Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Arr0w]

So no predictions? Ok guess we're free to talk about the last 20 years then if 2024 is off the table

Or 60, 80 years?

I see you still love those emojis despite complaining about them, you certainly in your long history of double standards

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Or 60, 80 years?

I see you still love those emojis despite complaining about them, you certainly in your long history of double standards

I've complained about emojis? What are you on today old man? Make a bl#*dy prediction ffs it's 2024

 

[RPCB]

Don't think so. Continue to celebrate the GF losses as you do it must be ingrained in your beliefs that habit

Have you heard the one where Collingwood supporters think their side is good enough to come back from 9 goals behind without the help of the umpires?

 

[Arr0w]

I've complained about emojis? What are you on today old man? Make a bl#*dy prediction ffs it's 2024

Already have corn boy

 

[Worm4]

There are no circumstances where finishing 3rd is better than 2nd, prove otherwise

Finishing 2nd sucks more than finishing 3rd or 4th

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Already have corn boy

No, you made a statement of fact NostrArr0wdamus

So for the record, you have no opinion on who will be better in 2024? In which case you cannot criticise anyone else's analysis or predictions

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Finishing 2nd sucks more than finishing 3rd or 4th

Prove it

 

[GastevsBeard]

could easily be a collingwood carlton grand final if the pies find their best footy

 

[Fadge]

You’re about to be “minnows” then for the next 15+ years.

Playing list falling off a cliff, very poor drafting, TAS about to suck value out of the draft for the next 5 years.

YIKES!

To confirm, when is the 15 years starting?

It's not starting in 2021, as we were reliably informed at the time?

And if it does occur, will you be there to guide us through re: how to cope with it, given your recent experience in being minnows for multiple decades at a time?

Actually, I'm sensing dejavu... I'm positive I had this same conversation with Carlton poster after the 2021 season...

 

[Fadge]

Don't think so. Continue to celebrate the GF losses as you do it must be ingrained in your beliefs that habit

Huh?

So 2nd isn't better than 3rd?

So if Carlton come second this year, and Collingwood lower than second, we don't necessarily have an answer to this thread question?

 

[Fadge]

No, you made a statement of fact NostrArr0wdamus

So for the record, you have no opinion on who will be better in 2024? In which case you cannot criticise anyone else's analysis or predictions

FFS.

Got to love the hypocrisy.

Having a crack at me for refusing to label specific teams contenders until such time as they actually contend for the premiership, yet refuses to share their current thoughts on who the contenders are....

And you get called out for double standards, because you use emoji's after complaining about using emoji's, when it wasn't even you who was complaining!

I've never seem a supporter base tie themselves in as many knots as the Carlton crew currently are. They're not dealing with the weight of expectation well...

 

[Worm4]

could easily be a collingwood carlton grand final if the pies find their best footy

That's a big IF

 

[Fadge]

2024.

Can any Carlton posters please tell me who the premiership contenders are?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

FFS.

Got to love the hypocrisy.

Having a crack at me for refusing to label specific teams contenders until such time as they actually contend for the premiership, yet refuses to share their current thoughts on who the contenders are....

And you get called out for double standards, because you use emoji's after complaining about using emoji's, when it wasn't even you who was complaining!

I've never seem a supporter base tie themselves in as many knots as the Carlton crew currently are. They're not dealing with the weight of expectation well...

I'm a serial abuser of emojis love them

They are a long way out of their "comfort zone" in the bottom 4, it's getting real and they are simply not equipped to cope, overcome with this novel fear of finishing 2nd, which isn't even an official "phobia" it's that ridiculous

 

[Fadge]

I'm a serial abuser of emojis love them

They are a long way out of their "comfort zone" in the bottom 4, it's getting real and they are simply not equipped to cope, overcome with this novel fear of finishing 2nd, which isn't even an official "phobia" it's that ridiculous

Can you imagine being a Carlton supporter and watching your team play in a Preliminary Final?

The left side of your brain would be hoping they'd win, to have a chance to win a flag, whilst the right side of your brain would be hoping they'd lose, so you wouldn't have to finish 2nd if you lost the Grand Final!

 

[BLUEALLTHRU]

FFS.

Got to love the hypocrisy.

Having a crack at me for refusing to label specific teams contenders until such time as they actually contend for the premiership, yet refuses to share their current thoughts on who the contenders are....

And you get called out for double standards, because you use emoji's after complaining about using emoji's, when it wasn't even you who was complaining!

I've never seem a supporter base tie themselves in as many knots as the Carlton crew currently are. They're not dealing with the weight of expectation well...

Got to love Bravery.

The only way to settle this debate is an avatar bet on who gets to 17 first. 1 month duration .

Que crickets...


Put your big boy pants on and put up or shut up.

 

[Fadge]

I'm a serial abuser of emojis love them

They are a long way out of their "comfort zone" in the bottom 4, it's getting real and they are simply not equipped to cope, overcome with this novel fear of finishing 2nd, which isn't even an official "phobia" it's that ridiculous

Maybe we can call it 'Deucephobia'?

 

[BLUEALLTHRU]

Can you imagine being a Carlton supporter and watching your team play in a Preliminary Final?

The left side of your brain would be hoping they'd win, to have a chance to win a flag, whilst the right side of your brain would be hoping they'd lose, so you wouldn't have to finish 2nd if you lost the Grand Final!

Lolingwood have been bridesmaids on numerous occasions to the mighty Baggers.

Short memory!

 

[Fadge]

Que crickets...


Put your big boy pants on and put up or shut up.

Would you be present on BigFooty for that month?

Asking for a friend...

 

[BLUEALLTHRU]

Would you be present on BigFooty for that month?

Asking for a friend...

You betcha.

We on?

 

[Fadge]

You betcha.

We on?

I don't believe you.

Your peers have given Carlton supporters a bad name when it comes to honouring avatar bets.

 

[BLUEALLTHRU]

I don't believe you.

Your peers have given Carlton supporters a bad name when it comes to honouring avatar bets.

Put up or shut up.

 

[Fadge]

Put up or shut up.

I'll go neither.

Thank you.

 

[Arr0w]

No, you made a statement of fact NostrArr0wdamus

So for the record, you have no opinion on who will be better in 2024? In which case you cannot criticise anyone else's analysis or predictions

Of course I have us finishing higher

What about you Chester, do you have us finishing 16th like your inept mate?

 

[CCurnow3votes]

To confirm, when is the 15 years starting?

It's not starting in 2021, as we were reliably informed at the time?

And if it does occur, will you be there to guide us through re: how to cope with it, given your recent experience in being minnows for multiple decades at a time?

Actually, I'm sensing dejavu... I'm positive I had this same conversation with Carlton poster after the 2021 season...

Yes but there’s this thing called time you see & it doesn’t stop.

I’m assuming players the previous Carlton poster was referring to are now a few years older;

Pendlebury 36
Sidebottom 33
Howe 33
Cox 33
Elliott 31
Mihocek 31
Tom Mitchell 30
Crisp 30
Hoskin- Elliott 30

The next couple of years will see your very average drafting filling this gap - .

At least you’ve got your first draft pick this year to bring in a young gun!

Oh hang on!