Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[South of the Yarra]

Is that why he got 70 odd coaches votes this year in a down season?

So, thank you for admitting Nick Daicos is the best player in the country this year. Now coaches votes counts, thank you. Please note that on 29th December 2024, WalshistheGOAT admitted Nick Daicos was the Premier player in the competition in 2024.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

So, thank you for admitting Nick Daicos is the best player in the country this year. Now coaches votes counts, thank you. Please note that on 29th December 2024, WalshistheGOAT admitted Nick Daicos was the Premier player in the competition in 2024.

That would be Cripps actually. Only player this year to come top 2 in the Brownlow, AFLCA and MVP

 

[YeoShuey]

So, thank you for admitting Nick Daicos is the best player in the country this year. Now coaches votes counts, thank you. Please note that on 29th December 2024, WalshistheGOAT admitted Nick Daicos was the Premier player in the competition in 2024.

They don't count for Daicos when the Collingwood coach gives him the max even when undeserved.

 

[South of the Yarra]

That would be Cripps actually. Only player this year to come top 2 in the Brownlow, AFLCA and MVP

Oh but you just placed all the importance on coaches votes, make up your mind.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Oh but you just placed all the importance on coaches votes, make up your mind.

Well lets see...

Squibcos won the AFLCA by 4 votes (mind you thats with Farcical Fly rigging them in his favour)
Cripps won the Brownlow by 7 votes...
Cripps came a narrow 2nd in the MVP while Nicky was way down in 4th...

Therefor, Cripps easily the best player in the AFL in 2024.

 

[Arr0w]

Walsh does not hurt teams. No impact on games at all.


Carlton have won 100 % of their flags last Millenium
Carlton have won 100% of their flags last Century.

That is footballs biggest embarrassment. Minnow Club.

Yes, we have been poor the last 3 decades, but 5 flags since WWII is embarrassing

Not even in the top 8 for flags compared to other clubs over that period

Strangely enough, eerily similar to this year

 

[YeoShuey]

Better question.

How many coaches votes did Cox get?

 

[South of the Yarra]

WalshistheGOAT Arr0w YeoShuey

You are running around trying to goad others into a bet. I am happy to take a bet with anyone of you right now. Happy to make it all 3 if you want. If Collingwood finishes higher in 2025 (After Finals) than Carlton, the 3 of you can have a Nick Daicos or Mason Cox pic of my choosing. If Carlton finishes higher than Collingwood after finals, I will have a Sam Walsh or Patrick Cripps picture of your choosing. The pic must be used from the completion of the 2025 Grand Final to the commencement of the 2026 season.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

WalshistheGOAT Arr0w YeoShuey

You are running around trying to goad others into a bet. I am happy to take a bet with anyone of you right now. Happy to make it all 3 if you want. If Collingwood finishes higher in 2025 (After Finals) than Carlton, the 3 of you can have a Nick Daicos or Mason Cox pic of my choosing. If Carlton finishes higher than Collingwood after finals, I will have a Sam Walsh or Patrick Cripps picture of your choosing. The pic must be used from the completion of the 2025 Grand Final to the commencement of the 2026 season.

Given you've got 3 against one there I feel its a little unfair... If you find 2 other Pieheads from this thread such as Scritchyscroony Corn Cobbers Fadge Pistol Night etc to be on the other side of the wager I'm willing to accept. Depends on what the others say however...

 

[doppleganger]

Better question.

How many coaches votes did Cox get?

Billy Frampton had more coaches votes than A.Cerra in 2024.

 

[YeoShuey]

WalshistheGOAT Arr0w YeoShuey

You are running around trying to goad others into a bet. I am happy to take a bet with anyone of you right now. Happy to make it all 3 if you want. If Collingwood finishes higher in 2025 (After Finals) than Carlton, the 3 of you can have a Nick Daicos or Mason Cox pic of my choosing. If Carlton finishes higher than Collingwood after finals, I will have a Sam Walsh or Patrick Cripps picture of your choosing. The pic must be used from the completion of the 2025 Grand Final to the commencement of the 2026 season.

Given you've got 3 against one there I feel its a little unfair... If you find 2 other Pieheads from this thread such as Scritchyscroony Corn Cobbers Fadge Pistol Night etc to be on the other side of the wager I'm willing to accept. Depends on what the others say however...

