Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Arr0w]

66 is the relevant number ie any Carlton fan under 66 cannot claim to have vivid memories of 8 flags

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Want to think about that?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

How many living pie players have won more than 2 flags compared to Carlton players?

Do you find it embarrassing?

Thoughts?

Super lame comeback as usual. I've seen 2 flags in the last 14 years while Carlton win spoon after spoon and rack up a losing record to North and the Saints.

You have to be embarrassed.

 

[Arr0w]

Super lame comeback as usual. I've seen 2 flags in the last 14 years while Carlton win spoon after spoon and rack up a losing record to North and the Saints.

You have to be embarrassed.

Another one that lacks comprehension

Read it slowly and carefully

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Guys, guys.....

I've just developed a new Fadgegorithm!

With Carlton's youngest premiership player turning 50 next year, I wanted to know the probability of this current drought extending beyond the lives of all Carlton premiership players.

The answer - 12.25%

I'm a bit surprised the odds are that low to be honest.
But as usual you are the expert and I'll trust your algorithms.

 

[Arr0w]

This is not even a challenge anymore

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Another one that lacks comprehension

Read it slowly and carefully

Ok. Did. Nothing changed. Tell me what I did not comprehend from your brilliant post. Please...spell it out for me...

 

[Arr0w]

Ok. Did. Nothing changed. Tell me what I did not comprehend from your brilliant post. Please...spell it out for me...

How many living pie players have won more than 2 flags compared to Carlton players?

Let it sink in

 

[Arr0w]

Go to bed pie supporters, you're embarrassing yourselves, again

 

[Fadge]

I'm a bit surprised the odds are that low to be honest.
But as usual you are the expert and I'll trust your algorithms.

Well, there were a number of very complex factors incorporated into the algorithm, including medical advancements that will lead to increased life expectancy.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

How many living pie players have won more than 2 flags compared to Carlton players?

Let it sink in

Yeah I read and comprehended that. Cute you thought it was somehow hard to understand. So? As I said... Super lame comeback! What part of that did you not comprehend?
I'm also not interested in your ancient history and 70 year old ex Carlton players ... No one is.. we are 1/4 of the way through a new century FFS!

So as I said... I've seen 2 flags in 14 years, plenty of top 4 finishes, a ton of wins against your pathetic mob all while watching you guys win spoon after spoon and not even make top 4 once.
Comprende?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Go to bed pie supporters, you're embarrassing yourselves, again

You drinking beer, whisky or wine tonight?

 

[Arr0w]

Yeah I read and comprehended that. Cute you thought it was somehow hard to understand. So? As I said... Super lame comeback! What part of that did you not comprehend?
I'm also not interested in your ancient history and 70 year old ex Carlton players ... No one is.. we are 1/4 of the way through a new century FFS!

So as I said... I've seen 2 flags in 14 years, plenty of top 4 finishes, a ton of wins against your pathetic mob all while watching you guys win spoon after spoon and not even make top 4 once.
Comprende?

Oh boy

 

[Arr0w]

You drinking beer, whisky or wine tonight?

Whisky and cigar

 

[King Tut]

66 is the relevant number ie any Carlton fan under 66 cannot claim to have vivid memories of 8 flags

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

I’m surprised any Blues fan of that vintage are still awake at this time.Arr0w you’ll be snooty tomorrow mate without your much needed 16 hours kip.

Hopefully the staff at your home remember to roll you every few hours to prevent any bed sores.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Oh boy

Awesome response

 

[Arr0w]

I’m surprised any Blues fan of that vintage are still awake at this time.Arr0w you’ll be snooty tomorrow mate without your much needed 16 hours kip.

Hopefully the staff at your home remember to roll you every few hours to prevent any bed sores.

Coming from King Tut?

Surprised your arms are still attached, typing with a toe bone?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

I’m surprised any Blues fan of that vintage are still awake at this time.Arr0w you’ll be snooty tomorrow mate without your much needed 16 hours kip.

Hopefully the staff at your home remember to roll you every few hours to prevent any bed sores.

He's a lot younger than he's been letting on, this 80 year thing was a ruse... he was actually only about 3 years old at the 1968 GF, an event for which he claims to have "vivid memories"

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Arr0w]

Night you pretenders, yes, that means you too fudge

 

[King Tut]

Coming from King Tut?

Surprised your arms are still attached, typing with a toe bone?

Mummy’s the word

 

[Noidnadroj]

Yeah nah. Cerra takes clean possession and Nick is the one running to nowhere with Walsh is wide open.

Exact same stuff happens with players like Jack Higgins who starts running forward even before his team has won possession back. Sometimes it works out and looks great, other times he just runs to the middle of nowhere and hinders his team.

Coin flip moment that went the Pies way that day.

Watch the video. It was really poor from Walsh, just own it. Cerra never took clean possession, and Walsh let Naicos run goal side into open space and onto a ball that came off hands in a contest.

It’s no big deal. It was really bad from Walsh given the state of the game, his opponent and the way the play unfolded.

But why there’s some weird insistence Cerra took clean possession and Walsh was moving into space to receive possession is just baffling. The actual video shows nothing of the sort.

I am no Naicos or Collingwood apologist, but that was brilliant from him and poor from Walsh. Just own it … I’m sure Walsh does and I’m sure it wouldn’t happen again.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Scritchyscroony]

He's a lot younger than he's been letting on, this 80 year thing was a ruse... he was actually only about 3 years old at the 1968 GF, an event for which he claims to have "vivid memories"

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Shifty old bugger!

 

[jezzajay]

View attachment 2186974
Looks pretty coordinated holding the premiership cup to me.

Maybe he’s doing it wrong. Can you show me one of Crippa doing the same so I can make sure?

That's cute...Anyone can look coordinated in a photo.. holding a handle and having someone else hold the object with you is hardly groundbreaking and requiring much coordination...even you wouldn't stuff that up I'm sure.

 

[jezzajay]

Sends shivers down the spine reading that.
To be fair Sam Walsh has a role in this epic albeit as an extra. Standing next to Nick at a stoppage is probably the closest to greatness he’ll get.

He stands next to Cripps every day...proven great of the game...twice!
Can't say that for any Collingwood players...lol

 

[King Tut]

That's cute...Anyone can look coordinated in a photo.. holding a handle and having someone else hold the object with you is hardly groundbreaking and requiring much coordination...even you wouldn't stuff that up I'm sure.

Just show me a pic of Cripps holding a premiership cup to confirm this for me mate. Humour me.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Watch the video. It was really poor from Walsh, just own it. Cerra never took clean possession, and Walsh let Naicos run goal side into open space and onto a ball that came off hands in a contest.

It’s no big deal. It was really bad from Walsh given the state of the game, his opponent and the way the play unfolded.

But why there’s some weird insistence Cerra took clean possession and Walsh was moving into space to receive possession is just baffling. The actual video shows nothing of the sort.

I am no Naicos or Collingwood apologist, but that was brilliant from him and poor from Walsh. Just own it … I’m sure Walsh does and I’m sure it wouldn’t happen again.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

This is by far the best and most intelligent post this thread has ever seen from a Tigers poster.
Falcon take note!