Bound_4_Glory
Draftee
- Feb 26, 2007
- 14
- 0
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
WRFL Division 2
- Thread starter coldog
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Bound_4_Glory
Draftee
- Feb 26, 2007
- 14
- 0
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Bound_4_Glory
Draftee
- Feb 26, 2007
- 14
- 0
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Hey Weapons credit to the Deer Park guys who obviously had a fair crack at the game today. From what i'm hearing big things are happening down there next year so I don't think it will be long before they get back to the form of 2006.
I hear he got a red card. Isn't that an automatic weeks suspension?
Yes if you are guilty of both. He will play this week end of story.
yeah weapons ur not wrong mate the umpiring was shocking both ways, ive never seen so many deliberate out of bounds in the 1 game, wata joke, ah well, we got away with the win, but to deerparks credit they played pretty good..
i did get smacked a few time champ but dont know about getting smashed from pillar to post...
bring on nth footscray
ColeReserve
Debutant
Watched the Heightsv North game Saturday and liked what I saw from Heights in regard to their leg speed and hardness at the ball.North wasted a lot forward and really struggled setting up anything in the forward line.
Only downside I saw was the constant bickering of Heights players toward umpire decisions - both field and goal umpires - regardless of your opinions of the Umpires - your performance in finals will not be helped if you continue to antagonise these guys and ultimately may cost you.
Should be a good game v West's this week
Only downside I saw was the constant bickering of Heights players toward umpire decisions - both field and goal umpires - regardless of your opinions of the Umpires - your performance in finals will not be helped if you continue to antagonise these guys and ultimately may cost you.
Should be a good game v West's this week
- Banned
- #5,486
Where are the Division 2 finals being held this year?
What I think you might find was that West was not instructed to NOT watch the game but they were to be at Shorten Reserve by 2.30pm to prepare for a training session that started at 3pm.
it was great to see robbie acknowledged in todays paper for kicking his ton well done to him and Nick and fais for winning their respective awards on the weekend
easy_champ
Debutant
i couldn't make it to the game on saturday, but congrat's on the W and to Robbie, a well deserve 100!! i heard that Mallia got reported is that true, also heard not much in it but also heard that was his second send -off for the game? If thats true, thats an automatic 1 week suspension isn't it just for being sent off? Even if you get off the reports? Hope not, looking forward for a ripper of a game next week, will make for some very good viewing
No. People seem to think that but it is not true. The rule is you are RED carded and not allowed back on after send off number 2. Nick is not under suspension at the moment. He has 2 charges to face tomorrow night. (very soft charges too)
Anyone else at the game agree that the goal Greto kicked to notch the TON was an absolute CRACKER? As good a goal as you will see anywhere!!
HI guys ,yeah weapons ur not wrong mate the umpiring was shocking both ways, ive never seen so many deliberate out of bounds in the 1 game, wata joke, ah well, we got away with the win, but to deerparks credit they played pretty good..
i did get smacked a few time champ but dont know about getting smashed from pillar to post...
bring on nth footscray
Dont usually get on here but have to laugh at the comments about Joe Scordo.
He umpired Yarra v StAlbans last week and was a disgrace. Should be umpiring u/10 football and whats worse is that he gets a final the week after. Surely the umpires need to be made accountable to someone for their poor performances. He has been terrible all year, but keeps on getting senior A grade, now B grade finals...Disgraceful.
Why does the leagu spend a little more money on the umpires, pay them more on game day so we cn attract some quality instead of the trash we get on a saturday like Scordo. I hope he reads this...
ANy other news from Div 2 as the season ends, which clubs looking to pick up and which clubs looking for new coaches... Must be some changes at the lower clubs to try to become competitive....
cougarman
Team Captain
umpires have a tough job to do each week and it is a thankless job, they can have bad days and make mistakes just like players do and we have to try to respect them as they are trying their best but scordo is an exception
he is a disgrace and shouldn't umpire at all in my opinion, i know it's a big call as we are low on umpire numbers but everyone seems to have the same opinion of this bloke
he is a disgrace and shouldn't umpire at all in my opinion, i know it's a big call as we are low on umpire numbers but everyone seems to have the same opinion of this bloke
Agree with that... very hard job and people will always have different opinions on a decision. The problem with Scordo isn't that he makes mistakes on decisions because he doesn't know the rules it's that he feels he needs to impose himself on the game.
On Sat there were 8 free kicks paid in the first 4 minutes (6 by Scordo).... Maybe 2 were reasonable. He also has a habit of making decisions when he is not the umpire in charge. I am sure we all have images in our heads of him charging in from 50 or 60 metres away blowing his whistle when the other umpire is right on the spot.
yes agree the umpires on sunday were bad both ways but the 3rd quarter free kick count was astonishing.........21 to 5.......for albanvale.......
but amazingly it was the other way around in the last 19 to 9 dissapointing yes but it got us back into the game.......and the crowd come to life which is want you want in a final............
karim what about the descision the boundry umpire made probably 5 min to go when we were realy pushing f/ward id say he was 150 mtres away a d/p player took a mark near the boundry.......obviosly got the ball moving quickily umpire hadnt called play on yet and the boundry blew his whistle and called out of bounds.......150 meters away.........that hurt......funny thing was the umpire didnt even interact with the young bloke they kept the game going..........anyway onto the brittany spears.....
but amazingly it was the other way around in the last 19 to 9 dissapointing yes but it got us back into the game.......and the crowd come to life which is want you want in a final............
karim what about the descision the boundry umpire made probably 5 min to go when we were realy pushing f/ward id say he was 150 mtres away a d/p player took a mark near the boundry.......obviosly got the ball moving quickily umpire hadnt called play on yet and the boundry blew his whistle and called out of bounds.......150 meters away.........that hurt......funny thing was the umpire didnt even interact with the young bloke they kept the game going..........anyway onto the brittany spears.....
- Banned
- #5,495
54 free kicks in a half of football? UN ****ING BELIEVABLE.
They need to stop calling everything. Let the play go. Call the obvious free kicks or the free kicks that put a player at a huge disadvantage. How the hell can they justify calling that many in half a game, let alone a whole game?
54 free kicks. WOW.
yeah i seen that weapons, what happnd was number 11 for deerpark played on but ran out of bounds b4 kicking it, theres no way the boundry umpire seen it i think he just went with the crowd...
good finals games...
cheers buddy
RedDevil and Dekkaroo... havn't heard much from you 2 after the weekends game.... any thoughts?
Heard it's season over for Alldridge? Huge loss if true
Heard it's season over for Alldridge? Huge loss if true
- Status
