2009 Trade Discussion - Part 5

[JDWCE]

Need to do this tonight so some help would be appreciated.

Unless you're in a lot of strife, im not sure i would trade hodge

 

[spence]

Contemplating whether or not I should keep Lucas. I'm about 90% sure that he will return next week.

ooooo I wouldn't be so sure.

What's his b/e? If it's over 60 I'd trade him if you had enough for an upgrade.

 

[SM]

Unless you're in a lot of strife, im not sure i would trade hodge

Already have, sick of him dragging me down. Has only scored 80 maximum I think.

Should I trade Ziebell then? Got him and Ablett on the bench and I'm more than happy to wait Ablett out.

 

[Dimitri_Mishkin]

Is Rich/Tuck on your bench?

Nah Im playing both of them ><

Zaha on the bench (dont wanna get rid of him yet, still riding that 97)

 

[Dimitri_Mishkin]

i'd really appreciate some help here, struggling a bit with injuries and form

got hodge and houlihan in the backline, but petrenko and broughton to cover...plus i have more pressing issues

higgins, lucas (and goodwin) in the forward line, with only mitch brown on the bench. Im thinking of going lucas to sidebottom and leaving the rest...or possibly downgrading rich/t.tuck to cockie, then upgrading lucas to delidio.

Already down to 13 trades though o.o

thoughts please?

 

[Bert1]

what are peoples thoughts on Hodge and Houlihan? I need to trade one of them. Which one is more worthwhile keeping onboard? Im leaning more towards holding onto Hodge at the moment.

 

[JDWCE]

Already have, sick of him dragging me down. Has only scored 80 maximum I think.

Should I trade Ziebell then? Got him and Ablett on the bench and I'm more than happy to wait Ablett out.

He scored 100 against eagles, it can be done but i feel your pain

 

[SM]

Soooo Ziebell/Rich/Robinson out? And who do I trade to?

Or do I upgrade J. Riewoldt to Johnson?

 

[magpies03]

Soooo Ziebell/Rich/Robinson out? And who do I trade to?
Or do I upgrade J. Riewoldt to Johnson?

Is rich out?? sorry if im a bit slow but i dont think the brisbane team has been posted in the teams section...

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

Is rich out?? sorry if im a bit slow but i dont think the brisbane team has been posted in the teams section...

No, Rich is in. Isn't he?

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

Mackay-->Dal Santo
or
Mackay-->Murphy

Really can't decide (will probably get Dal) but what do people think?

 

[JDWCE]

he means who to get rid of from his team, and personally i wouldnt get rid of any of them.

Maybe go J volt to Stevie J but wait until tomorro to do it (even though i think young volt will be dropped)

 

[magpies03]

No, Rich is in. Isn't he?

not sure maybe i have just misread stat machines post. itjust said out ziebel rich and robinson

 

[Kid A]

Rich is in the Brisbane team. No outs except Troy Selwood.

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/blog/2009/05/14/eight-is-great/

 

[JDWCE]

Mackay-->Dal Santo
or
Mackay-->Murphy

Really can't decide (will probably get Dal) but what do people think?

I'd say Dal Santo purely because of the form him and the Saints are in right now but Murphy is at a bargain price.. sorry no help there

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Argh = what to do!

Will cop a donut if I don't trade cloke

Can either do cloke to sidebottom and be done with it.

But SJ looks tempting under $400k

I could do otten -> Sidebottom and then cloke -> SJ

however this leaves sidebottom in my mids and i really want him in my forwards!!

what to do - hmmmmm

 

[SM]

he means who to get rid of from his team, and personally i wouldnt get rid of any of them.

Maybe go J volt to Stevie J but wait until tomorro to do it (even though i think young volt will be dropped)

Ah but that'd be too easy! I'm out tomorrow, so I won't know if Robinson makes the final team, which is a problem.

 

[magpies03]

he means who to get rid of from his team, and personally i wouldnt get rid of any of them.

