Young girl allegedly insulted by St Kilda player.

[Bazzar]

From the 3AW interview it sounded like she wasn't a St Kilda supporter, she was getting a photo for her friends birthday who was a Saints supporter, but she could only recognize Nick Reiwoldt (it wasn't him who made the remarks).

She said she was a Collingwood supporter.

 

[Plugger35]

She said she was a Collingwood supporter.

That explains a lot.

 

[Ando727]

Please what ? Be dishonest ? Let them die young coz you're too afraid to tell them the truth ? Mental health my arse...teenagers get called a shitload worse than fat and dont jump for the razorblades. Everyone wants to have a social disease or blame what they have on anyone and everyhting else...and the dudley do rights claim if the world is honest they will become mentally ill.

The hypocrisy of some is amazing...disabilities or anything out of anyone's control is not something anyone can make light of...but obesity is purely self inflicted and as a taxpayer i have as much right to complain about obesity as alcholism, smoking, or any of the others you probably whine about to do with the health $.

My health taxes should be spent on disabilities, children, the handicapped and genuinely physically and mentally ill...if you are the type that screws your nose up at anyone smoking, or look down upon anyone drinking too much...about time you woke up to yourself about those who eat too much and dont burn it off.

Excuses for everything these days. Biting your fingernails now qualifies as a disease too..i should feel sorry for them too and get a support group going.

Dane Swan should be crying and blubbering about being called F A T...poor fella, nobody should be subject to that, joke or not it would be just so disgusting and we should worry he'll top himself.

Yikes! You'd be the guy people go to to be set straight on things then?

 

[Pie in the Sky]

Regardless not knowing the players names is no excuse to be trash talked to.

Agree, if true it is pretty ordinary form.

 

[saintsrule]

That's a completely different case. Why would someone make up a story where they were called fat by a footy player? Open your eyes.

There are similarities in that Hinch has beaten up an unproven story out of all proportion. Why would you humiliate yourself by going public and not just deal directly with the club? The story stinks of self promotion.

 

[Pie in the Sky]

She said she was a Collingwood supporter.

Yeah I didn't want to mention that because it opens the door for this:

That explains a lot.

 

[LT Smash]

It will be interesting to see if any StKilda player is "omitted" this week despite form.

 

[Bazzar]

That explains a lot.

The whole interview was strange, and as i said before who would call a chick who is size 8 and able to get into a size 6 fat?

 

[brendan84]

It will be interesting to see if any StKilda player is "omitted" this week despite form.

Out: Milne (Name calling)

 

[Bollox]

That's a completely different case. Why would someone make up a story where they were called fat by a footy player? Open your eyes.

Open YOUR eyes...young women make false complaints about a lot of things...for many reasons only known to them. Just because u cant imagine why, doesnt mean they dont. Thats kinda why things follow a process and get investigated before we convict them. You're judging people on things u know absolutely nothing about. Waste of time even finding out what truly happened...but some silly pricks out there will want retribution over nothing.

If your missus asks if her bum looks big in those jeans...should she ring Hinch if you're simply honest with her ? You worried about her mental health or just her mental state towards you ? Where does it stop ? Some insecure bimbo hears a Dons player joking about blondes being dumb...ring Hinch, string him up...its disgusting.

 

[Magpie Since 1986]

The whole interview was strange, and as i said before who would call a chick who is size 8 and able to get into a size 6 fat?

Probably someone who was still big enough to fight off a tip rat.

 

[Plugger35]

The whole interview was strange, and as i said before who would call a chick who is size 8 and able to get into a size 6 fat?

Like Kim Duthie's interviews, her story started to fall apart when she was grilled by people in the media and came across as the vacuous, lying, immature attention seeking mole she really is.

It was after those interviews that people finally started to wake up to the fact it was all bullshit like this story most likely is. If Hinch has his grubby mitts all over it then there is an even higher likelihood it is bullshit or at least grossly exaggerated.

 

[Hodgepodge]

Poorly handled by the club, and insulting to the fans.

The way the news item read was that a StKilda player insulted a fan's weight and they made a donation to Beyond Blue and sent the girl a guernsey. No apology, no player suspension, just a token charity gesture. Or, if the allegations are false, no contesting of the allegations.

 

[Bazzar]

Like Kim Duthie's interviews, her story started to fall apart when she was grilled by people in the media and came across as the vacuous, lying, immature attention seeking mole she really is.

It was after those interviews that people finally started to wake up to the fact it was all bullshit like this story most likely is. If Hinch has his grubby mitts all over it then there is an even higher likelihood it is bullshit or at least grossly exaggerated.

Hinch or Mitchell? Mitchell and his celebrity shrink mate Michael Carr Gregg are the biggest do-gooder wankars in Australia, I havnt heard Hinch talk about this, but it seems a bit trivial for him to even bother with.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

So what's worse calling an overweight person fat, or calling a skinny person fat.

