Prediction Your 2020 Best 22 (Post Trade Period)

[spry]

This idiot is gonna have a go at how we line up round 1

Plowman - Jones - Simpson

Doc - weitering - Newman

Newnes - Cripps - Walsh

Kruezer - setterfield - Murphy

Fisher - McKay - Martin

Betts - Kennedy - CAZ


Cunningham - SPS - GOV - ED

UNLUCKY:

Gibbo: outshone by Martin and fisher imo
Marchy: first in if injuries down back. Or could replace Newnes.
Jsos: could replace ED on bench if Mids are humming without him.
WILLO: Newman wins on exposed form.

Dow/O’Brien et al to get killer instinct at northern.

Alright guys who’d I miss?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[F_therest]

Best 22 all fit ...

Simpson. Jones. Plowman.
Docherty. Weitering. SPS.
Walsh. Ed Curnow. Setterfield.
Martin. Charlie Curnow. Cuningham.
Betts. McKay. McGovern.
R. Kreuzer. Cripps. Murphy.
I. Marchbank. Fisher. Gibbons. Casboult.

next few: JSOS. O’Brien. Williamson. Newman. Dow. Stocker. Newnes. Gibbons. TDK.

Geez this really highlights our depth going into 2020 doesn't it...thank you SOS.
And under 'next few' you'd have to have Kennedy in there as well - although you have Gibbons listed here but also in the best 22

Ruck depth: TDK & Pittonet - A little unproven at AFL level but looks decent for the future.
Forward depth: JSOS & Kennedy. A lot of pre-season reports have Honey impressing.
Midfield depth: LOB & Dow. A few other high draft pick midfielders building and can call upon in a few years.
Defence depth: Willo/Newman/Newnes/Stocker. Suddenly we are well stocked for smaller running defenders. Macreadie & Goddard not the best looking KPP depth, but we already have 4 in the team so could just go with one less if any got injured and can always swing Casboult back.

List is is good shape.

 

[Tim H]

 

[Pablito]

View attachment 823947

Close to mine, I'd just switch out LOB for Newman and promote Setters to the wing.

 

[LemmingMaster]

But you think Gibbons is?

I think he looks more natural in the midfield, so that is why he is ahead of Cunners.

Not like Gibbons and Cunners are locked top 22 players, so splitting hairs with such a player is up to perception.

 

[LemmingMaster]

Let’s agree to disagree.

Gibbons is not a natural forward, so it’s about whether we play another small forward or rotate midfielders through a forward pocket.

Cunningham is not a natural forward as well, so not sure you're making a point of difference?

I would back Gibbons in the midfield rotations over Cunningham at their current development.

 

[JuddgementDay]

This idiot is gonna have a go at how we line up round 1

Plowman - Jones - Simpson

Doc - weitering - Newman

Newnes - Cripps - Walsh

Kruezer - setterfield - Murphy

Fisher - McKay - Martin

Betts - Kennedy - CAZ


Cunningham - SPS - GOV - ED

UNLUCKY:

Gibbo: outshone by Martin and fisher imo
Marchy: first in if injuries down back. Or could replace Newnes.
Jsos: could replace ED on bench if Mids are humming without him.
WILLO: Newman wins on exposed form.

Dow/O’Brien et al to get killer instinct at northern.

Alright guys who’d I miss?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I really think this is very close to our starting 22, but I would like to make some tweaks:

Plowman - Jones - Simpson

Doc - weitering - Willo

Newnes - Cripps - Walsh

Kruezer - setterfield - Murphy

Fisher - McKay - Martin

Betts - Kennedy - GOV


Cunningham - SPS - JSOS- ED

UNLUCKY:
CAZ - team is too top heavy with all of McKay,Gov & CAZ
Newman: Willo just seems he is really ready to break out; so Newman has to fight with Willo & Simpson

The rest, I agree with you

 

[Carlton1234]

This idiot is gonna have a go at how we line up round 1

Plowman - Jones - Simpson

Doc - weitering - Newman

Newnes - Cripps - Walsh

Kruezer - setterfield - Murphy

Fisher - McKay - Martin

Betts - Kennedy - CAZ


Cunningham - SPS - GOV - ED

UNLUCKY:

Gibbo: outshone by Martin and fisher imo
Marchy: first in if injuries down back. Or could replace Newnes.
Jsos: could replace ED on bench if Mids are humming without him.
WILLO: Newman wins on exposed form.

Dow/O’Brien et al to get killer instinct at northern.

Alright guys who’d I miss?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I would have JSOS, Gibbo or Marchy(depending fitness) ahead of Cunners for round 1

 

[spry]

I really think this is very close to our starting 22, but I would like to make some tweaks:

Plowman - Jones - Simpson

Doc - weitering - Willo

Newnes - Cripps - Walsh

Kruezer - setterfield - Murphy

Fisher - McKay - Martin

Betts - Kennedy - GOV


Cunningham - SPS - JSOS- ED

UNLUCKY:
CAZ - team is too top heavy with all of McKay,Gov & CAZ
Newman: Willo just seems he is really ready to break out; so Newman has to fight with Willo & Simpson

The rest, I agree with you

can’t wait for pre season games for everyone to prove their case!

My concern for removing CAS would be that we’d be too small if Harry was to do the relief rucking.

