( in saying that, pittonet kicked 2 goals in his last final so that elevates him up to around 60th ranking)Pretty sad that they're projecting Pittonet to be in their best 22so obvious he isn't but anyway
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3
- Thread starter Wosh
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.
- Status
They do coaches votes for finals ?
CarmenSandiego
All Australian
- Apr 23, 2024
- 876
- 1,871
- AFL Club
- Carlton
McRae gave Nick 10 votes for every finals game this year.
Not too much talking down of Houston occurring.Especially two in a row, and the LAST TWO, not 2021
This talking down of Houston will be gold
The weird thing is the talking up of Saad.
Laughable to have him within a bulls roar of Maynard - Maynard was runner up in our BnF in premiership year, and was top10 in BnF again last year.
Saad is living off his 2022 year, regressed ever since.
If doing a combined team you wouldn't have Saad in the team
Houston, Maynard, Newman, Quaynor all ahead of him as smalls, and Crisp a better option if used across HB also.
Saad should be ranked down near Sidey and Doc around 30.
Crankyhawk
Hall of Famer
Tbh it looks like early season nick watson
Your obsession with coaches votes continues. Get over it.
How many votes did Nick get this year in the finals ?
As many as every Carlton player combined.
But good to see you're now aware there are Coaches Votes in finals, that are used to determine the Gary Ayres Award winner.
There's so much for you guys to learn about finals - how exciting!
- Dec 9, 2015
- 7,898
- 13,623
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
His output is irrelevant, Blues are just a lot better without him
TDK solo ruck, chopped out by McKay with sprinkles of JSos and Cripps
Pies have only played in the big boy finals (QF, PF and GF) and are 3-0.
Carlton only played in one big boy final (QF, PF and GF) and unsurprisingly lost.
But yes good on Carlton a 5-10 team that played in a few EFs and SFs.
Robertio
Spotswood Guinness Bar manager
How many big boy finals in 2024?
Pies have only played in the big boy finals (QF, PF and GF) and are 3-0.
Carlton only played in one big boy final (QF, PF and GF) and unsurprisingly lost.
But yes good on Carlton a 5-10 team that played in a few EFs and SFs.
Very cute seeing the Geelong and Hawthorn thread.
The sad thing is, it wouldn't surprise me if they looked at that stat and honestly thought - Carlton have been better than Collingwood over the last two seasons because we've played in more finals than them'!
Pies have only played in the big boy finals (QF, PF and GF) and are 3-0.
Carlton only played in one big boy final (QF, PF and GF) and unsurprisingly lost.
But yes good on Carlton a 5-10 team that played in a few EFs and SFs.
The poor things are still learning all about how the finals system works...
He was talking about learning about finals. What better way, than to play in them. More you play in, more you learn. But I guess learning isn't a Collingwood mindset.
Pies have only played in the big boy finals (QF, PF and GF) and are 3-0.
Carlton only played in one big boy final (QF, PF and GF) and unsurprisingly lost.
But yes good on Carlton a 5-10 team that played in a few EFs and SFs.
On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app
Yeah, Collingwood have only played in 40 finals since the current finals system was introduced.
Nearly 3 times as many as Carlton.
We don't have too much more to learn when it comes to 'playing in finals'....
Plenty of lessons to take from not scoring in the first 53 minutes of a final.
Smart thinking by the Baggers.
And the learning was for Carlton supporters, who rarely see their team play in finals in the 21st century, so most don't understand how the finals system actually works.
Robertio
Spotswood Guinness Bar manager
Wasn't the question i asked but i knew you wouldn't answer the question, enjoy Mexico.0 for Carlton
Carlton haven't won a big boy final this millennium
Robertio
Spotswood Guinness Bar manager
What was the Pies scores in the finals this year?
Exactly right. Would expect our guys to learn a heap from that but at least they were there this year. Where were your guys when our final was being played. Did I hear someone say Mexico!
On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll
