a little silly when they all go. put murph on the wing and let him slide back into defence when necessary

Yep. For the purpose of things like this and team sheets etc. one will more than likely get named on the wing or bench.

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

Should we vote on the ruck and centre line together or separately?

 

[Yojimbo]

Should we vote on the ruck and centre line together or separately?

I would say seperate because i want to see if you include Jong and
Bontempelli as options for the ruck spot.

 

[TheHoneyBadger]

Together.

 

[TheHoneyBadger]

I would say seperate because i want to see if you include Jong and
Bontempelli as options for the ruck spot.

Don't forget giant-killer Shane Biggs

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Should we vote on the ruck and centre line together or separately?

Good question.
I'm interested how people will go for interchange too.
Pick the best available players or team balance?

 

[Yojimbo]

Don't forget giant-killer Shane Biggs

I was going to include Brett Goodes (The Master of Sandilands) ,but
sadly he was cut.

 

[BEaston]

Should we vote on the ruck and centre line together or separately?

hmmm.

I'd go ruck + 3 onballers then 2x wingers separate.

Obviously there would be some cross pollination with the players available (ie Macrae could be wing or on-ball) but that would allow a differentiation between the two slightly different roles (onball and wing)

 

[Super Hans]

Should we vote on the ruck and centre line together or separately?

Maybe you could also edit the title whenever voting for a new line opens? So that way people can know without having to open the thread up. May lead to more votes.

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

hmmm.

I'd go ruck + 3 onballers then 2x wingers separate.

Obviously there would be some cross pollination with the players available (ie Macrae could be wing or on-ball) but that would allow a differentiation between the two slightly different roles (onball and wing)

I like it.

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

New poll will go up this afternoon.