Remove this Banner Ad

Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2025

  • Collingwood

    Votes: 126 52.1%
  • Carlton

    Votes: 116 47.9%

  • Total voters
    242

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh surprise surprise Carlton given an arm chair ride again via their number 1 benefactors-the AFL
I mean what’s this like 3rd or 4th year in row the AFL have handed them a finals position on silver platter, with ridiculously cushy draw?

Oh well it seems the blooze are again this years AFL anointed “fairytale “ team ….im just now wondering that luke Darcy’s no longer commentating, who will pick up the slack for Carlton fans in terms of repeating the word “brave” ad nauseam after describing every CFC loss?
Whingers from all clubs are welcome here, helps with our entertainment.
 
The fixture shows how shitter teams finish in front other teams, despite going 0-2 against them
You couldn't beat Essendon and Adelaide mate, had nothing to do with the fixture.
 
Insane to me that Carlton yet again gets an incredible fixture but I really shouldn't be surprised, especially how the umpires mysteriously favour them in close games.

Carlton will finish higher end of H&A, Pies will finish higher after finals.
Umpires favouring Carlton "in close games" is peak comedy
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

We beat Adelaide.
If you're gonna use facts as some kind of "burn" make sure you get them right otherwise you look like a 🤡.
Can't win them all but you get my drift, there were teams you should've beaten and didn't, that's why you didn't play finals and the draw had nothing to do with it.
 
Can't win them all but you get my drift, there were teams you should've beaten and didn't, that's why you didn't play finals and the draw had nothing to do with it.
Of course. Because every team that played finals didn't lose a single game against teams they should have beaten...

And I'm sure Carlton would have preferred to have played Sydney twice (as Collingwood did), than Richmond twice (as Carlton did).

But the 'fixture' had nothing to do with the eventual ladder...
 
Last edited:
Of course. Because every team that played finals didn't lose a single game against teams they should have beaten...

And I'm sure Carlton would have preferred to have played Sydney twice (as Collingwood did), than Richmond twice (as Carlton did).

But the 'fixture' had nothing to do with the eventual ladder...
Still sooking about the fixture I see, you really are salty
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Of course. Because every team that played finals didn't lose a single game against teams they should have beaten...

And I'm sure Carlton would have preferred to have played Sydney twice (as Collingwood did), than Richmond twice (as Carlton did).

But the 'fixture' had nothing to do with the eventual ladder...
If we are talking preferences I would have preferred not to play 7 games (equal highest in the comp) against the eventual top 4 but we don't always get what we want unfortunately.
 
If we are talking preferences I would have preferred not to play 7 games (equal highest in the comp) against the eventual top 4 but we don't always get what we want unfortunately.
So GWS were amongst the 'eventual top 4' were they?

Because we've been told for the past 14 months that the ladder is updated after finals.

Interesting...
 
So GWS were amongst the 'eventual top 4' were they?

Because we've been told for the past 14 months that the ladder is updated after finals.

Interesting...
That makes Brisbane the fifth best team in 2024.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

So GWS were amongst the 'eventual top 4' were they?

Because we've been told for the past 14 months that the ladder is updated after finals.

Interesting...
I'm talking about fixturing solely in the home and away season. Giants were a top 4 team in the H+A.
 
Carlton.

The AFL in all its bias has again kissed them on the proverbial and rewarded them with a soft draw not befitting their position because clearly the AFL needs to meddle as much as possible by finding any advantage it can give to them. No five day breaks when other teams have 2, gifted double ups against North and WCE (Curnow will therefore win the Coleman easily) and you could go on.

Either way, hopefully Collingwood will be better.
 
Carlton.

The AFL in all its bias has again kissed them on the proverbial and rewarded them with a soft draw not befitting their position because clearly the AFL needs to meddle as much as possible by finding any advantage it can give to them. No five day breaks when other teams have 2, gifted double ups against North and WCE (Curnow will therefore win the Coleman easily) and you could go on.

Either way, hopefully Collingwood will be better.
Yes, the AFL has done so much to help Carlton in the last 20 years...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top