Find 2 other Pies fans, give us the option of either Daicos or Cox, and you guys the option of Walsh or Cripps, and I am happy to accept too.

 

[YeoShuey]

Billy Frampton had more coaches votes than A.Cerra in 2024.

Irrelevant.

How many did Cox get this year? How many did Cerra get this year?

 

[doppleganger]

Irrelevant.

How many did Cox get? How many did Cerra get?

Very relevant if you think coaches votes are important.

The great Cerra not as good as Billy "premiership FF" Frampton.

Frampton never been as good as Cox.

 

[YeoShuey]

Very relevant if you think coaches votes are important.

The great Cerra not as good as Billy "premiership FF" Frampton.

Frampton never been as good as Cox.

And where are the numbers?

How many coaches votes did Cox get this year? How many votes did Cerra get this year?

 

[doppleganger]

And where are the numbers?

How many coaches votes did Cox get this year? How many votes did Cerra get this year?

Frampton 2
Cerra 1
Cox 0

All battlers really.

But Cox lifts in big finals, unlike Adam "1/2 as good as Frampton in 2024" Cerra.

 

[JustaBattler]

Fudgey are you still chickening away with squibby gutslessness and a big fat mouthing of nuffery amnd chanelling your inner kidGOAT?

Keep it up but try and give yoir sock puppet mates some of their own lines Fudgeywood is boring.

 

[YeoShuey]

Frampton 2
Cerra 1
Cox 0

All battlers really.

But Cox lifts in big finals, unlike Adam "1/2 as good as Frampton in 2024" Cerra.

Your stat means nothing when Cerra was injured and played 5 less games than Frampton.

 

[YeoShuey]

Imagine looking at these stats and thinking Frampton is the better player

Adam Cerra and Billy Frampton AFL Stats Comparison

Adam Cerra and Billy Frampton AFL Stats Comparison.

www.footywire.com

Or these ones and thinking that Cox is the better player.

Adam Cerra and Mason Cox AFL Stats Comparison

Adam Cerra and Mason Cox AFL Stats Comparison.

www.footywire.com

Moronic thinking if those are your thoughts.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Imagine looking at these stats and thinking Frampton is the better player

Adam Cerra and Billy Frampton AFL Stats Comparison

Adam Cerra and Billy Frampton AFL Stats Comparison.

www.footywire.com

Or these ones and thinking that Cox is the better player.

Adam Cerra and Mason Cox AFL Stats Comparison

Adam Cerra and Mason Cox AFL Stats Comparison.

www.footywire.com

Moronic thinking if those are your thoughts.

And they're the stats for arguably Cerra's worst year in the AFL ever vs arguably Framptons best...

 

[doppleganger]

Your stat means nothing when Cerra was injured and played 5 less games than Frampton.

No shame in only being half as good as Frampton according to the coaches in 2024.

Frampton is Cox' back-up, Moore's help if needed and a premiership FF, an all rounder.

 

[YeoShuey]

And they're the stats for arguably Cerra's worst year in the AFL ever vs arguably Framptons best...

Exactly

I could post their career average too, but Cerra is destroying them in that regard as well. Way better player.

 

[doppleganger]

I could post their career average too, but Cerra is destroying them in that regard as well. Way better player.

Need to see more stats for Adam "1/2 as good as Frampton in 2024 according to the coaches" Cerra and how mediocre he is.

So many stats, so little impact.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Need to see more stats for Adam "1/2 as good as Frampton in 2024 according to the coaches" Cerra and how mediocre he is.

So many stats, so little impact.

What are Cerra and Framptons career totals for Coaches Votes?

 

[YeoShuey]

What are Cerra and Framptons career totals for Coaches Votes?

I can give those stats to you.

Cerra: 119 in 129 games.
Cox: 42 in 129 games.
Frampton: 12 in 58 games.

Now here are the averages:
Cerra: 0.92
Cox: 0.33
Frampton: 0.21

Our superstar Cerra is the best, and that comes as no surprise to anyone with a functioning brain.

 

[Worm4]

it does... its a fair bet given 343 pages of cluckering, its basically an admission of well, lack of confidence, and thats OK, given their historic record.

0-60

72 to 7 halfway through the last quarter. Embarassing