- Mar 1, 2005
- 7,740
- 15,716
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- carlton
There is no harm in having him there for the experience and a place holder, its up to the young bucks to bust the door down and demand a game.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Prediction Your 2020 Best 22 (Post Trade Period)
- Thread starter V_23
- Start date
- Tagged users None
There is no harm in having him there for the experience and a place holder, its up to the young bucks to bust the door down and demand a game.
- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,667
- 13,094
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Yep I didn’t care if we got him or not and actually didn’t really want him but the guy was in the AA squad as a third year player. How many player do we have who look/looked capable of that? It’s a matter of will our kids develop or are we just being typical supporters living in abit of hope? I’m happy to back this group in but I can see the reasoning for a proven player. I would also love to know how much a player like Marchbank has been on for the four years he has been at the club. I would bet my bottom dollar Ellis would be better value.
I AM CARLTON
Club Legend
- Mar 9, 2014
- 1,802
- 2,459
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Ok here is my best 22 with everyone fit
Docherty Jones Plowman
SPS Weitering Williamson
O'Brien Setterfield Walsh
Kruezer Cripps Murphy
Fisher Curnow Martin
Betts McKay TDK
Stocker Curnow JSOS Simpson
A few coments:
1. Plowman plays the lockdown defender role.
2. Couldnt pick both Plowman and Marchbank in back 6 it makes us too slow and i really wanted Docherty, SPS & Willo back there.
3. SPS and Williamson to provide the run off half back.
4. Setterfield to play in the guts not on a wing and use his size to help Crippa.
5. Picked TDK before Mcgov and Casboult tough call but he might have more upside and I'm not sure if McGov is best 22 if eveyone fit.
Docherty Jones Plowman
SPS Weitering Williamson
O'Brien Setterfield Walsh
Kruezer Cripps Murphy
Fisher Curnow Martin
Betts McKay TDK
Stocker Curnow JSOS Simpson
A few coments:
1. Plowman plays the lockdown defender role.
2. Couldnt pick both Plowman and Marchbank in back 6 it makes us too slow and i really wanted Docherty, SPS & Willo back there.
3. SPS and Williamson to provide the run off half back.
4. Setterfield to play in the guts not on a wing and use his size to help Crippa.
5. Picked TDK before Mcgov and Casboult tough call but he might have more upside and I'm not sure if McGov is best 22 if eveyone fit.
Team to run out whenever we go out on the park next.
Injuries to CC, MK, Newman (? maybe back from the elbow).
Philp & Newnes in the fray as well. Maybe a few surprise with their condition on return as a smokey selection.
Injuries to CC, MK, Newman (? maybe back from the elbow).
Philp & Newnes in the fray as well. Maybe a few surprise with their condition on return as a smokey selection.
Made sense before you put TDK ahead of Cas and McGov
Looking at our best team for round 2 now.
From round 1: injuries - Kruez & Fish (borderline). Form - Gibbons, Dow, Setterfield had no impact.
INS
Pittonet, McKay & Eddie definitely if fit. Kennedy, O’Brien, Willo, Stocker, TDK pressing hard.
OUTS
Kruez is the only definite. Fisher borderline re injury.
Dow, Setterfield, Gibbons, JSOS (could be left out for McKay re team balance) are shaky.
Our forward line suddenly looks a lot more balanced and potent.
Betts McKay Cuningham
Marin Casboult McGovern
From round 1: injuries - Kruez & Fish (borderline). Form - Gibbons, Dow, Setterfield had no impact.
INS
Pittonet, McKay & Eddie definitely if fit. Kennedy, O’Brien, Willo, Stocker, TDK pressing hard.
OUTS
Kruez is the only definite. Fisher borderline re injury.
Dow, Setterfield, Gibbons, JSOS (could be left out for McKay re team balance) are shaky.
Our forward line suddenly looks a lot more balanced and potent.
Betts McKay Cuningham
Marin Casboult McGovern
Simpson Jones Plowman
Williamson Weitering Docherty
Samo Crippa Walsh
Martin M McGov Cuningham
Jack Silv McKay Betts
Pittonet Crippa Murphy
Bench: E Curnow, Casboult (2nd ruck and tall utility either end). Setterfield, Gibbons
Emergencies: Newman, Dow, O'Brien, TDK
Injured: Kruezer (LTI), C Curnow (LTI), Kemp (LTI), Fisher (close to return), Marchbank
Stocker and Kennedy play when next needed.
