Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Scritchyscroony]

Not if Petracca nominates

Be hard to get that deal done. Also not sure it's a good fit at his age with us needing youth.

 

[Fadge]

Lying lightweight, I placed the bet?

Oh no.

Do you actually need someone to explain what the term 'hypothetical scenario' means?

 

[Arr0w]

Oh no.

Do you actually need someone to explain what the term 'hypothetical scenario' means?

You never mentioned "hypothetical scenario" in that post, another lie

Get help

 

[Fadge]

Okay, back to more facts, Carlton better in 2024 and over 80 years

'CArr0w facts' - two false statements.

But as I said, compulsive liars fail to realise they are actually lying

 

[Fadge]

Get help

Seems as though you're the one that needs help.

Hypothetical/Hypocritical

Same/Same (in CArr0w's world).

 

[Arr0w]

'CArr0w facts' - two false statements.

But as I said, compulsive liars fail to realise they are actually lying

This will be fun

2024 Carlton finish in the 8, Pies don't

Over 80 years 10 to 5 in flags

Where are the false statements?

 

[Arr0w]

Seems as though you're the one that needs help.

Hypothetical/Hypocritical

Same/Same (in CArr0w's world).

Get help

 

[Fadge]

This will be fun

2024 Carlton finish in the 8, Pies don't

Over 80 years 10 to 5 in flags

Where are the false statements?

We've been through it all before (but wouldn't be surprised if you weren't able to comprehend the facts).

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Agree.

Pies in same boat, would have top 4 as the pass mark for 2025.

If we don't make it, think Fly is safe as he already has a flag and a couple of top 4 finishes to give him a bit of security.

Oh yeah fly's safe. He will be in charge of the upcoming mini rebuild we will be on after 2025.
And having already won a flag I don't think we are in the same boat as Carlton in terms of pressure to perform.
Their fans will burn the place down when they realise they've blown yet another rebuild.
I just can't see the likes of Curnow being able to handle the pressure. The Blueshakes are a real thing for their mob who repeatedly wilt when the going gets really tough.

Horse to coach the Bloos in 2026 is my tip.

 

[Arr0w]

We've been through it all before (but wouldn't be surprised if you weren't able to comprehend the facts).

There you go again, you really do struggle

Make a claim, challenged, can't provide evidence

Get help fudge, you're embarrassing yourself

Even your mate called you out in that wager claim, "Fadge made an error"

Need another shovel?

 

[Fadge]

Horse to coach the Bloos in 2026 is my tip.

And if Horse takes the reins (see what I did there?) he certainly won't be planning for 3 or 4 years don't the track.

He will recruit for the now, given the age profile of their top end - a top end that Carlton rely on more so than any other team.

 

[Worm4]

Be hard to get that deal done. Also not sure it's a good fit at his age with us needing youth.

He would fit right in at age 29 . Some clubs would consider him young

 

[Arr0w]

Easier than candy from a baby

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Oh yeah fly's safe. He will be in charge of the upcoming mini rebuild we will be on after 2025.
And having already won a flag I don't think we are in the same boat as Carlton in terms of pressure to perform.
Their fans will burn the place down when they realise they've blown yet another rebuild.
I just can't see the likes of Curnow being able to handle the pressure. The Blueshakes are a real thing for their mob who repeatedly wilt when the going gets really tough.

Horse to coach the Bloos in 2026 is my tip.

They just haven't got the depth to survive a normal amount of injuries

Tipping Voss will go to Gather Round 1-3 and coaching for his job against the Eagles, might hang on until June

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

There you go again, you really do struggle

Make a claim, challenged, can't provide evidence

How many times do you expect us to repeat the same facts?

If you couldn't understand what we were saying the first, second or 16th time, you should have told us to slow down and simplify it to cater for the lowest common denominator.

 

[Arr0w]

How many times do you expect us to repeat the same facts?

If you couldn't understand what we were saying the first, second or 16th time, you should have told us to slow down and simplify it to cater for the lowest common denominator.

Get help

 

[Corn Cobbers]

There you go again, you really do struggle

Make a claim, challenged, can't provide evidence

Get help fudge, you're embarrassing yourself

Even your mate called you out in that wager claim, "Fadge made an error"

Need another shovel?

Error on a minor, irrelevant detail that had zero to do with the point

You are such a gormless liar I've never seen anything like it omg

Vivid memories at 3yo

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

They just haven't got the depth to survive a normal amount of injuries

Tipping Voss will go to Gather Round 1-3 and coaching for his job against the Eagles, might hang on until June

Yep, spot on.

How many consecutive years are we going to hear 'Carlton underachieved because injuries', despite when you look at it in any level of detail, you'll see that they actually weren't impacted anywhere near as badly as other clubs were in relation to their better and most important players.

But because Silvagni, Docherty and Martin missed over 60 games between them, they were crucified by injury!

 

[Worm4]

Yep, spot on.

How many consecutive years are we going to hear 'Carlton underachieved because injuries', despite when you look at it in any level of detail, you'll see that they actually weren't impacted anywhere near as badly as other clubs were in relation to their better and most important players.

But because Silvagni, Docherty and Martin missed over 60 games between them, they were crucified by injury!

Keep hanging your hat on our depth.
We lost doc , silvagni, Marchbank, Cunningham and Martin for 90-95% of the season.
The latter 3 are gonski, and replaced with some some players who will play more game time than those 3 ever did.
There's 5 extra players straight away.
We have plenty of depth.

 

[doppleganger]

If there was a reasonable Blues fan on gods green earth, they would not argue with this one bit.

2025 is the shit or get off the pot season for Carlton, time for a 16 win H&A season and a top 4 finish.

 

[Fadge]

Keep hanging your hat on our depth.
We lost doc , silvagni, Marchbank, Cunningham and Martin for 90-95% of the season.
The latter 3 are gonski, and replaced with some some players who will play more game time than those 3 ever did.
There's 5 extra players straight away.
We have plenty of depth.

Oh yeah, sorry.

Forgot to include Marchbank and Cuningham.

OMFG.

 

[Arr0w]

Carlton finish higher, they blame the draw (after the fact), umpiring and injuries

Another fun day where they dig another hole

oh boy

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Oh yeah, sorry.

Forgot to include Marchbank and Cuningham.

OMFG.

Also guys who DID play a lot of games like Owies, Kennedy and to a lesser extent Carroll, they're gonski too, surely they come off the total

Depth shredded all for a skinny 18yo

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

Carlton finish higher, they blame the draw (after the fact)

Yeah, how dare anyone review the draw 'after the fact' - that is, based on how teams actually performed across a season, as opposed to how they were predicted to perform.

Again showing you're the one who needs to 'Get Help'....

 

[Fadge]

Also guys who DID play a lot of games like Owies, Kennedy and to a lesser extent Carroll, they're gonski too, surely they come off the total

Depth shredded all for a skinny 18yo

Yep.

A team that's allegedly had major issues with injury over the years let go two of their most reliable and durable players.

Interesting decision.