Universal Love Who is the best player who has played for the Melbourne Football Club since and including 2000? WINNER: Max Gawn

[Topkent]

Or Headless could be a complete dick hole and play off like for likes.

Green vs Bruce
Whelan vs Jetta
Fritsch vs Robbo
May vs Neitz
Woey vs Vince


You sick **** Less

 

[Meds]

Since we're not counting the 90's this has to be Jetta.

Has this been stated in the rules?

After a quick flick through the thread, I can only see a rule stating that players had to have played at least 1 game since the start of 2000, not that we were only to consider contributions in that time.

 

[Topkent]

Has this been stated in the rules?

After a quick flick through the thread, I can only see a rule stating that players had to have played at least 1 game since the start of 2000, not that we were only to consider contributions in that time.

Best player since 2000.
Ox isn't in the best 50 players for us since 2000


Actually we sucked pretty hard he might be but he's not top 20

 

[Bluelegs]

Has this been stated in the rules?

After a quick flick through the thread, I can only see a rule stating that players had to have played at least 1 game since the start of 2000, not that we were only to consider contributions in that time.

It's a fair point. Perhaps we should SEEK CLARIFICATION from Headless as to whether 90s form can be considered.

 

[Headless]

Or Headless could be a complete dick hole and play off like for likes.

Green vs Bruce
Whelan vs Jetta
Fritsch vs Robbo
May vs Neitz
Woey vs Vince


You sick * Less

It's a fair point. Perhaps we should SEEK CLARIFICATION from Headless as to whether 90s form can be considered.

serial_thrilla

 

[Bluelegs]

View attachment 1843667
serial_thrilla

Might be time to shut the thread down and start over.

 

[Headless]

Might be time to shut the thread down and start over.

serial_thrilla

 

[Headless]

My take was entire Melbourne career from anybody eligible (1+ game from 2000 onward).

 

[Meds]

My take was entire Melbourne career from anybody eligible (1+ game from 2000 onward).

That was what I thought you thought.

Makes sense to consider their full career but limit it to players that most of us had the opportunity to see live (i.e. excluding the Barassi's, Warne-Smith's etc).

 

[Bluelegs]

My take was entire Melbourne career from anybody eligible (1+ game from 2000 onward).

This makes things much more difficult. Perhaps we should start a new tournament:

Who is the best player who has played for the Melbourne Football Club between 1900 and 1923?

First up Vin Coutie vs Harry Harker

 

[Headless]

That was what I thought you thought.

Makes sense to consider their full career but limit it to players that most of us had the opportunity to see live (i.e. excluding the Barassi's, Warne-Smith's etc).

Meds gets it.

Hope I made it so that people can't change their votes for full humorous effect.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

What a shambles , this is going as well as the thread about the Western Bulldogs jumper.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

This thread will go from sticked to not stickied to hell in the space of two or three days.

Such a fall from grace.

 

[Headless]

What a shambles , this is going as well as the thread about the Western Bulldogs jumper.

One of my all-time favourites!

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

One of my all-time favourites!

"Post here if you're having a nice time" kicks it's ass.

 

[Headless]

"Post here if you're having a nice time" kicks it's ass.

And I am!

 

[Meds]

Meds gets it.

Hope I made it so that people can't change their votes for full humorous effect.

Permanently enshrining poster's mistakes in an open and unchangeable poll is the kind of accountability that has resulted in a board culture that's the envy of anonymous online text-based forums right across the world wide web.

 

[Bluelegs]

Permanently enshrining poster's mistakes in an open and unchangeable poll is the kind of accountability that has resulted in a board culture that's the envy of anonymous online text-based forums right across the world wide web.

A board that also appears to be highly accepting of players with gambling and drug problems.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Permanently enshrining poster's mistakes in an open and unchangeable poll is the kind of accountability that has resulted in a board culture that's the envy of anonymous online text-based forums right across the world wide web.

Gary Pert out Meds in please.

 

[BaliDemon]

Tribute vote to the Ox from me. What a player he was in his prime.

 

[Scythe94]

Since we're not counting the 90's this has to be Jetta.

Ok, Jetta

I just ignored the 2000 thing. Couldn't be bothered.

Ok, Schwarz

So the Ox was undoubtedly a better player but if it's after 2000 it can't possibly he him. Was just holding on in the GF year and fell away after that.

So has to be Jetta

Ok, Jetta

Has this been stated in the rules?

After a quick flick through the thread, I can only see a rule stating that players had to have played at least 1 game since the start of 2000, not that we were only to consider contributions in that time.

Ok, Schwarz

Schwarz best was before 2000 so this is a somewhat easy decision for me , it's Nev. If we were including the 90s and it's Ox.

Ok, Jetta

My take was entire Melbourne career from anybody eligible (1+ game from 2000 onward).

Ok, Schwarz

 

[Bluelegs]

Ok, Jetta

Ok, Schwarz

Ok, Jetta

Ok, Schwarz

Ok, Jetta

Ok, Schwarz

Is there any way to remove my vote? I'd like to abstain.

 

[Scythe94]

Is there any way to remove my vote? I'd like to abstain.

Not without resetting the poll, unfortunately. You can change, but there's no remove function.

Anyway, next poll is Headless v Bluelegs

 

[Headless]

Not without resetting the poll, unfortunately. You can change, but there's no remove function.

Anyway, next poll is Headless v Bluelegs

serial_thrilla, this makes posting so much easier.

 

[Bluelegs]

Not without resetting the poll, unfortunately. You can change, but there's no remove function.

Anyway, next poll is Headless v Bluelegs