😲 Umpire appointments & discussion - Rounds 0, 1,2 and beyond
- Thread starter beema limapep
- Start date
- Tagged users None
sante
Emu
What happens if we win the free kick count today?
Groupie_
time to return the traditional Richmond yellow
- Oct 29, 2017
- 22,347
- 43,853
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Thread starter
- #80
- Dec 8, 2003
- 5,984
- 8,741
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- May 10, 2017
- 642
- 2,494
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- May 1, 2011
- 722
- 1,955
- AFL Club
- Richmond
As predicted. Two BS free kicks right in front of goal for GC in the last quarter to kill our momentum. The umps aren’t even trying to disguise their bias against us these days. Hilarious if it wasn’t so frustrating
- Nov 28, 2017
- 5,782
- 11,815
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Tasmania Devils
Didn't want to buy into the umpires talk another year but wow... clearly umpires have a perception about our players... and how the hell was Broad not under pressure Suns player inside the square a free kick?
Last edited:
our first half was an abomination but when we had the momentum and were closing in, o'gorman and co were there to deny our threat with cheat frees
it's the same movie every time
it's the same movie every time
- Nov 26, 2013
- 13,897
- 24,892
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Man U, Chicago Bulls, Anaheim Ducks
Several obvious calls missed
Grimes being tackled to the ground while the suns player ran into goals was clear the rort was on
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Grimes being tackled to the ground while the suns player ran into goals was clear the rort was on
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
If they are going to pay them it’s going to be against us. It’s almost an umpire culture thing by now.
- Oct 3, 2012
- 13,000
- 25,328
- AFL Club
- Richmond
In the NBA they've brought in frees against flopping. In the AFL you get a 50m penalty and a goal
20 reamed us harder than 10 and that is saying something.
smasha
It's Time!
Dimma got an 8 course meal today.
Happy Meal at Tigerland.
Happy Meal at Tigerland.
- Jul 15, 2014
- 23,260
- 45,177
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, LA Lakers, Western United
This is going to be a bit of a rant.
I agree that we get a hard run from the umpires, but I’m officially sick of blaming them. It’s time our players copped heat for the stupid things they do.
We all know that what Broad did is against the rules. He was under no pressure to cross the line and he did. The lack of pressure was evident to even me sitting at home, so what about the ump standing there? He did that fully relying on the umps not calling him out for it, and they didn’t look past it. Grimes’ contact with the Gold Coast player was even worse. Those two decisions killed our comeback.
We do stupid crap like this all the time. Yes, we seem to get held to the rules unlike some sides, but you’d have expected the players to take better care by now. But nope, they still nonchalantly break the rules and get shocked when the umps call them out for it. The worst part is that they barely even attempt to hide their infringements from the umps, which is probably why they get pinged more than other teams. Players from other sides at least try to obscure it from the umps.
This is the 8th season of this crap and I am sick of it. Bloody play to the rules or at least try to hide you breaking them. Don’t display it for all to see and then whinge to the ump.
The players simply need to learn the rules and abide by it more. Rant over.
I agree that we get a hard run from the umpires, but I’m officially sick of blaming them. It’s time our players copped heat for the stupid things they do.
We all know that what Broad did is against the rules. He was under no pressure to cross the line and he did. The lack of pressure was evident to even me sitting at home, so what about the ump standing there? He did that fully relying on the umps not calling him out for it, and they didn’t look past it. Grimes’ contact with the Gold Coast player was even worse. Those two decisions killed our comeback.
We do stupid crap like this all the time. Yes, we seem to get held to the rules unlike some sides, but you’d have expected the players to take better care by now. But nope, they still nonchalantly break the rules and get shocked when the umps call them out for it. The worst part is that they barely even attempt to hide their infringements from the umps, which is probably why they get pinged more than other teams. Players from other sides at least try to obscure it from the umps.
This is the 8th season of this crap and I am sick of it. Bloody play to the rules or at least try to hide you breaking them. Don’t display it for all to see and then whinge to the ump.
The players simply need to learn the rules and abide by it more. Rant over.
- May 1, 2011
- 722
- 1,955
- AFL Club
- Richmond
“Stand, stand, stand”. Different rules apply to the Pies than us
The umpiring overall was good. If a GC player did what Broad did we'd all be screaming for deliberate. The Grimes one was a flop but dumb and poor leadership by Grimes to shove him. Has no one else to blame.
Hoppers free innfront of goal was a cheapy so a bit of a square up there.
The non call against Grimes early when he was tackles off the ball for a GC goal was a howler though.
Hoppers free innfront of goal was a cheapy so a bit of a square up there.
The non call against Grimes early when he was tackles off the ball for a GC goal was a howler though.
This is why your post is straight up ****ing rubbish. Its not up to our players to disguise what we do better, its up to the umpires to be consistent and not pick and chose to influence games when they please which is exactly what they did in the Grimes and Broad incidents.
The contact Grimes placed on the GC player was no different to the shove he received when he took the mark. The only difference was the umpire decided to penalise one action and allow the other. While under the rules what Broad did was perfectly fine and 9 times out of 10 the umpire wont penalise.
- Jul 15, 2014
- 23,260
- 45,177
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, LA Lakers, Western United
No, what Broad did under the rules was not fine. Broad’s actions can be classified as a deliberate rushed behind, and that is a free kick to the opposition if he was not under pressure when doing so. It is something that umpires don’t enforce most of the time, but I’ve seen them enforce it from time to time. I watched Broad do it, and I agree with the ump that Broad was not under pressure when he crossed the line. So, the free is technically there even though opposition players get away with it most of the time.
My point is that this is the 8th year of this crap. Our players (especially the veterans) should know the rules better than anyone in the league given how strictly we’ve been adjudicated in the past. That’s why I no longer care when we get pinged for something that the opposition got away with. They simply should know better, even in situations where the infringements happen consecutively on the field like what happened with Grimes and his opponent. To me, I see that as complaining about a cop deciding to pull someone over for crossing a yellow traffic light with enough time to stop and letting go the one next to them that did the exact same thing. By the rule they should’ve pulled both over, but at the end of the day, it’s up to the person not to cross a yellow light with enough time to stop in the first place. Otherwise, they’d be relying on the cop to not fine them for it.
Do I wish the umpires held every club to the same standard of adjudication? Yes. It is clear that we get held to a higher standard than many other clubs. Do I want the AFL to address it? Yes. But after 7 years of the same shit, you’d expect our players to understand how we’ll get adjudicated in the 8th year. Especially veterans like Grimes and Broad. So why are players like them still doing whatever they feel like and relying on the ump not to call them out when they infringe the rules? What of the last 7 years made them think that they could get away with it? Because it clearly seems like they expected different when I see their shocked facial expressions.
So I don’t care anymore about how the umps adjudicate. It’s not going to change anytime soon from what I’ve seen, so we need to adjust and follow the bloody rules instead. Winning the match is more important, and we no longer have the talent to survive unnecessary free kick against in crucial moments. It’s time our lack of discipline gets focused on. It’s not a popular viewpoint on this board, but more people need to realise how careless some of our players are on the field. They need to stop this.
Similar threads
- Locked