Williamson Weitering Docherty
Samo Crippa Walsh
Martin M McGov Cuningham
Jack Silv McKay Betts
Pittonet Crippa Murphy
Bench: E Curnow, Casboult (2nd ruck and tall utility either end). Setterfield, Gibbons
Emergencies: Newman, Dow, O'Brien, TDK
Injured: Kruezer (LTI), C Curnow (LTI), Kemp (LTI), Fisher (close to return), Marchbank
Stocker and Kennedy play when next needed.
ha ha..oh shit
Cloned Crippa out and Dow in. Stocker to emergency
If games are shorter this season does this change best 22s? Would have to take the importance of endurance off a bit and promote impact players a bit more. Would also IMO open the door for some younger players a bit more, that ability to run out games, well if games are shorter then perhaps some of them can now. I'm thinking that Philp, Honey, TDK, Stocker are bigger chances now. Particularly if it's pace and skills we want to bring into the team. Perhaps those senior players who may not have the pace and skills but are getting games because they have bigger tanks are less important. Hard to say at this stage but I'd gladly see us push a few quicker and better skilled players into the team.
Think I would be inclined to go more pace, better skills and some players who can be impact players. A few who can have short bursts in the middle but play elsewhere and have a quick impact. Reckon we might see some players selected who may not have previously.
Think I would be inclined to go more pace, better skills and some players who can be impact players. A few who can have short bursts in the middle but play elsewhere and have a quick impact. Reckon we might see some players selected who may not have previously.
- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,667
- 13,094
- AFL Club
- Carlton
It’ll be interesting but I think the lack of “tank” probably has just as much to do with repeated sprinting efforts and end to end running then it does running out games. Someone like Stocker will still get exposed with that in the midfield. Probably depends on the roles abit imo but I imagine impact players become more important at probably the expense of versatility as there could be less opportunities for some players because better players can play a higher % of game time in there best position. Someone like Setterfield and Fisher we may have needed to play 20min of midfield time might now only be needed for 5-6minutes.
- Jun 6, 2012
- 10,024
- 17,815
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Rampage
Casboult should ruck. We can't play him, McKay & McGovern in the one forward line - we were already too easy to rebound against in the Richmond game.
He's such a multi-faceted player now; his work around the ground would more than make up for not being a great tap ruck.
He's such a multi-faceted player now; his work around the ground would more than make up for not being a great tap ruck.
Of course we can
Going to be interesting as it seems our team has around 26 best 22 players now...when all fit.
brackets (are the expected replacements for older players)
Murphy Simpson Betts Casboult Kreuzer Curnow Jones
FB: Docherty Jones (BSOS) Simpson (Williamson)
HB: Plowman Weitering SPS
C: Murphy (LOB), Cripps, Curnow (Dow)
R: Kreuzer (Pittonet), Walsh, Cuningham
HF: Martin Charlie McGovern
FF: McKay Casboult (TDK) Betts (Papley/Honey)
Int: Setterfield Gibbons Fisher Stocker
Depth: Marchbank Kennedy Newman Newnes
Youth: Philp Kemp
brackets (are the expected replacements for older players)
Murphy Simpson Betts Casboult Kreuzer Curnow Jones
FB: Docherty Jones (BSOS) Simpson (Williamson)
HB: Plowman Weitering SPS
C: Murphy (LOB), Cripps, Curnow (Dow)
R: Kreuzer (Pittonet), Walsh, Cuningham
HF: Martin Charlie McGovern
FF: McKay Casboult (TDK) Betts (Papley/Honey)
Int: Setterfield Gibbons Fisher Stocker
Depth: Marchbank Kennedy Newman Newnes
Youth: Philp Kemp
Here you go Harks
I too had the likes of LOB ahead of Newnes, ultimately it means nothing, if the side is progressing short term
We all knew that Teague would hand back responsibility short term to senior players/bodies, the masses were calling for it
Have always stated the transition would be crucial, from senior players like Murphy, MK, Ed, to foot soldiers like Gibbons and Newnes
Now our younger players have an opportunity to dislodge these guys, naturally.
I look forward to that transition
There isn't one point there I have any reason to contest with any conviction, as it's all perfectly sound.
