Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2025

  • Carlton

  • Collingwood


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe they can trade Schultz to freo for a 1st rounder...
All jokes aside, should seriously look at Matt Owies.

Has kicked more goals this year than any of:

Bobby Hill
Lachie Schultz
Dan McStay
Brody Mihocek
Jamie Elliott
Mason Cox
Jordon De Goey
Nick Daicos

Well, anyone on their list actually.

I think something that would work for the Blues to look something like their future first, and one of their promising youngsters……….

On second thoughts, a future first and a late third, early fourth might be more palatable and get it done
 
Last edited:
456904766_1669210416954308_4037106048994832465_n.jpg


My god we stumbled and staggered like some drunkard into the finals, despite only winning twice since the end of June.

Oh well Port Adelaide were able to do us a massive favour in the end! We'll recharge the batteries, get some of the troops back from injury hopefully and have a good crack at the Lions up at the Gabba.

The Saints and Pies fans can put the champagne back on ice for now thankfully!:laughv1:
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Looking forward to hearing the “oh we were lucky to make the 8 anyways this is just a bonus” excuse when the scum are down 10 goals
Ha ha ha at least we have a finals game to look forward to mate. We'll be written off by all and sundry as well, and that will be no bad thing at all.
 
At least when Carlton finish 9th, they do it properly and play finals. Collingwood finishing 9th is so Richmond
Hopefully Collingwood will become a team that's good but not quite good enough to contend, and not bad enough to rebuild properly either.

That really would be a dream scenario if it ever comes to pass.:laughv1:
 
We can call Collingwood Ninthwood now.:laughv1:

We won 2 games since the end of June. And Collingwood still missed finals on percentage after failing to beat world beaters Bombers, Gold Coast, Fremantle and St Kilda, who needed the final 12 seconds to beat us with 18 players missing, this year.

Imagine Collingwood in finals getting 2016 GF umpiring every week.

1724616100951.gif


1724616010724.gif
 
We won 2 games since the end of June. And Collingwood still missed finals on percentage after failing to beat world beaters Bombers, Gold Coast, Fremantle and St Kilda, who needed the final 12 seconds to beat us with 18 players missing, this year.

Imagine Collingwood in finals getting 2016 GF umpiring every week.

View attachment 2091914


View attachment 2091912
They've still got this over us for next season. Would be nice to go into games with the added advantage
Screenshot_20240818_235803_Facebook.jpg
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

We won 2 games since the end of June. And Collingwood still missed finals on percentage after failing to beat world beaters Bombers, Gold Coast, Fremantle and St Kilda, who needed the final 12 seconds to beat us with 18 players missing, this year.

Imagine Collingwood in finals getting 2016 GF umpiring every week.

View attachment 2091914


View attachment 2091912
Their two wins against us this year were all in vain thankfully.:laughv1:
 
Their two wins against us this year were all in vain thankfully.:laughv1:

Yeah, that’s even funnier. They beat the side in 8th twice but failed to beat the aforementioned world beaters. So close to going B2B. You just know it would have happened with them in the finals. Too bad, so sad.
 
Weren't you in the top 2 a few weeks ago?

Epic season meltdown 😎

Meanwhile we're still the reigning premier 👍 we'll still remember this disappointing season more fondly than you guys
Oh dear!:laughv1:
 
"Oh dear" what? You still flushed your season down the toilet, epic meltdown 😆 9 weeks without beating a top 15 side, no finals at MCGView attachment 2091923

Oh whoops
Pies only beat us after the siren, Brisbane panicked last 5 minutes, Melbourne (14th) twice , kangas 17th albeit umpire assistance with a big fat asterisk and the spooners in the same time frame. Hardly the form of a team finals bound either to be fair
 
A proud day for the Blues View attachment 2091924
Are you finger pointing at the club , or the fckhd who threw a projectile at an umpire ?
If it's the latter, I don't think you can paint us all with that same brush. As unfortunate as it is, there are just some dickheads out there who ruin it for everyone.
 
Pies only beat us after the siren, Brisbane panicked last 5 minutes, Melbourne (14th) twice , kangas 17th albeit umpire assistance with a big fat asterisk and the spooners in the same time frame. Hardly the form of a team finals bound either to be fair
Pies made up 10 ladder places on the bumbling Blueshakes in 5 weeks, pretty obvious who has the better form
 
Are you finger pointing at the club , or the fckhd who threw a projectile at an umpire ?
If it's the latter, I don't think you can paint us all with that same brush. As unfortunate as it is, there are just some dickheads out there who ruin it for everyone.
They're STILL looking for him 😆

"What? Na we don't know him... nobody knows him... a complete stranger"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top