2009 Trade Discussion - Part 5

[DaVe86]

is anyone else having truoble accessing the site???

I'm getting really worried now. Need to make 2 urgent trades

 

[samwise]

not gonna trade malceski
i think the 80 points i will lose this week from playing cheney instead of trading malceski and playing lockyer isnt worth the extra points i will get from keeping malceski and trading suban next week
a.k.a
suban + about 80 points vs malceski having about 6 weeks to make up the 80 points or exceeed it before being traded..+chance of lockyer getting injured
make sense?

 

[OneEyedHawk]

What do you guys reckon of me going Hodge > Lockyer, then Malceski > Grimes??? Are there any better options??

16 trades left, $61.4k in bank.

B: Cornes, Goddard, Gilbee, Hodge, Malceski, Houlihan, Suban (Broughton & Cheney)
M: Bartel, Gibbs, Kornes, Selwood, Haselby, Rich (Otten & Anthony)
R: Petrie, Tippett (Jacobs & Spencer)
F: Franklin, Pavlich, Deledio, N Brown, Higgins, Krakouer, Ziebell (Walker & Brown)

 

[Eddie19]

hey guys am thinking just 1 trade this week but am not sure if it's worth it i have 15 trades left my backline is currently Cornes,Goddard,Hodge,Houlihan,Adcock,Hill,Suban,Raines,Petrenko
am thinking Hodge to S Fisher because hodge might not be back for a while and if he does he might not do well becuase its a groin. Is it worth trading Hodge or not? considering i have some backup but i do have 2 zeros in fwds this week thoughts cheers

 

[AjsGuns]

its working fine now.
Krak > Deledio
Skipworth > SJ

for me this week

 

[OneEyedHawk]

hey guys am thinking just 1 trade this week but am not sure if it's worth it i have 15 trades left my backline is currently Cornes,Goddard,Hodge,Houlihan,Adcock,Hill,Suban,Raines,Petrenko
am thinking Hodge to S Fisher because hodge might not be back for a while and if he does he might not do well becuase its a groin. Is it worth trading Hodge or not? considering i have some backup but i do have 2 zeros in fwds this week thoughts cheers

Do it, definitely. Don't be surprised if Hodge is gona alot longer than they're predicting. Fisher seems the perfect replacement.

And now for my advice??? (see above post)

 

[samwise]

f**k it
malceski to lockyer

15 trades, 125k, 6 rookies playing

 

[C-Dog]

Tempted now to go Houlihan > Gilbee

 

[Skystyler]

fueled by a desire to stay in the eliminator, I double traded Dempsey & the Eski for Grimes & Gilbert. Dempsey will be lucky to get double digits this week and with the Eski getting dropped I would've had to play Petrenko. Preseason when Grimes went down I tossed up between Dempsey and Gilbert. Went the wrong way, obviously. Although I think the eski might still come good, my eliminator opponent has got the wood on me and I need points this week.

 

[kingyubbo]

Everyon'es getting on SJ, but I reckon this will be the last time this season that you'll be able to get him sub 400k. Might have to jump on :S

 

[Eddie19]

Do it, definitely. Don't be surprised if Hodge is gona alot longer than they're predicting. Fisher seems the perfect replacement.

And now for my advice??? (see above post) cheers for help mate, I think you shud definately do those trades Lockyer is awesome replacement for hodge and Grimes could make big cash or be a keeper there is a injury risk but dw he shud be ok

 

[Mordecai]

Jonothan brown, deledio, ryan okeefe, gainsiracusa...

who represents the best value (scoring/price for the rest of the year)

 

[Barnzy]

Jonothan brown, deledio, ryan okeefe, gainsiracusa...

who represents the best value (scoring/price for the rest of the year)

Deledio / Gia for mine.

 

[C-Dog]

Think I'm going to do Houlihan > Fisher, have been very lucky with injuries and feel as though i can afford this trade. Will only be my 3rd trade.

 

[drd23]

Have 12 trades and 73k in the bank.

Will be doing Houlihan > Broughton.
And Otten > Any mid.

Who represents the best value - Bartell/Corey/Hayes/Montagna/Sewell/Murphy

Would leave my midfield as - Ablett/Gibbs/(Insert new mid)/Morton/K Simpson/Rich with Hartlett and Beams on the bench.

This trade would leave me with 3 more upgrades to do (Hill, Ziebell, Rich)

 

[The_Gunny_Bomber]

Jonothan brown, deledio, ryan okeefe, gainsiracusa...

who represents the best value (scoring/price for the rest of the year)

Brown Dog

 

[Dimitri_Mishkin]

Not sure if this is the thread...but I need a quick opinion.

Should I play Cockie or Zaharakis?

 

[Teh_Nub]

adcock to grimes
lucas to SJ

 

[Saint KFC]

adcock to grimes

Absolute barry of a trade right there.

 

[Mordecai]

Absolute barry of a trade right there.

What would you think of Houlihan to Grimes next week?

 

[Saint KFC]

What would you think of Houlihan to Grimes next week?

Depends on if Houlihan is named and how Grimes goes this week. I think that Adcock is a much better keeper than Houlihan though.

Regardless, I wouldn't be bringing in a midpricer at this stage, unless you intend for Grimes to be a keeper. Personally, I upgraded Houlihan last week to a premium - never really thought of Houlihan as a keeper anyway.

 

[GoNickGill]

the most annoying thing is that houlihan, malceski, ablett, higgins, ziebell, skipworth could all be back next week.
I want to keep hodge but im worried he will be out for an extended period. I also want to get Sidebottom maybe for Wade Thompson.

ffs i dont know.

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

This week,

Thompson - Sidebottom
Malceski - Harding

 

[CuriousObsession]

What do you guys think of these trades next week?

Out: Hodge and Beams
In: Grimes / Raines and Cooney / Better Option

Help would be Greatly Appreciated. (200k and 13 Trades)

 

[Mordecai]

Depends on if Houlihan is named and how Grimes goes this week. I think that Adcock is a much better keeper than Houlihan though.

Regardless, I wouldn't be bringing in a midpricer at this stage, unless you intend for Grimes to be a keeper. Personally, I upgraded Houlihan last week to a premium - never really thought of Houlihan as a keeper anyway.

looking at grimes this week. thinking of getting him as the 7th back and using the cash elsewhere.