Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Fadge]

Carlton - daylight- collingwood

Yeah, not even the most deluded of Carlton supporters could genuinely believe that.

But keep putting up that brave front...

 

[Purple Suit]

You mean these opponents ?View attachment 2089067

Is that Melbourne or WC players? They need jumpers.

 

[Worm4]

Yeah, not even the most deluded of Carlton supporters could genuinely believe that.

But keep putting up that brave front...

Lol, collingwood are entrenched in the bottom half of the ladder. Were in the top 8 for ONLY 3 weeks out of 24.

Carlton have been out of the TOP 8 for only 2 weeks out of the 24.
That's are big gap.
Geez, how putrid for the pies when you look at it that way

 

[Pancakes]

Lol, collingwood are entrenched in the bottom half of the ladder. Were in the top 8 for ONLY 3 weeks out of 24.

Carlton have been out of the TOP 8 for only 2 weeks out of the 24.
That's are big gap.
Geez, how putrid for the pies when you look at it that way

If Carlton miss finals after only being out of the eight for two weeks, would you agree it would be one of the great failures of the game of AFL?
An all time epic choke if you will?

 

[Fadge]

Lol, collingwood are entrenched in the bottom half of the ladder. Were in the top 8 for ONLY 3 weeks out of 24.

Carlton have been out of the TOP 8 for only 2 weeks out of the 24.
That's are big gap.
Geez, how putrid for the pies when you look at it that way

Nice way of saying 'Gee, Carlton shite the bed big time, didn't they?'

What an opportunity missed... such a shame your club has peaked at a 5th placed finish after more than two decades of building and rebuilding.

Oh well....

 

[Fadge]

If Carlton miss finals after only being out of the eight for two weeks, would you agree it would be one of the great failures of the game of AFL?
An all time epic choke if you will?

On equal footing with their 'all-time' choke to miss the finals in 2022.

No club fails to deliver more regularly than the Carlton Football Club.

And it's glorious!

 

[Worm4]

Nice way of saying 'Gee, Carlton shite the bed big time, didn't they?'

What an opportunity missed... such a shame your club has peaked at a 5th placed finish after more than two decades of building and rebuilding.

Oh well....

At least they have a bed to shit in if it happens.
Pies were swimming in shit from round zero. No beds, nothing. Bubcus.

 

[Fadge]

At least they have a bed to shit in if it happens.
Pies were swimming in shit from round zero. No beds, nothing. Bubcus.

'If' it happens?

It's happened.

Carlton were 2nd on the ladder and (false) second favourites for the premiership.

You've now got to win tomorrow to qualify for an away elimination final.

Yet another wasted year, not contending for a premiership.

Oh well...

 

[Robertio]

If Carlton miss finals after only being out of the eight for two weeks, would you agree it would be one of the great failures of the game of AFL?
An all time epic choke if you will?

Do your homework mate, you only need to go back two years.

 

[Worm4]

'If' it happens?

It's happened.

Carlton were 2nd on the ladder and (false) second favourites for the premiership.

You've now got to win tomorrow to qualify for an away elimination final.

Yet another wasted year, not contending for a premiership.

Oh well...

Carlton don't have to win to qualify for finals .
What happens if freo lose ?
Do you need a lesson on how to qualify for finals- sounds like you do....

 

[Robertio]

Nice way of saying 'Gee, Carlton shite the bed big time, didn't they?'

What an opportunity missed... such a shame your club has peaked at a 5th placed finish after more than two decades of building and rebuilding.

Oh well....

Ninthwood lol.

 

[Robertio]

On equal footing with their 'all-time' choke to miss the finals in 2022.

No club fails to deliver more regularly than the Carlton Football Club.

And it's glorious!

Pies started choking in round 1 this year.

 

[Fadge]

Carlton don't have to win to qualify for finals .
What happens if freo lose ?
Do you need a lesson on how to qualify for finals- sounds like you do....

Yes Mr. Carlton supporter....

Please school me on how to qualify for finals.

Just don't try to educate me on how to contend for a premiership.

 

[Robertio]

Yes Mr. Carlton supporter....

Please school me on how to qualify for finals.

Just don't try to educate me on how to contend for a premiership.

The gift that keeps on giving lol.

 

[Cmarsh]

A 2025 thread? Really? How about the focus on the 2024 finals.

 

[Reg Grundy35]

Whatever happens to Carlton, the fact that Collingwood almost always beats them will burn in their guts. How can there be a debate about who is superior when one of the sides almost always beats the other?

 

[Worm4]

Yes Mr. Carlton supporter....

Please school me on how to qualify for finals.

Just don't try to educate me on how to contend for a premiership.

Well then , get your facts straight prior to commenting on how Carlton will or won't qualify. FYI - Carlton win , they're in , Carlton lose and Freo lose, Carlton are in.
Carlton lose , and freo draw, then Carlton are out. Would be a cruel blow if Freo draw.
Considered yourself now as being brought up to date.

 

[Reg Grundy35]

Well then , get your facts straight prior to commenting on how Carlton will or won't qualify. FYI - Carlton win , they're in , Carlton lose and Freo lose, Carlton are in.
Carlton lose , and freo draw, then Carlton are out. Would be a cruel blow if Freo draw.
Considered yourself now as being brought up to date.

Remember when Sam McClure said Carlton should be premiership favourites? Put the Pies aside and think about what a loss to the Saints would truly mean to your club?

 

[Fadge]

Remember when Sam McClure said Carlton should be premiership favourites? Put the Pies aside and think about what a loss to the Saints would truly mean to your club?

I actually think they've resigned themselves to never contending for a premiership again, and will just search for the small things, such as finishing ahead of Collingwood on the ladder by percentage, in what has clearly been a down year for us.

 

[Reg Grundy35]

I actually think they've resigned themselves to never contending for a premiership again, and will just search for the small things, such as finishing ahead of Collingwood on the ladder by percentage, in what has clearly been a down year for us.

I guess its ok to dream of a premiership. - or even a win against Collingwood

 

[Worm4]

Remember when Sam McClure said Carlton should be premiership favourites? Put the Pies aside and think about what a loss to the Saints would truly mean to your club?

Remember when Collingwood were actual favourites for the 2024 flag.......

 

[Fadge]

Remember when Collingwood were actual favourites for the 2024 flag.......

Courtesy of being the reigning premier? That generally happens.

Carlton meanwhile... second favourites for the flag mid season, despite having not contended for a premiership in over two decades.

It was a joke at the time, and even more hilarious in hindsight.

 

[Worm4]

I actually think they've resigned themselves to never contending for a premiership again, and will just search for the small things, such as finishing ahead of Collingwood on the ladder by percentage, in what has clearly been a down year for us.

You've resigned yourself to doing chores around the house this week , throwing some old clothes out, cleaning those windows , and probably sitting in front of the TV watching foxtel wondering what might have been. Love the early resignation from the black and white army - 50k spare seats last night. Lol what happened to all those 110k members last night ?

 

[Worm4]

I guess its ok to dream of a premiership. - or even a win against Collingwood

Don't have to dream about winning premierships against Collingwood. I lived it. More than once too I might add.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

There's still a chance. Saints just need to win by 160 now.