12 months down the track: Simmonds for Fiora

[Bentleigh]

We did very well.

 

[heartbroken]

by the end of the season, Simmonds showed that as a mobile ruckman, he is a very handy player. Gets lots of poessions and can hold his own in the Ruck. As for Fiora, he continued to show why he could quite possibly be classified as the worst pick 3 of all time.

 

[CoggaRules]

by the end of the season, Simmonds showed that as a mobile ruckman, he is a very handy player. Gets lots of poessions and can hold his own in the Ruck. As for Fiora, he continued to show why he could quite possibly be classified as the worst pick 3 of all time.

yes, its pretty unbelievable isnt it? like wtf were they thinking back then.

 

[Bentleigh]

yes, its pretty unbelievable isnt it? like wtf were they thinking back then.

That Pavlich wasn't worth pick 3 is seems.

 

[CoggaRules]

That Pavlich wasn't worth pick 3 is seems.

moreso, how could they get it so wrong, like it aint that they got it a little wrong, sort of got a servicable player out of it, and missed on a star, they got a dud and missed out on a star.

 

[sante]

That Pavlich wasn't worth pick 3 is seems.

Don't bring it up anymore

 

[TheTigersReallyGreat]

Simmonds wasn't that impressive this year, Fiora was worse (even though he got to play in a prelim)
Pavlich was sensational. Oh well, you win some, you lose some.

 

[FLEMO]

DIM SIM is awsum hes one of the shortest ruckman and he was still get over 10-15 hitouts a week and kicking 1 or 2 goals around he also kicked alot of points aswell

 

[French Tiger]

DIM SIM is awsum hes one of the shortest ruckman and he was still get over 10-15 hitouts a week and kicking 1 or 2 goals around he also kicked alot of points aswell

Exactly,If he had kicked straight he could have kicked around 30-35 goals

 

[tigerT]

once they get a pre-season of endurance into him to compliment his running style in the ruck, he will be even better. Until the last 5-6 rounds he was at best serviceable, the last 5-6 games when he took over the number ruck possie, he was dynamite

 

[Bentleigh]

Troy Simmonds.

* Impressive ruckman
* Handy forward flanker/3rd tall forward
* Not a CHF arseh*le.

 

[tigerT]

who said he was a CHF?

who u calling arseh*le spanker?

 

[Bentleigh]

who said he was a CHF?

who u calling arseh*le spanker?

Simmonds has been played as a CHF this year, at times.

Very average when he is asked to play that role.

 

[tigerT]

Simmonds has been played as a CHF this year, at times.

Very average when he is asked to play that role.

eh? and R.Hall isnt a ruckman but was asked to play there a few seasons back... whats ur point?


I asked who actually said simmo was a CHF? we know hes no CHF but when he did play there he was average, fact.

and who are u calling an arseh*le?

 

[Bentleigh]

and who are u calling an arseh*le?

I wasnt calling anyone an arseh*le. Its mearly an expression my friend.

Simmonds clearly isnt a key forward.

 

[Mystery]

Yeah we have done well but at the start of the season I was a little worried because Fiora had strated to show some form in the Wizard Cup. Now I think we have done better has he is a very good mobile ruckman that can go forward and kick some goals. He can also play at CHB.

 

[CoggaRules]

Simmonds has been played as a CHF this year, at times.

Very average when he is asked to play that role.

very average he was, but he is a big unit that needs a big unit to play on him when at CHF. He aint that scrappywhen it comes to recovery as well, he doesnt go to ground to many times.

 

[TigerFan]

really, was there ever any doubt that we'd win this?

 

[froars]

You're comparing apples with apples, big turds with small turds. Anyway you put it, they're both crap. Well, they have been this year. How you can say we had a clear victory here, i don't see it. Or is it trying to keep positive knowing we've got the dud for another four years?

 

[rgauci]

Clear victory would be Fremantle with Heath Black. THough this deal had everything to do with salary cap space. So you can't compare winners/losers purely on players worth.

 

[Goldust]

DIM SIM is awsum hes one of the shortest ruckman and he was still get over 10-15 hitouts a week and kicking 1 or 2 goals around he also kicked alot of points aswell

AS a certain Queenslander once said in reply to Tracey Curro: "Please explain"?

 

[True Thylacine]

AS a certain Queenslander once said in reply to Tracey Curro: "Please explain"?

Allow me...FLEMO is 15yo.......and therefore and obviously still coming to terms with puberty let alone the intricacies of AFL footy...lol On the upside he has chosen the correct team to support which is a good start.

 

[jmf]

Don't get carried away !
Both are rubbish !! Anyway, you got Simmonds in the deal for Ottens.
Let's face it, all 3 are duds ! Except you are stuck with Simmonds for another 4 years !!

 

[CoggaRules]

Don't get carried away !
Both are rubbish !! Anyway, you got Simmonds in the deal for Ottens.
Let's face it, all 3 are duds ! Except you are stuck with Simmonds for another 4 years !!

yeah so coming from the experts how do we handle it? like maybe we can pay him a few hundred k a year to play at Coburg like your braniacs have done huh? LOL. fool, a doggie supprter having a go at the tigers, get real dipstick, we reckon we are hard done by with the lack of success in the last 20 years, god onlyknows how you morons feel.

 

[FLEMO]

Allow me...FLEMO is 15yo.......and therefore and obviously still coming to terms with puberty let alone the intricacies of AFL footy...lol On the upside he has chosen the correct team to support which is a good start.

Oi im 15 in a couple of days and i am over the terms of puberty and i no lots about footy and i no were following the right team and i only wrote that down i was looking for positives not negatives as everyone in here seems to be doing