Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Worm4]

Thats the yard stick for a successful season at Carlton . No wonder you haven’t won a premiership for decades

Perhaps try and comprehend the title of the thread. Is important.

 

[Fadge]

.



View attachment 2061119

Nice cartoon, but it should be 'We have made more than one in every three Grand Finals in history'.

43 Grand Finals in the 127 year history of the competition.

 

[JustaBattler]

Nice cartoon, but it should be 'We have made more than one in every three Grand Finals in history'.

43 Grand Finals in the 127 year history of the competition.

Participation award winners for sure Fudgey - you can gloat about being the games biggest chokers over your entire history as much as you like...talk about making a silk purse out of a pig's ear...

too funny.

 

[Fadge]

Participation award winners for sure Fudgey - you can gloat about being the games biggest chokers over your entire history as much as you like...talk about making a silk purse out of a pig's ear...

too funny.

Much prefer to have to most number of games won in the history of the competition, than having the most number of wooden spoons in the professional era.

 

[Arr0w]

All that matters is flags

But, back to the thread. Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood?

 

[Fadge]

Hilarious.

Here we are in a thread where the topic is who wins the most games in a given year, but we're told the number of games you win doesn't matter and 'premierships are all that count'.

Does that mean that if neither team win the flag this year, this thread is null and void?

OK.

 

[JustaBattler]

Much prefer to have to most number of games won in the history of the competition, than having the most number of wooden spoons in the professional era.

You can quote irrelevancies as much as you like - they are still irrelevant.

I understand why you wish to avoid the topic of the actual thread though.....

 

[JustaBattler]

Hilarious.

Here we are in a thread where the topic is who wins the most games in a given year, but we're told the number of games you win doesn't matter and 'premierships are all that count'.

Does that mean that if neither team win the flag this year, this thread is null and void?

OK.

oh here you go again - trying to add a deflection on top of a deflection - careful fudgey you might spin yourself into more of a confused state than you live in already.

 

[Arr0w]

Hilarious.

Here we are in a thread where the topic is who wins the most games in a given year, but we're told the number of games you win doesn't matter and 'premierships are all that count'.

Does that mean that if neither team win the flag this year, this thread is null and void?

OK.

This is a "2024" thread, merely who finishes higher. Flags are the ultimate prize

Not hard to comprehend

So, who will be better in "2024", you know, tge thread title

 

[Fadge]

You can quote irrelevancies as much as you like - they are still irrelevant.

I understand why you wish to avoid the topic of the actual thread though.....

Well you tell me...

Do winning games of footy count if you don't win the flag?

Because multiple Carlton posters in this thread are saying they don't.

Knot tying... the Carlton supporter's favourite pastime.

 

[Arr0w]

Well you tell me...

Do winning games of footy count if you don't win the flag?

Because multiple Carlton posters in this thread are saying they don't.

Knot tying... the Carlton supporter's favourite pastime.

You are 13th, won 8 games, maybe 9 after today

 

[Fadge]

This is a "2024" thread, merely who finishes higher. Flags are the ultimate prize

Not hard to comprehend

So, who will be better in "2024", you know, tge thread title

Nah, you've said 'flags are all that matter'.

It's there posted above.

Which makes me think.... why are you even in this thread?

 

[Arr0w]

Nah, you've said 'flags are all that matter'.

It's there posted above.

Which makes me think.... why are you even in this thread?

This thread is purely entertainment, especially witnessing constant failed predictions, it's a great source of laughter

 

[Robertio]

Hilarious.

Here we are in a thread where the topic is who wins the most games in a given year, but we're told the number of games you win doesn't matter and 'premierships are all that count'.

Does that mean that if neither team win the flag this year, this thread is null and void?

OK.

 

[JustaBattler]

Well you tell me...

Do winning games of footy count if you don't win the flag?

Because multiple Carlton posters in this thread are saying they don't.

Knot tying... the Carlton supporter's favourite pastime.

No one who posts on here -wins or loses a game of footy - I think you might do well to consider this.

I'm off to lunch with family and then I will squeeze nine holes in ( maybe 12 if I am lucky) these are things we do win or lose in - stuff we personally control.

As for AFL - it is getting a tad too 'fix-turing' and a tad too much run by the type of person I wouldn't have a coffee with tbh.

The whole umpires are being coached by a bloke in the stands - during games issue has been nicely swept under the carpet - doesn't sit well with me - a very "Victorian" shitshow.

 

[Fadge]

No one who posts on here -wins or loses a game of footy - I think you might do well to consider this.

Oh my.

Should this be a call out to everyone who posts in this thread?

Noone is forcing you to post here.

 

[Crankyhawk]

Hilarious.

Here we are in a thread where the topic is who wins the most games in a given year, but we're told the number of games you win doesn't matter and 'premierships are all that count'.

Does that mean that if neither team win the flag this year, this thread is null and void?

OK.

Confusion was generated as to whether it is most games/ premiership points in 2024, furthest post season progression on head to head record as to thread meaning

 

[Arr0w]

Oh my.

Should this be a call out to everyone who posts in this thread?

Noone is forcing you to post here.

2024, any more "prosperity" predictions?

 

[PAFC66]

Neither will do anything

 

[Chief]

Well you tell me...

Do winning games of footy count if you don't win the flag?

Because multiple Carlton posters in this thread are saying they don't.

Knot tying... the Carlton supporter's favourite pastime.

​

Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood?

 

[doppleganger]

​

Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood?

Pretty obvious that once Collingwood win next week to have a 2-0 HTH record over Carlton of who the better team in 2024 was.

 

[doppleganger]

Nah, you've said 'flags are all that matter'.

It's there posted above.

Which makes me think.... why are you even in this thread?

Is he still stalking you?

 

[Chief]

Pretty obvious that once Collingwood win next week to have a 2-0 HTH record over Carlton of who the better team in 2024 was.

Yes it is obvious: Carlton.

 

[Robertio]

Pretty obvious that once Collingwood win next week to have a 2-0 HTH record over Carlton of who the better team in 2024 was.

Richmond because they beat Sydney.

 

[carlton_99]

Pretty obvious that once Collingwood win next week to have a 2-0 HTH record over Carlton of who the better team in 2024 was.

Pies supporters shifting the goalposts