Banter Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood Part 5

[Robertio]

Kennedy and Walsh are about on a par these days. You guys reckon old mungel punter Walshy is a superstar...so...

Owies your best small forward.
Best half back has a Lti, the other one is cooked but ....."we don't need Houston".

Brilliant Carlton list management own goals. 12 gauge both barrels straight to the foot. Never change Carlton.

Halfway through March lol.

 

[Robertio]

It must be so disappointing for them.

Every time they bring up their very best season since the turn of the century - their solitary Preliminary Final appearance - they subconsciously recall it was a Pies flag year...

Answer Walshy's question.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Halfway through March lol.

Never too early for this

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

Where would Kennedy be on the Pies depth chart? Thats all I want to know

FFS. Kennedy's a midfielder, and I've listed 8 players who are ahead of him if all fit.

That's where he is on the Pies depth chart, so he wouldn't be getting a game ahead of 8 midfielders, 10 forwards, and he doesn't play backline or ruck, so there's another dozen positions taken.

 

[Fadge]

Never too early for this View attachment 2253559

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Next week's ladder will be even more interesting...

 

[nahnah]

You must be new here

Fadge can you point another one of your mates to your recommended ‘grade 4 remedial classes’?

Thanks.

Are you frustrated Carmen, may I suggest a stress ball or a cup of peppermint tea

 

[Arr0w]

FFS. Kennedy's a midfielder, and I've listed 8 players who are ahead of him if all fit.

That's where he is on the Pies depth chart, so he wouldn't be getting a game ahead of 8 midfielders, 10 forwards, and he doesn't play backline or ruck, so there's another dozen positions taken.

Who are the 8 mids and the 10 forwards?

 

[Robertio]

Never too early for this View attachment 2253559

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

We're only 4 points and a game behind you, that's the weirdest flex I've ever seen or did i get to you last season, i reckon both.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

FFS. Kennedy's a midfielder, and I've listed 8 players who are ahead of him if all fit.

That's where he is on the Pies depth chart, so he wouldn't be getting a game ahead of 8 midfielders, 10 forwards, and he doesn't play backline or ruck, so there's another dozen positions taken.

Its a very simple exercise Fadge. You've said he'd be a 30-35th best player for the Pies. Is he still in that bracket?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

We're only 4 points and a game behind you, that's the weirdest flex I've ever seen or did i get to you last season, i reckon both.

Had a whole summer of weird flexes didn't we? Equal on points and separated only on %... strap yourself in son

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Arr0w]

Its a very simple exercise Fadge. You've said he'd be a 30-35th best player for the Pies. Is he still in that bracket?

Easier exercise

Who are the 8 mids and the 10 forwards ahead of Kennedy?

This will be very interesting

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Easier exercise

Who are the 8 mids and the 10 forwards ahead of Kennedy?

This will be very interesting

Apparnently Tom Mitchell and Harry Perryman lmao. Also a cooked Pendles who's on as a sub nowadays

 

[Cyclops]

Kennedy lacks the basketball background of a true champion.

I think the Kennedy point has been misconstrued.

Carlton has a list stacked with talent, better than ours. However they have been Carltoned. Some have been Vossed, others Boltoned. This "debuff" plagues them and if they came to Collingwood they'd be way down the list until cleansed.

Imagine an unBoltoned Cripps! Already a champion despite being blued.

 

[Ctracks]

The insecurity of Blue supporters is hilarious

 

[Ctracks]

Where would Kennedy be on the Pies depth chart? Thats all I want to know

Below Ned Long

 

[Fadge]

Its a very simple exercise Fadge. You've said he'd be a 30-35th best player for the Pies. Is he still in that bracket?

Do your sums from the above comment, and there's your answer.

If the maths is too hard for you, maybe use AI or something, because I doubt any of the other Carlton nuff nuff's would be able to help you.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Do your sums from the above comment, and there's your answer.

If the maths is too hard for you, maybe use AI or something, because I doubt any of the other Carlton nuff nuff's would be able to help you.

Its literally a yes or no question... Surely you can answer it...

 

[Fadge]

Its literally a yes or no question... Surely you can answer it...

Of course the answer is yes, still.

Unchanged because Collingwood have actually improved their list since the comment was made, despite a couple of the elder statesmen being a year older, and supported by the information provided in my earlier posts.

But still an important player to a lesser team with lesser depth such as the Ubershizen Bloosers.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Of course the answer is yes, still.

Unchanged because Collingwood have actually improved their list since the comment was made, despite a couple of the elder statesmen being a year older, and supported by the information provided in my earlier posts.

But still an important player to a lesser team with lesser depth such as the Ubershizen Bloosers.

Delusional

 

[Fadge]

^^^^

Sounds as though someone is regretting offloading their 2024 Best Clubman, top 10 B&F place getter, and one of the most durable players on their list.

Oh well.

 

[CarmenSandiego]

^^^^

Sounds as though someone is regretting offloading their 2024 Best Clubman, top 10 B&F place getter, and one of the most durable players on their list.

Oh well.

I should dig up some of your comments on Kennedy when he played for us.

Also - was he that durable? Averaged 14 games per year with us, even after playing every game last year.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

^^^^

Sounds as though someone is regretting offloading their 2024 Best Clubman, top 10 B&F place getter, and one of the most durable players on their list.

Oh well.

They would have been much better off trading Walsh rather than Kennedy. They have about the same impact on games but Walsh is on twice the coin and would've netted them a first rounder plus a second at least.
Sliding doors. Old finger snapper mungrel punter Walshy remains at the Blues bombing his mungrels.
Oh well

 

[nahnah]

would've netted them a first rounder plus a second at least.

thats a heavy price to pay for a cooked medium mid who can't kick

 

[Ctracks]

Carlton are a chance against the Hokballers.

 

[nahnah]

you chucking Saad into that deal Scritchyscroony ?