I don't know what to say, other than it had little to do with the point I put forward
Even in these four short weeks to date we've seen from the older/MOR guys -
1. Newman out for injury unfortunately. Don't think we've lost much with Williamsons involvement just yet.
2. Murphy has been extracted out of the midfield and we've won our past two games, having a more aggressive midfield.
3. Kreuzer has gone down, but Pittonet has done nothing but to heighten his profile.
It's a somewhat natural course that this will continue to be the case, for the talent we still have parked away.
Newnes was more of a stop-gap rather than a window to the future.
ECurnow by years end won't be involved in 90% of stoppages as he has been in the first four weeks.
Simpson is in his last year, surely etc.
This is the ideal year to consolidate what our best team may be going forward and add to the squad where deficiencies exist.
There isn't one point there I have any reason to contest with any conviction, as it's all perfectly sound.
I don't know what to say, other than it had little to do with the point I put forward
Even in these four short weeks to date we've seen from the older/MOR guys -
1. Newman out for injury unfortunately. Don't think we've lost much with Williamsons involvement just yet.
2. Murphy has been extracted out of the midfield and we've won our past two games, having a more aggressive midfield.
3. Kreuzer has gone down, but Pittonet has done nothing but to heighten his profile.
It's a somewhat natural course that this will continue to be the case, for the talent we still have parked away.
Newnes was more of a stop-gap rather than a window to the future.
ECurnow by years end won't be involved in 90% of stoppages as he has been in the first four weeks.
Simpson is in his last year, surely etc.
This is the ideal year to consolidate what our best team may be going forward and add to the squad where deficiencies exist.
That's still all perception, wants, desires, nothing to do with how it will definitely play out
I doubt there are many on this site that has promoted playing our youth ahead of senior players if output was similar than I have over the last 4 years
Current wins are wonderful, especially for attracting players, but I am more interested about continiuty first, natural development and depth
Not too long ago, everyone had Levi gone, sacked, traded, not best 22
I wouldn't be putting a line through the likes of Ed just yet
I AM CARLTON
Club Legend
- Mar 9, 2014
- 1,802
- 2,459
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Can't see how Plowman and Marchbank can play in the same team.
Weiters and Jones are locks so playing both Plowman and Marchbank would make us too slow and tall down back.
Weiters and Jones are locks so playing both Plowman and Marchbank would make us too slow and tall down back.
They're very different players. Can easily fit those 4 in our back 7.
I AM CARLTON
Club Legend
- Mar 9, 2014
- 1,802
- 2,459
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Nah not for me would prefer Docherty, Simpson, SPS and Willo before having both Plowman and Marchbank in the same team.
Move one of Simmo, Willo or Samo up the field.
- Aug 16, 2015
- 12,276
- 21,248
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Arsenal
I get quite excited when I look at our spine and what/who I see as long term/future premiership players. I still have plenty of holes and reservations about some and I think by the end I’d the year I’ll be adding another one or two from within and hopefully one from another club.
FB: ?.?????? Jones ?.??????
CHB: Williamson Weitering Docherty
C: Walsh Cripps. ?.??????
CHF: ?.????? Mckay Martin
FF: ?.????? Charlie. ?.?????
Int: CAS
I have Williamson there and Jones, although I can see Jones only being there 2-3 years, which I see as enough to get a premiership and Willo despite not playing much and being out for a long time, I can see many positives that I can’t yet see in a lot of the others.
FB: ?.?????? Jones ?.??????
CHB: Williamson Weitering Docherty
C: Walsh Cripps. ?.??????
CHF: ?.????? Mckay Martin
FF: ?.????? Charlie. ?.?????
Int: CAS
I have Williamson there and Jones, although I can see Jones only being there 2-3 years, which I see as enough to get a premiership and Willo despite not playing much and being out for a long time, I can see many positives that I can’t yet see in a lot of the others.
Right now and moving forward, we are thin in quality KPD stocks. Luckily it shouldn't be too hard to rectify
Prediction - Your 2020 Best 22 (Post Trade Period)
With all of the uncertainty and discussion around what will be our Best 22 come Round 1, perhaps we need to rethink and re-frame the discussion. Rather than a Consensus 22... perhaps we need to separate our list into 3 groups. 1. Consensus Best 18 players - based on CJMB and his outstanding...
www.bigfooty.com