But I would like to see Kennedy and jsos play together


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[F_therest]

I really think this is very close to our starting 22, but I would like to make some tweaks:

Plowman - Jones - Simpson

Doc - weitering - Willo

Newnes - Cripps - Walsh

Kruezer - setterfield - Murphy

Fisher - McKay - Martin

Betts - Kennedy - GOV


Cunningham - SPS - JSOS- ED

UNLUCKY:
CAZ - team is too top heavy with all of McKay,Gov & CAZ
Newman: Willo just seems he is really ready to break out; so Newman has to fight with Willo & Simpson

The rest, I agree with you

Casboult is most certainly in our best 22. Especially with Curnow out.

Gov/McKay/Cas can easily play together...they did last year.

 

[Arr0w]

Not enough love for Levi

Last year could lay a claim to being our best/most durable defender or forward

 

[Stamos]

Not enough love for Levi

Last year could lay a claim to being our best/most durable defender or forward

I think he would just get squeezed out of our best 22, and be first emergency for our talls.

But to suggest he won't be playing when Charlie is a good chance to miss the first half of the season is just silly.

 

[Arr0w]

I think he would just get squeezed out of our best 22, and be first emergency for our talls.

But to suggest he won't be playing when Charlie is a good chance to miss the first half of the season is just silly.

I think Levi is there until TDK is ready. Unless Krooz is out, then it changes again

 

[Stamos]

I think Levi is there until TDK is ready. Unless Krooz is out, then it changes again

It's possible, for sure.
I think having him in with Charlie, Harry and Gov makes for a tall forward 7.

 

[JuddgementDay]

can’t wait for pre season games for everyone to prove their case!

My concern for removing CAS would be that we’d be too small if Harry was to do the relief rucking.

But I would like to see Kennedy and jsos play together


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Was that with or without any of these?
Kruezer, Jones & weitering ?

 

[Arr0w]

It's possible, for sure.
I think having him in with Charlie, Harry and Gov makes for a tall forward 7.

Could do, but I see it as dangerous setup if we can win/break even with inside 50 counts

Apart from Levi(who has improved) all the others have some toe for their size. In fact, I would say all of Mitch, Charlie and Harry have got more toe than Jack and Kennedy

 

[Stamos]

Could do, but I see it as dangerous setup if we can win/break even with inside 50 counts

Apart from Levi(who has improved) all the others have some toe for their size. In fact, I would say all of Mitch, Charlie and Harry have got more toe than Jack and Kennedy

Just get them all fit.
We're going to be ****ing lethal.

 

[spry]

Was that with or without any of these?
Kruezer, Jones & weitering ?

Was referring to the forwards. If kruezer is on the bench with your lineup and Harry is in the ruck. You’d have Gov and Kennedy and SOS up forward
That’s too small imo


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[JuddgementDay]

Was referring to the forwards. If kruezer is on the bench with your lineup and Harry is in the ruck. You’d have Gov and Kennedy and SOS up forward
That’s too small imo


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Ooops - sorry, I was supposed to respond to this post below. But, pretty much the same sentiments.
When Harry is in the ruck, it's probably a good thing to allow our fwd line a bit of a mix up anyway.

Casboult is most certainly in our best 22. Especially with Curnow out.

Gov/McKay/Cas can easily play together...they did last year.

 

[Blugazi]

Rd 1

B: Lachie Plowman, Liam Jones, Nic Newman
HB: Kade Simpson, Jacob Weitering, Sam Docherty
C: Will Setterfield, Patrick Cripps, Sam Walsh
HF: Jack Martin, Harry McKay, Zac Fisher
F: Mitch McGovern, Levi Casboult, Eddie Betts
Foll: Matthew Kreuzer, David Cuningham, Marc Murphy
I/C: Ed Curnow, Sam Petrevski-Seton, Michael Gibbons, Jack Silvagni

Inj: C.Curnow

Marchbank to come back through the reserves.

 

[iAsbestos]

FB: Simpson Jones Plowman
HB: Newman Weitering Docherty
C: SPS Cripps Walsh
HF: Cunningham Casboult Martin
FF: Betts Mckay Mcgovern
R: Kruezer Murphy E.Curnow
IC: Fisher Setterfield Newnes Marchbank

 

[Kernafides]

Not enough love for Levi

Last year could lay a claim to being our best/most durable defender or forward

Couldn't agree more...cant think of another player in the league who can play forward, defence and in the ruck

 

[Arr0w]

Couldn't agree more...cant think of another player in the league who can play forward, defence and in the ruck

That's a fair point, off the top of my head maybe a Carlisle, Hipwood in juniors showed he can play back as well, Blicavs, maybe Balta may come through too

Although none have his marking consistency

 

[Eiffel 65]

I would have JSOS, Gibbo or Marchy(depending fitness) ahead of Cunners for round 1

Might have been the case in the past, but I think Cunners will move past at least two of those guys.

Cuningham is a watch this space player. Could well be our most improved in 2020.

 

[blue_trinity]

That's a fair point, off the top of my head maybe a Carlisle, Hipwood in juniors showed he can play back as well, Blicavs, maybe Balta may come through too

Although none have his marking consistency

Westhoff. Maybe even Roughead