Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Arr0w]

Wondering what the probability is of Pie supporters seeing more flags than me, based on the last 66 years

Doubt any of them would live that long

Oh boy

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Well they are pretty slim, particularly given Collingwood play Qualifying Finals, Preliminary Finals and Grand Finals, whilst Carlton play Elimination Finals (and if they're very lucky the occasional Semi Final).

It's kind of like dividing a number by 0...

Similar to the odds of Carlton winning a flag since WW2 without K Luke country zone rorts?

What happened in WW2 that sucked the life out of Carlton?

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Arr0w]

Ummm Carlton have won twice the amount of flags since the end of WWII

 

[JustaBattler]

When was the last time the Pies beat Carlton in a Grand Final?

They dirty their already soiled undies at the mere thought of having to play Carlton in a final - look how the dogged making finals last year to avoid the inevitable and rejoice at Carlton missing out by percentage the previous years...

FMD ANYONE could have beted Collingwood in 23's GF - except for Brisbane

the last few years have been lkightweights V lightweights in GF's - everyone knows - hence the total lack of respect for teh outcomes...

Brisbane and Shitney with the hme grounds and Collinwgodo - the umpires pets ...

lol @ these mungies

 

[Corn Cobbers]

So if you take out war-affected years incl post-war, country zone rorts and paper bags, Blues are down to only 4 flags, same as North Melbourne

1906-08 and 1938

Shambles

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[JustaBattler]

Pretty smart by Carlton, cant lose a big final if you're not good enough to make em.

Thus protecting the precious ratio.

Collingwood will do anythign to avoid playing Carlton ina final mate- get over yourself - yoru chest pufery isnt convincing anyone - just false bravado for your fellow dirty birders to hide behind...

 

[JustaBattler]

So if you take out war-affected years incl post-war, country zone rorts and paper bags, Blues are down to only 4 flags, same as North Melbourne

1906-08 and 1938

Shambles

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

iof this and maybe that and coulda woulda benn this that or teh other thing -

LOL at your imaginings

 

[Corn Cobbers]

iof this and maybe that and coulda woulda benn this that or teh other thing -

LOL at your imaginings

Three quarters of your flags have an asterisk, must be embarrassing

No wonder the Blues are at sea in the modern era

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[JustaBattler]

Three quarters of your flags have an asterisk, must be embarrassing

No wonder the Blues are at sea in the modern era

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

All yoru flags are cheat flags mate...

blah blah blah

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Last beat us in a grand final in 1910 last beat us in any sort of final in 1984.

 

[doppleganger]

They'll still be pulling out that line in 60 years when we're 8 flags and a further 20 Grand Final appearances ahead of them, and they're still waiting for their first top 4 finish of the 21st Century...

Poor crusty old Bagger fans are the new Dees fans.

A 40 year old Dee in 1965 could brag he had seen 10 flags live and his Dees were the power team
A 50 year old Dee in 1975 could still brag he had seen 10 flags live, and that the Dees were still top few in overall flags
A 60 year old Dee in 1985 was still bragging that he had seen 10 flags live, despite it being over 20 years since the Dees made a GF
A 70 year old Dee in 1995 was rambling about seeing 10 flags live, but now 30+ years sinces the Dees made a GF and the Dees were long forgotten as being a power club.
A 80 year old Dee in 2005 could barely remember the 10 flags he saw, and it was 50+ years since the Dees last flag the Dees are a minnow club now.
If any 90 year old Dees still around in 2015, they had forgot how many flags the Dees had won, and the Dees are selling home games

Just add 30 years to the dates and drop a few flags for Carlton - so we are effectively at 1995 stage of the Dees cycle. There are 70 year old Bagger fans still rambling about seeing flags live, but it has been 30 years since Carlton saluted and they arent considered a power club in the AFL anymore.

 

[JustaBattler]

Last beat us in a grand final in 1910 last beat us in any sort of final in 1984.

easy beats these dirty birders are...very very easy beats -Ive got my fingers crossed that their pensioners have got another year in them and they fluke a finals possie - and Carlton gets the chance to put the mail in their coffin - as is the natural order of things.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

easy beats these dirty birders are...very very easy beats -Ive got my fingers crossed that their pensioners have got another year in them and they fluke a finals possie - and Carlton gets the chance to put the mail in their coffin - as is the natural order of things.

There are Collingwood supporters in their early 40s who have never experienced a meaningful loss to Carlton

"Easy beats"

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

easy beats these dirty birders are...very very easy beats -Ive got my fingers crossed that their pensioners have got another year in them and they fluke a finals possie - and Carlton gets the chance to put the mail in their coffin - as is the natural order of things.

Tell us more about putting mail in coffins?

I hope you don't expect the recipient to respond too quickly...

 

[Fadge]

Collingwood will do anythign to avoid playing Carlton ina final mate

Including sending Micky Malthouse there to send the club back a decade.

Now they've fallen for the Graham Wright plant.

Oh no.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

More excuses. Typical.

Yeah I guess Carlton being unable to make finals for the best part of 3 decades is just an "excuse"

 

[JustaBattler]

Including sending Micky Malthouse there to send the club back a decade.

Now they've fallen for the Graham Wright plant.

Oh no.

that one was below the belt ...

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Including sending Micky Malthouse there to send the club back a decade.

Now they've fallen for the Graham Wright plant.

Oh no.

They just never learn do they.
They're all ridiculing the Schultz trade for being terrible. Next minute they recruit the guy who did it and think he's a legend

 

[JustaBattler]

There are Collingwood supporters in their early 40s who have never experienced a meaningful loss to Carlton

"Easy beats"

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Including sending Micky Malthouse there to send the club back a decade.

Now they've fallen for the Graham Wright plant.

Oh no.

Graham Wright who ur club was disappointed to lose... Hmm

 

[JustaBattler]

Graham Wright who ur club was disappointed to lose... Hmm

Bolton says hold my beer!

 

[Cyclops]

Wondering what the probability is of Pie supporters seeing more flags than me, based on the last 66 years

Doubt any of them would live that long

Oh boy

Carlton flags without cheating in the last 66 years: 0

Pies flags without cheating in the sane period: 3.

So 100% chance ill see more flags than you, unless you get better at cheating again.

 

[doppleganger]

There are Collingwood supporters in their early 40s who have never experienced a meaningful loss to Carlton

"Easy beats"

Carlton beating us Rd3 in 2012 probably their biggest win against the Pies in 21st century.

After their strong for Carlton (5th) in 2011 the Baggers were the April premiership favs after knocking us off and being undefeated to start the year.

Blueshakes came early in 2012 though, and by June they were outside the top8.

 

[doppleganger]

Bolton says hold my beer!

Pies didnt promote Bolton to a role he aint proven in. We brought him in to do what he has proven to be great at.

 

[JustaBattler]

Carlton beating us Rd3 in 2012 probably their biggest win against the Pies in 21st century.

After their strong for Carlton (5th) in 2011 the Baggers were the April premiership favs after knocking us off and being undefeated to start the year.

Blueshakes came early in 2012 though, and by June they were outside the top8.

you'll have those fond memories to look back on in your dotage m8.