Maybe go J volt to Stevie J but wait until tomorro to do it (even though i think young volt will be dropped)

yeh i think stevie Jis very tempting under 400 however chapman may start to drop after his 70 odd on theweekend.

JDWCE how many rookiesare you playing inyour mid field? I GOT rich and otten....would u get rid ofone of them if u had both playing?

 

[JDWCE]

yeh i think stevie Jis very tempting under 400 however chapman may start to drop after his 70 odd on theweekend.

JDWCE how many rookiesare you playing inyour mid field? I GOT rich and otten....would u get rid ofone of them if u had both playing?

I had both playing until last week and now only have rich playing but i wouldn't worry about them too much

Otten is very consistent and Rich seems to be doing well enough on the field

They could be your last upgrades for the season, unless you're eyeing someone off now like cooney or murphy don't really see the need to trade any of them because most people have bigger concerns in their forward or defence

 

[JDWCE]

Ah but that'd be too easy! I'm out tomorrow, so I won't know if Robinson makes the final team, which is a problem.

Looks like I cant help you then

but do take note that Robinson has been flying in the VFL so try and make a judgement before tomorro

 

[Affidavit]

Hey guys I need some other opinions on what to do this week besides my own. I am in the top 100 and really want to go for the major prize even though it takes a lot of luck.

I am thinking of maybe not trading at all this week but do have 70k in the bank to spend.

Backs:
Cornes, Goddard, Lockyer, Adcock, Houlihan, Hill, Suban (Raines, Broughton)

Mids:
Bartel, Kornes, Corey, Rich, Swan, Gibbs (Hartlett, Cockie)

Fwd:
Chapman, Higgins, Pav, Deledio, Roughead, Ziebell, Nahas (Walker, Brown)

70k in the bank

Option 1: No trade
Option 2: Houlihan>fisher/mackie/enright/gilbert
Option 3: Can't really think of any others lol

 

[magpies03]

I had both playing until last week and now only have rich playing but i wouldn't worry about them too much

Otten is very consistent and Rich seems to be doing well enough on the field

They could be your last upgrades for the season, unless you're eyeing someone off now like cooney or murphy don't really see the need to trade any of them because most people have bigger concerns in their forward or defence

Yeh i agree. Am tempted to trade rich to cokie as he is only goin up up about 4 and 5 grand a week. Otten is still makin decent money but yeh will probably hold on to both ofthem for a week or so and work it out after that

 

[SM]

Looks like I cant help you then

but do take note that Robinson has been flying in the VFL so try and make a judgement before tomorro

Might TRY and get on tomorrow...

 

[Big Kitty]

Backs:
Fisher, Goddard, Newman, Mackie, Hill, Raines, Broughton. Petrenko, Hodge.

Mids:
Swan, Gibbs, Kornes, Otten, Rich, Beams. Zaha, Robinson.

Rucks:
Cox, Kruzer. Jacobs, Browne

Forwards:
Pavlich, Deledio, NGB, Gianciracusa, Higgins, Krakouer, Brown. Walker, Skipworth.

177K in Bank 13 trades left - Freakin Injuries

Heres my little plan

This week: Skippy-->Buddy, Krak-->Brennan (Or Vice Versa) Doesnt leave me with much but barring injury (god forbid) my fwdline is complete.

Some week ahead. Hopefully when Rich & Otten peak downgrade one and upgrade the other...simple enough.

Would like to get Grimes in but i dont think i can atm. Am happy to keep Hill as a 7th back if he keeps pumping out the 75s~

 

[RickSanchez]

St. Johnson for Higgins - I got no forwards that can play if Higgins doesn't
or
T. Lockyer for Hodge - Hodge is 2-4 weeks, not in great form so if i traded him I could get him later assuming he goes down a bit....but I have Broughton who can play yet I'd have a zero for this week. Consider the fact I got Grimes and Suban already starting, add Broughton to the mix and yeah aint the strongest backlines.

Big help needed with that please really appreciate it as well.
Didn't get any replies

as for that j2kboiz guy, I think Enright/Fisher at good prices to get and will be on the rise soon might be time to get.