Preview 2010 Brownlow Medal

[jefffff34]

It should be said the Chris Judd is a phenomenal leader and one of the best players in the game. So in this sense, he deserved to win.

As shown by his leadership in finals since switching to Carlton.

 

[Sublime]

Judd's votes speaks volumes for the quality of his team mates

This.

If Swan was playing for Carlton in Judd's place, he'd have 40 votes by now.

 

[Pies_10]

Who's playing Saturday ??
We are were not a one man show

 

[nolanr]

Swanny VERY Stiff here, wish judd would wipe that grin off his face


"Could it get any worse! Poor Swanny finishes in 3rd!

 

[aussiedude]

i wonder how the AFL feel about Judd winning, after that MRP stuff wasnt looked at after the elbow.

 

[Ant85]

Switched it off after round 20. Absolute bullshit.

Even when we finish on top, Carlscum find a way to screw us over. Cheating filth.

Brownlow shmownlow.

 

[thatday]

Sooo. I just got a whole bunch more confident about Saturday.

 

[Pie eyed]

Hard to believe really.....
You can see why the AFL had to spend big money and have a mandatory Umpire respect round.

 

[mattys123]

Swan needs to shave his head, lol.

How he didn't get 3 votes against Port is beyond me, 39 disposals, including 16 in the second quarter that turned the game.

 

[footycool]

For the first time in history i fell for collingwood

Swan>Smug ****

 

[jefffff34]

Bench player in the All-Australian side says it all.

 

[Thommo 42]

lets move on boys, Swanny won't care and we have more important events coming up

 

[LifeSpan-Void]

I wouldn't worry about it too much guys, Judd carries Carlton and this is evidenced by the fact that nobody else even got double figures in their votes. In good teams there's always the risk of a Pendlebury or a Selwood stealing those last few from the fancied player. You've got bigger fish to fry now anyway.

 

[Copeland]

MVP more prestigious. To be judged by your peers not friggin umpires.

 

[SOPH_CROSS]

umpires like bald untatooted men

Swans waaaaay better than that

 

[the_fresh]

People don't get too upset about this.
We disagree with the umpires for 364 days of the year, tonight we proved that we are right. They don't understand the game.
The 2 best and only awards that count are the MVP & the coaches award

 

[jefffff34]

I'll be ****ed if I recognise someone that made 122 blatant, unforced errors for the season as the best player in 2010.

 

[Temploar]

Switched it off after round 20. Absolute bullshit.

Even when we finish on top, Carlscum find a way to screw us over. Cheating filth.

Brownlow shmownlow.

You switched your tv off? I threw a bottle at it.

F* the brownlow, i wont even watch it next year.

 

[Markfs]

I do feel a little bad for Dane because he deserves recognition after being overlooked for the last two years... but other than that, its a good outcome for the main game..

 

[ChrisB31]

although I feel Swan was robbed of the brownlow (he had a fantastic season) it is nothing compared to the medal he is going to get next week. perhaps he will get two.

His peers have judged him the MVP of 2010 already.

Go Pies!

 

[2009premiers]

I haven't been as annoyed with a Brownlow result since Graeme Wright was robbed by Tony Liberatore in 1990....................

 

[didaktic]

Hey guys.
The problem we had was that too many different players got votes.
(we had the most individual vote scorers)
I'd rather have 18 vote getters and a premiership.

 

[danielnajdek]

I know it doesn't matter that much compared to a Premiership but **** Judd didn't deserve it one bit. Ed was seriously pissed off

 

[absy]

Yeah wouldn't be as pissed if Ablett or somebody more deserving actually won it, everyone saying we had more people to take votes off us etc is true but there were so many more deserving players then that dudd.

 

[TheWoodsOf72]

I can understand Ed being pissed. It seems that only Pin-up boys get a better run. Judd didn't expect it and really wasn't even excited about winning. He's surrounded but crap and gets the points when they win. Last years eye gouge and this years elbow in the face are overlooked when you're special.