Does it mean the door is still open for me to sue someone for racial vilification even though I dont belong to any racial minority?
"Yes your honour, I maintain that the reason the barman refused to serve me was because he thought I was black, even though I'm clearly white. The fact that I was drunk and obnoxious at the time was irrelevant "

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Poorly handled by the club, and insulting to the fans.

The way the news item read was that a StKilda player insulted a fan's weight and they made a donation to Beyond Blue and sent the girl a guernsey. No apology, no player suspension, just a token charity gesture. Or, if the allegations are false, no contesting of the allegations.

I think if you go to complaints department they receptionist hands you a t-shirt, makes a donation and writes your name down.

Did they insult her? If you saw an enourmous woman and called her skinny would it be an insult?
If no-one heard the insult or owned up should the whole class oops I mean team be suspended to make Hodge Podge happy?

 

[DTRAIN87]

I think if you go to complaints department they receptionist hands you a t-shirt, makes a donation and writes your name down.

Did they insult her? If you saw an enourmous woman and called her skinny would it be an insult?
If no-one heard the insult or owned up should the whole class oops I mean team be suspended to make Hodge Podge happy?

Ironic considering how Hawthorn handle the injunction and Tuck incidents.

 

[Magpie Since 1986]

Does it mean the door is still open for me to sue someone for racial vilification even though I dont belong to any racial minority?

So you think only racial minorities can be the subject of racism?

Guess it shows the caliber of intellect defending the Saints players' actions.

 

[Plugger35]

Hinch or Mitchell? Mitchell and his celebrity shrink mate Michael Carr Gregg are the biggest do-gooder wankars in Australia, I havnt heard Hinch talk about this, but it seems a bit trivial for him to even bother with.

Hinch has been banging on about this story in his blog, in fact he's the one that's been driving it like the Kim Duthie scandal.

In WA we have Howard Sattler who is our version of Neil Mitchell, the guy is always winding up his moron listeners into outrage over trivial scandals. One of his recent efforts was saying how disgraceful it was that George Michael will be the opening act at the new Perth Arena because of his previous drug/sex scandals and saying how you wouldn't want to let your kids go to the toilet at the concert because George Michael might be lurking in there, he was actually being serious too.

 

[Bazzar]

Hinch has been banging on about this story in his blog, in fact he's the one that's been driving it like the Kim Duthie scandal.

In WA we have Howard Sattler who is our version of Neil Mitchell, the guy is always winding up his moron listeners into outrage over trivial scandals. One of his recent efforts was saying how disgraceful it was that George Michael will be the opening act at the new Perth Arena because of his previous drug/sex scandals and saying how you wouldn't want to let your kids go to the toilet at the concert because George Michael might be lurking in there, he was actually being serious too.

I know of Sattler as I lived in Perth for year, she is a tool . I will have to tune into Hinch at 4 to see what he has to say.

 

[Hodgepodge]

If no-one heard the insult or owned up should the whole class oops I mean team be suspended to make Hodge Podge happy?

There are ways of handling it if nobody owns up or indeed if the entire team made the insults. The option of suspending players goes out, but then there is also the option of fining the players, and/or having the players apologise. And again, if there is nothing to the story, a denial of the claims.

 

[blueboy25]

It

There are ways of handling it if nobody owns up or indeed if the entire team made the insults. The option of suspending players goes out, but then there is also the option of fining the players, and/or having the players apologise. And again, if there is nothing to the story, a denial of the claims.

Chris Judd did it

 

[Hodgepodge]

Ironic considering how Hawthorn handle the injunction and Tuck incidents.

There is no injunction incident, since taking out an injunction is not an offence. If you're referring to the rehab involvement of two Hawthorn players, then I would've thought they handled it quite well, since it was done in a manner fully and strongly endorsed by the AFL CEO.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

So you think only racial minorities can be the subject of racism?

Guess it shows the caliber of intellect defending the Saints players' actions.

Wow sorry for generalising in a flippant comment in a forum about football. Lets be pedantic twatts. Lets all go off topic and discuss apartheit South Africa.
What does your assumption that my one comment would define posters defending Saints player's actions say about your intellect?
In fact, the post you are refferring to is not defending anyone mr intellectual gigant.
I dont even know who do defend?
I only have some hearsay which seems to be different on each media report.

Now tell me this Mr Smartarse moralist. Assuming it is totally unacceptable to refer to even a size 8 girl as a "fat chick", please tell me why it is not unacceptable to refer to a person, who does not frequent garbage waste disposal facilites, and bears only a passing resemblance to a rodent as a "tip rat".

Take your bullshit trolling moral standards and shove it you two faced moron.

 

[NSWCROW]

Player insults fat girl
Fat Girl slaps player

problem solvered