I've had thought a fair bit about Schache, orginally I liked the idea as long as the next year first year pick wasn't on the table. Now I'm all for it, first round pick or not.
Talls take time, Without a tall any team will struggle to build a relevant team. But more importantly by getting...
For me he looks too big these days, looks one paced and appears to have low mobility.
I remember leading into the finals at the end of his second year Lennon was looking the GOODs he got dropped for the final (didn't deserve to be) anyway he played far more up the ground and looked extremely...
One year on and I'm still as confused as ever about this trade!
a) Id love to hear a clarification message from the hawks - Won't happen
b) Receive something additional this year from STK - Very unlikely
c) remain confused - very likely
If Hartung is a chance to leave, who would be circling? I'd think Brisbane with the Hodge and Fagan link would suit nicely.
If that's the case I'd love to see him incorporated in a deal for Schache. Potentially Hartung, Hodge (just to get him up there) and 32 for Schache. Feels a touch unders...
I'd like to throw Ben Lennons name out there. Clearly it would only be if a list spot was open but he is on the outta at that club and with Sicilys backline form I think we are in need of a HFF. Could do worse and won't cost much.
Great list!! Will also be happy with one or two of these!
I personally wouldn't be against adding some more X factor also! lebois is the one I'm hoping for!
Clearly this is an impossible task but I think pick 88 would simply be best put to a player with X factor but a deficiency or maybe a mid that could become a solid B grader that has slipped because of class but they are very hard to predict!
My picks are:
Tyson Stengle - Tiny but X factor
Kym...
SPP - In the 30s - I'm feeling that mature body slider like a Luke Tapscott back in the day.
English - late teens early 20s - lack of desire to use high end picks especially if GC don't want him (grundy style)
Battle - late 20s early 30s - slightly undersized (Gardiner /Culter)
Would froff this pick up! Imagine this guy in a fwd line with some decent supply, could work well. It would also allow the other 3 to spend greater time in the midfield, plus Joshy wasn't the worst mid going around back in his tassie days, so he could add some depth! If we miss out on Barrett I...
Could he be the (3rd rd + Player) that has been thrown around for Mitchell??? I know we had 31 two years back and was shattered we didn't get Tom (who went 32 from memory). His sub par kicking isn't a trait we rated which makes me question why we would want him now, however I think he fits the...
On JOM and TMitchell do we know if they were/are mates at all? They played for WA together in 2011, they would been a year level apart but it would be great if these boys are mates coming in together, does anyone know???
Would I change it - no, as would I not change recruiting Dew over Zaraharkis as we won flags in the subsequent year (although Dews GF impact over the next best was material compared to BB over Cegs). My post was focusing on that fact that Hale/Cegs/a Young Longer could of done the job in 14,15...
All this BB talk has got me thinking and the trade for the big fella in 2013 is shaping up being a real loss for 2 reasons.
1. We missed Out on Billy Longer because we went for BB late instead of holding firm for longer, a bloke with atleast 8years in him and ready to launch (after a inj year...
Been used at both ends of the ground in his 3 years and is likely to push through the midfield in the near future, has that Hawks Flexibility about him already ;)
Bonner , don't mind your thinking (the ideal next Birch replacement)
I don't think you need to execute one trade to meet all your needs, you have to play with the other teams supply and meet your needs through other trades. In saying that as you pointed out they have Lobbe and we are needing a ruck, not the player I would want as his just got that big boy look...
Good on him if he was to get that deal and if I was him I'd want out on something like that, that's the contract size and length he would be after!
For Hawks it also means port rate him and we could seriously bite off something on the trade table.
I would be looking at Jarman Impey, but no...
What do you think his contract would be worth on the open market??? I think on your merit he would be able to get close to base 200k max $400k (levered with huge game incentives).
Would be interesting to find out Nathan Browns options from North because I would take Brand over him in a...
Other than the fact this was posted at 4am I think this is a real good trade, the minor edits I would make are removing the 26 and 39 element of the Barlow trade and maybe sneaking in a small pick upgrade to GC in the second part (could be achieved by giving our second round and getting GCs 3rd...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.